3.5 KiB
Independent v2 control readback
PASS: one unchanged positive and all fourteen declared negatives reached their intended outcomes. This was a read-only review of completed evidence, not another verifier/control run. No subject code, compiler or GUI was executed. Only this review file was added.
All 15 per-case result JSONs equal their summary rows; all 30 raw stdout/stderr files match their recorded SHA256. All six original package files still match the frozen package pins. Commands identify the reviewed verifier, the intended repository and either the original positive package or a transient negative package beneath this controls directory.
The positive exited 0 with empty stderr. Its parsed output retains source aaec78fcc9b273d1485497126392afdd1fb2e54e, runtime source 71cadfa0cd0e112caa29588d2494753301f3cb6c, listing 209, Project 13/admission 2/four integration passes, and strict PASS at the runtime source. Crucially, the full suite remains FAILED: 193 passed/16 failed, and successor formatting remains FAILED with eight inherited blocks. Prior statuses/diagnostics are reported preserved; successor_runtime_claim is false. This is private Project evidence, with no public source8 success, GUI completion or prerelease-production acceptance implied.
Each negative exited 1 with empty stdout and exactly one REFUSED: stderr line. Observed boundaries:
| Case | Exact refusal after REFUSED: |
|---|---|
| archive-pin | Top-level archive pin differs |
| verifier-pin | Top-level verifier pin differs |
| route-pair-artifact | Repeated integration target artifact differs |
| source-pair-artifact | Repeated integration target artifact differs |
| missing-new-outcome | Missing/extra runtime outcomes |
| changed-inherited-diagnostic | Exact historical failure diagnostics changed |
| forged-git-input | Git input bytes mismatch: Cargo.lock |
| missing-failed-history | Missing/extra package payload |
| integration-zero-test | Missing/extra runtime outcomes |
| integration-ignored | Runtime status mismatch |
| integration-wrong-command | Exact command/mode/filter differs |
| changed-formatter-body | Inherited formatter block body differs |
| changed-successor-diff | Exact Git correction diff differs |
| duplicate-zip-member | Duplicate ZIP members |
The semantic cases therefore reached their declared checks, not an incidental stale transport hash. The two top-level pin cases intentionally retained incorrect pins. The reviewed driver refreshes inner receipt/outcome and outer payload/archive bindings for the other cases; raw outcomes agree with that design. Mutated archives were transient and are not retained, so this readback reviews recorded execution plus the frozen mutation code rather than independently reconstructing each mutant.
Reviewed anchors:
summary.json: SHA256c39e52c220b0b023382d70ed4344597cf3596e741ca67995fb67edf8e9aa20c8.- Verifier: 23,199 bytes, SHA256
f94e5f4a733c82c0b240dc4c64557bf34f6705590144df686ccfbc53c076b6ff. - Control driver: 11,834 bytes, SHA256
0d2cd38c7baffba78cd2f009d832c7a16e9ac46437d56105a484821ce54601e7. - ZIP: 490,311 bytes, SHA256
a42f29c9adc05adc6bd0c881b716bda3bd098732eb081b0f6214252db5d29d83. - Manifest: 9,112 bytes, SHA256
9277764168157819faaddaa8dffd2714efe995e2e136c795a51cc10340cd2f50.
No unexpected refusal, timeout, changed original package pin or contradictory positive result was found. The result establishes this finite consistency-control set; it does not authenticate historical execution or turn retained failures into passes.