Record SCC placement evidence and bounded transfer correction
This commit is contained in:
@@ -546,3 +546,32 @@ compatibility as a necessary placement constraint in a future initial coordinate
|
||||
assignment with connection ordering and corridor/label space. Compound geometry,
|
||||
automatic side changes and native tracing remain separate required evidence.
|
||||
This is branch-specific experimental evidence, not an integrated capability.
|
||||
|
||||
## Keep cyclic groups coherent before assigning global ranks — 2026-09-25
|
||||
|
||||
The [SCC placement experiment](experiments/scc-placement-20260925/results.md)
|
||||
at `2426d286` supports condensation of sibling-subtree cycles as a useful
|
||||
structural step. Independent reconstruction finds four ten-node components in
|
||||
the sparse case. Compact blocks remove the old layered prototype's shared top
|
||||
corridor: raw pairwise sharing falls from 40,522 to 32, with fewer crossings and
|
||||
less area than that prototype. The released router is unchanged. The full
|
||||
comparison includes original and Arrange-reset controls; this is not a universal
|
||||
improvement across all measures or scenes.
|
||||
|
||||
Preserve effective geometry at the placement-transfer boundary. An old
|
||||
projected size can depend on children that subsequently move inward; retaining
|
||||
the old authored size then loses an explicitly requested minimum. The corrected
|
||||
example importer makes one conditional simultaneous minimum restoration and
|
||||
still demands exact final projection. All 14 frozen cases now complete; the
|
||||
13 prior successful outputs remain exactly unchanged, with conservation,
|
||||
roundtrip and ten-call checks recorded. This is an experimental transfer
|
||||
contract, not a production command or history integration.
|
||||
|
||||
Do not adopt the whole candidate yet. The two-container case still ignores
|
||||
external-neighbor order within each parent and is worse than the old layered
|
||||
zero-sharing witness. Sparse residual label conflicts, folded route retracing,
|
||||
bipartite sharing and area tradeoffs remain distinct issues. The next bounded
|
||||
comparison should preserve coherent SCC ranks while using actual cross-boundary
|
||||
neighbors to order siblings. Treat label association separately from route
|
||||
sharing, preserve the full quality vector, and retain native tracing as a later
|
||||
acceptance gate. No global gap or routing-penalty sweep follows from this result.
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user