Files
ARCADIA-Studio/harness/allocation-arrange-evidence-20260923/reviews

Preserved independent review records

reviews.zip contains six exact historical Markdown records, pinned by members.json. Their original context was .local/allocation-group-design/ in the reviewed checkout. Relative links and line references inside this historical archive retain that context and reviewed source version; they are not links to an installed peer workspace.

Record Scope
critique.md Initial combined assignment/Arrange proposal criticism
fresh-policy-critique.md Independent policy alternatives and falsifiers
experiment/v2-review.md Four-family experiment; SA port sizing oracle defect
selection-boundary.md Exact typed App selection versus pure placement API
input-boundaries.md Pending click, irreversible threshold and input integration obligations
arrange-planner-review.md Fresh pure-planner review plus R1/R2 test-disposition addendum

The accepted contract and result report are authoritative for current decisions and acceptance. Historical recommendations or proposed APIs inside the archive do not supersede them. Root verified reported execution separately; review authors did not independently run Cargo or native workflows.

The report records remaining P3 coverage suggestions and App/native gaps. The archive preserves earlier findings even when the dated addendum addresses them. files.json pins this index, the archive and its member map.