3.4 KiB
Final removal report evidence audit
Reviewed harness/scenario-group-removal-app-20260925.md against source 43340b94a13f192c3b5d3c3112dbe87246790a44, the eleven raw removal gate result/source-proof records, relevant raw test summaries, current CLI preflight, both native process completion receipts, fixture manifest, six actual saved source snapshots and parent native observation notes.
Finding: no blocking unsupported implementation/validation claim, count/source mismatch or contradiction identified within this audit's scope.
- The five final gates identify source43340 and input-map SHA256
839b041088be0638c55cdcc4da18d6cf9b69eecee3c00d48734759166ed06a0f; all record exit0, unchanged823 inputs and exact Git-blob proof PASS. Raw final summaries match333/0/1/1296filtered and53/0/0/1577filtered. Eleven attempts and three retained failures are correct. The earlier scenario331/2/1 result and four-source history match the records. Filters are explicitly overlapping rather than summed. - Source contains ten planner and eight App test functions as reported. The boxed-snapshot-only final delta preserves the captured snapshot and admission semantics. The single visibility enumeration fix is present. Full-set transaction, model/source Undo versus transient selection, stale-token refusal and explicit review confirmation descriptions agree with the inspected source.
- Build receipt agrees with the reported120,067,072-byte GUI hash. Current CLI preflight identifies source43340 and successful checks of both fixtures, with the stated libunwind pin. Both process completion receipts record exit0, empty logs and unchanged immutable inputs.
- Independently rehashed all six actual snapshot files: baseline/cancel/Undo are4389 bytes with the reported70c32355… hash; removed/Redo/reopened are3856 bytes with the reported1cb04cba… hash. Counts2removed/10updated and the12-record impact agree with the predeclared manifest and parent observation notes. Compact capture dimensions1102×732 agree with those notes and are correctly described as capture dimensions.
- The report explicitly distinguishes mounted Delete/Shift+Delete routing from the unsuccessful native Delete attempt at capture35. Native additive selection is contextual rather than Shift-click. Keyboard-only confirmation, broad accessibility, long-alias stress, native SA/Fragment/reuse, Linux and full-suite acceptance remain excluded. A real App source-write-failure execution remains an explicit runtime gap; static atomicity is not substituted for it.
- Input and capture recovery failures remain described, and fresh reopen is expressly limited to source persistence. No default-branch integration, release or full issue29 closure is asserted.
Independence limits: this reviewer authored the removal panel and previously reviewed the adapter/planner; panel source observations are self-review, not independent UI acceptance. No screenshots were interpreted in this audit: independent original-image review belongs to Herschel. ZIP completeness/offline verification belongs to Godel; the evidence README/package links were still being finalized when inspected, so this audit is not a package-verification claim. The peripheral Windows networking/WSL DNS paragraph is parent operational reporting and was not independently re-executed here. No tests, builds, GUI interactions, Git writes or production edits were performed; only this report was written.