Preserved independent review records
reviews.zip contains six exact historical Markdown records,
pinned by members.json. Their original context was
.local/allocation-group-design/ in the reviewed checkout. Relative links and
line references inside this historical archive retain that context and reviewed
source version; they are not links to an installed peer workspace.
| Record | Scope |
|---|---|
| critique.md | Initial combined assignment/Arrange proposal criticism |
| fresh-policy-critique.md | Independent policy alternatives and falsifiers |
| experiment/v2-review.md | Four-family experiment; SA port sizing oracle defect |
| selection-boundary.md | Exact typed App selection versus pure placement API |
| input-boundaries.md | Pending click, irreversible threshold and input integration obligations |
| arrange-planner-review.md | Fresh pure-planner review plus R1/R2 test-disposition addendum |
The accepted contract and result report are authoritative for current decisions and acceptance. Historical recommendations or proposed APIs inside the archive do not supersede them. Root verified reported execution separately; review authors did not independently run Cargo or native workflows.
The report records remaining P3 coverage suggestions and App/native gaps. The archive preserves earlier findings even when the dated addendum addresses them. files.json pins this index, the archive and its member map.