Record lifecycle integration gates and independent native paint review

2026-09-12 17:20:31 -07:00
parent aadc6396d3
commit 26ca4a4c81
14 changed files with 8332 additions and 0 deletions
@@ -98,6 +98,12 @@ failures, reviews and validated bound OA/SA evaluator fixtures. Complete direct
 manipulation, persistent process placement/lanes and coherent peer integration
 remain open. Gitea owns live coordination.

+Source **aadc6396d39ff336d05381d58d545093d3f37a73** integrates reviewed lifecycle
+rendering with typed activations. Its 36 lifecycle, 14 activation and one atomic
+Call/Reply tests pass on 536 unchanged inputs, including rendered border continuity.
+These 51 targeted checks do not establish full-suite or native acceptance for the
+combined source. [Integration evidence](release-lifecycle-activation-union-20260913.md).
+
 [Native follow-up evidence](release-canvas-native-83f53c7-20260912.md) records
 the normally closed source83 trial, observed defect, minimum-size layout and
 the boundary between state and scenario keyboard policies.
@@ -0,0 +1,21 @@
+    Finished `test` profile [unoptimized] target(s) in 7.05s
+     Running unittests src\main.rs (target\debug\deps\arcadia_studio-e358a5ed59b1de41.exe)
+
+running 14 tests
+test behavior::scenario_activation::tests::a_fragment_cannot_make_crossed_calls_an_unambiguous_caller_execution ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_activation::tests::activation_shoulders_under_label_backplates_select_their_call ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_activation::tests::actual_canvas_pointer_selects_each_exposed_shoulder_under_zoom_and_pan ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_activation::tests::alternative_and_parallel_operand_local_calls_do_not_nest_from_screen_order ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_activation::tests::an_inactive_self_call_has_no_fabricated_parent_and_three_nested_calls_expose_three_columns ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_activation::tests::call_uuid_order_does_not_choose_activation_columns_or_message_anchors ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_activation::tests::inherited_execution_anchors_a_self_call_inside_an_operand_before_returning_after_the_fragment ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_activation::tests::long_message_backplates_do_not_erase_selected_activation_border_pixels ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_activation::tests::missing_reply_is_a_short_explicit_open_span_and_an_uncorrelated_reply_closes_nothing ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_activation::tests::nested_calls_expose_both_bars_and_end_at_their_exact_replies_in_both_directions ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_activation::tests::nested_correlations_returning_in_alternative_operands_remain_nested_before_the_fragment ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_activation::tests::reentrant_call_uses_the_other_receiver_without_inventing_a_caller_execution ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_activation::tests::self_call_receives_at_lower_loop_end_and_self_reply_returns_to_the_parent ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_activation::tests::sequential_calls_reuse_column_and_crossed_replies_keep_their_correlations ... ok
+
+test result: ok. 14 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 848 filtered out; finished in 4.80s
+
@@ -0,0 +1,20 @@
+{
+  "source": "aadc6396d39ff336d05381d58d545093d3f37a73",
+  "start": "2026-09-13T00:10:36.029521+00:00",
+  "end": "2026-09-13T00:10:50.675505+00:00",
+  "exit": 0,
+  "command": [
+    "cargo",
+    "test",
+    "--locked",
+    "-p",
+    "oa-desktop",
+    "--bin",
+    "arcadia-studio",
+    "scenario_activation",
+    "--",
+    "--test-threads=1"
+  ],
+  "inputs": "activation-aadc639.inputs.json",
+  "changed_inputs": []
+}
@@ -318,5 +318,50 @@
    "file": "gui-d61f1f3.result.json",
    "bytes": 351,
    "sha256": "244535cd3032d71b9755ccd97c1102c7f0da3c9d64f8ceea6836271870bff771"
+  },
+  {
+    "file": "lifecycle-aadc639.log",
+    "bytes": 5054,
+    "sha256": "3a9c80e3b875c6b41612851666a0cececddf0ec127e3109bb10b921492257992"
+  },
+  {
+    "file": "lifecycle-aadc639.inputs.json",
+    "bytes": 99902,
+    "sha256": "a03c6f7c5a700fbce64a4808f81bd118f689cc9a5ebb377b921a98f5b58ce8ec"
+  },
+  {
+    "file": "lifecycle-aadc639.result.json",
+    "bytes": 416,
+    "sha256": "c9df3f204e76568b1acb66d7b52603a5895d39075e7ea5e8ff7683cba1ac32b7"
