sorokin.oleg.edu/learnharness
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases 6 Wiki Activity

verdicts-only auditor: submit_review is {links, bridging edges} — the findings echo dies

Browse Source 
Owner ruling 2026-09-28: the auditor has no control over the
extractor's output and never alters it, so re-emitting the full
findings per submit was pure payload cost — the retry collapse the
schema slim attacked, halved again. submit_review is now links
(local proposition id -> existing graph node; EQUIVALENCE BIAS
carried in the linkTo description) + bridging edges ONLY; the
merger joins extractor findings + verdicts.

mergeFindings(chatId, findings, verdicts, ...) — propositions come
from findings verbatim, links join by id, edges emit extractor's
then auditor's through one dedup-preserving emitter. The old echo
form hid an accidental drop channel: an auditor that omitted a
proposition from its echo silently dropped it from the merge.
Verdicts-only removes it structurally — extractor output always
fully merges (tests updated to full-merge expectations).

AuditResult/AuditedProposition -> IdentityLink/AuditVerdicts;
audit() logs links/bridges; batch view renders anchorless like
transcriptView; auditor prompt rewritten to the verdicts-only
deliverable; architecture.md division-of-trust updated.
This commit is contained in:
amosblomqvist
2026-09-28 19:22:58 +03:00
parent bd9694b0e4
commit f11b1664dc
6 changed files with 163 additions and 142 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files
src/core/contracts/graph.ts
+20 -16
View File
@@ -229,24 +229,28 @@ export interface SessionFindings {
edges: ExtractedEdge[];
}
/** The auditor's verdict on one proposition: the findings, plus `linkTo` —
* the identity judgment. Absent = create a new node. */
export interface AuditedProposition extends ExtractedProposition {
/** The existing GraphNode id this proposition IS — the auditor's
* identity verdict. On link, the session's phrasings (statement,
* aliases) join the node's aliases and the provenance unions.
* EQUIVALENCE BIAS (2026-09-27): paraphrases, rewordings, and
* compressions of the same claim MERGE — do not create a duplicate
* because the wording differs. Only genuinely distinct propositions
* stay apart. */
linkTo?: string;
/** One identity verdict: the extractor's local proposition id → the
* EXISTING graph node that proposition IS. On link, the session's
* phrasings (statement, aliases) join the node's aliases and the
* provenance unions. EQUIVALENCE BIAS (2026-09-27): paraphrases,
* rewordings, and compressions of the same claim MERGE — do not create
* a duplicate because the wording differs. Only genuinely distinct
* propositions stay apart. */
export interface IdentityLink {
id: string;
linkTo: string;
}
/** The auditor's output: the findings with identity verdicts, plus any
* bridging edges drawn to existing graph nodes. No drop channel — the
* auditor never rejects; the extractor is fully trusted (2026-09-27). */
export interface AuditResult {
propositions: AuditedProposition[];
/** The auditor's output — VERDICTS ONLY (owner, 2026-09-28): the auditor
* never alters the extractor's findings, so it does not restate them;
* the deterministic merger joins findings + verdicts. `links` = the
* identity verdicts (local id ⇄ existing node); `edges` = BRIDGING
* edges the auditor draws from existing graph nodes to the batch's
* propositions (endpoints: existing node ids and/or local proposition
* ids). No drop channel — the auditor never rejects; the extractor is
* fully trusted (2026-09-27). */
export interface AuditVerdicts {
links: IdentityLink[];
edges: ExtractedEdge[];
}