+  },
+  {
+    "file": "activation-aadc639.log",
+    "bytes": 2049,
+    "sha256": "28676a070d25276e9b7967f71d28785d6575f85e1ca97bf7e4f9eae86231a26c"
+  },
+  {
+    "file": "activation-aadc639.inputs.json",
+    "bytes": 99902,
+    "sha256": "a03c6f7c5a700fbce64a4808f81bd118f689cc9a5ebb377b921a98f5b58ce8ec"
+  },
+  {
+    "file": "activation-aadc639.result.json",
+    "bytes": 418,
+    "sha256": "e4288793fd618be5c4abe237af14f945dfac65ec9138e6c3792013b0b70a8261"
+  },
+  {
+    "file": "atomic-aadc639.log",
+    "bytes": 369,
+    "sha256": "ff6773e979dc35152db446df377f27686b87a416cff17f1cc6e5e10bfc873dce"
+  },
+  {
+    "file": "atomic-aadc639.inputs.json",
+    "bytes": 99902,
+    "sha256": "a03c6f7c5a700fbce64a4808f81bd118f689cc9a5ebb377b921a98f5b58ce8ec"
+  },
+  {
+    "file": "atomic-aadc639.result.json",
+    "bytes": 458,
+    "sha256": "26e1cf5e541947055d9c62cca4b71ac1cf102ac9b73eab3ff7f597ab38a813a3"
  }
 ]
@@ -0,0 +1,8 @@
+    Finished `test` profile [unoptimized] target(s) in 4.98s
+     Running unittests src\main.rs (target\debug\deps\arcadia_studio-e358a5ed59b1de41.exe)
+
+running 1 test
+test behavior::scenario::tests::graphical_call_reply_is_atomic_correlated_and_source_equivalent ... ok
+
+test result: ok. 1 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 861 filtered out; finished in 0.49s
+
@@ -0,0 +1,20 @@
+{
+  "source": "aadc6396d39ff336d05381d58d545093d3f37a73",
+  "start": "2026-09-13T00:11:16.140390+00:00",
+  "end": "2026-09-13T00:11:23.831450+00:00",
+  "exit": 0,
+  "command": [
+    "cargo",
+    "test",
+    "--locked",
+    "-p",
+    "oa-desktop",
+    "--bin",
+    "arcadia-studio",
+    "graphical_call_reply_is_atomic_correlated_and_source_equivalent",
+    "--",
+    "--test-threads=1"
+  ],
+  "inputs": "atomic-aadc639.inputs.json",
+  "changed_inputs": []
+}
@@ -0,0 +1,44 @@
+   Compiling oa-desktop v0.2.0 (C:\Users\User\Documents\Git\ARCADIA-Studio\crates\oa-desktop)
+    Finished `test` profile [unoptimized] target(s) in 12m 21s
+     Running unittests src\main.rs (target\debug\deps\arcadia_studio-e358a5ed59b1de41.exe)
+
+running 36 tests
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::birth_label_clip_keeps_padded_world_bounds_at_each_scene_scale ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::birth_label_clip_preserves_parent_viewport_bounds ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::box_text_clip_intersects_parent_viewport_and_rejects_empty_interiors ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::panned_header_and_create_clips_use_screen_translation_and_actual_viewport ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::real_scene_birth_death_markers_align_endpoints_and_win_selection_without_mutating_source ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::real_scene_branch_delete_clips_only_its_activation_and_keeps_unanswered_call_visible ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::real_scene_conditional_repeated_and_parallel_scopes_do_not_claim_definite_continuation ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::real_scene_empty_and_create_only_use_visible_root_extents_not_insertion_bounds ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::real_scene_lifecycle_edit_undo_redo_restores_exact_source_and_changed_geometry ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::real_scene_long_header_title_and_detail_keep_names_and_have_bounded_clips ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::real_scene_minimum_zoom_marker_halos_do_not_steal_adjacent_capsule_or_header_hits ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::real_scene_minimum_zoom_near_ordinary_message_wins_over_lifecycle_halos ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::real_scene_panned_zoomed_program_keeps_header_birth_and_death_hit_identity ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::real_scene_self_delete_caption_clears_the_preceding_action_box ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::real_scene_self_lifecycle_elbows_end_on_recorded_marker_rows ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::real_scene_unassigned_lanes_and_explicit_incomplete_receiver_keep_real_marker_identity ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::real_scene_wide_latin_header_exceeds_old_character_budget ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::union_tests::admitted_calls_without_sender_polylines_still_have_logical_correlation_metadata ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::union_tests::admitted_death_and_incomplete_later_reply_do_not_fabricate_an_answered_execution ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::union_tests::admitted_delayed_create_nested_calls_replies_delete_share_one_geometry_pipeline ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::union_tests::admitted_self_lifecycle_and_self_call_keep_distinct_send_receive_rows ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::union_tests::admitted_unresolved_operand_keeps_unanswered_cue_without_any_visible_segment ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::union_tests::clipped_operand_preserves_original_nested_or_crossed_correlation_distinction ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::union_tests::conditional_death_then_recreate_never_revives_call_but_keeps_open_sibling ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::union_tests::invalid_prebirth_call_and_postdeath_reply_remain_rejected_with_defensive_scene_clipping ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::render::tests::union_tests::test_only_upstream_row_offsets_update_lifetime_segments_and_endpoints_without_authoring ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::tests::alternative_death_does_not_kill_its_displayed_sibling ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::tests::conditional_birth_does_not_infer_absence_in_siblings_or_ancestors ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::tests::explicit_receiver_is_authoritative_even_with_missing_exchange ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::tests::lifecycle_free_fragments_do_not_poison_other_lanes ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::tests::loop_lifetime_is_local_and_warning_bearing_loops_remain_drawable ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::tests::missing_geometry_is_reported_without_nonfinite_or_guessed_markers ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::tests::optional_cleanup_inside_loop_does_not_claim_balanced_or_definite_exit ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::tests::projection_retains_exact_authored_source_and_does_not_enter_history ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::tests::root_lifetime_has_exact_birth_death_boundaries_without_source_mutation ... ok
+test behavior::scenario_lifecycle::tests::scenario_use_is_opaque_and_never_imports_callee_lifecycle_events ... ok
+
+test result: ok. 36 passed; 0 failed; 0 ignored; 0 measured; 826 filtered out; finished in 3.43s
+
@@ -0,0 +1,20 @@
+{
+  "source": "aadc6396d39ff336d05381d58d545093d3f37a73",
+  "start": "2026-09-12T23:56:54.823261+00:00",
+  "end": "2026-09-13T00:09:22.399674+00:00",
+  "exit": 0,
+  "command": [
+    "cargo",
+    "test",
+    "--locked",
+    "-p",
+    "oa-desktop",
+    "--bin",
+    "arcadia-studio",
+    "scenario_lifecycle",
+    "--",
+    "--test-threads=1"
+  ],
+  "inputs": "lifecycle-aadc639.inputs.json",
+  "changed_inputs": []
+}
@@ -16,6 +16,13 @@ disposable fixture copies. Its actual process exited normally with code 0.
 [Native manifest, screenshots and source checkpoints](experiments/canvas-native-d61f1f3-20260912/manifest.json)
 retain launch/closure records and the exact staged-build identity.

+A [fresh independent native-evidence review](release-canvas-native-d61f1f3-independent-review-20260912.md)
+finds no actionable issue within this scope. It verifies all 43 archived payload
+hashes and complete saved fixture bytes, and independently checks visible
+Inspector identities. Its same-coordinate pixel discriminator finds zero missing
+border rows in each repaired band versus all 21 missing rows per band in the old
+source83 negative control. This does not extend acceptance to other renderers.
+
 ## Observed behavior

 - In bound OA nested C1/C2/R2/R1, clicks at the formerly covered outer shoulder
@@ -0,0 +1,39 @@
+# Independent review of closed d61 native paint evidence
+
+Reviewed `harness/release-canvas-native-d61f1f3-20260912.md` and the original archive at `harness/experiments/canvas-native-d61f1f3-20260912/`. Scope: the closed Windows trial of `d61f1f38779ab70a77efcde523ae31c432aefcfd`, activation-border continuity, selected identities, minimum-window evidence and claim boundaries. No app input, compiler/test execution, Gitea mutation or tracked edits. This report is the only new review artifact.
+
+**Bounded conclusion: no actionable finding against the reported paint correction or its stated scope.** The archived original images independently show the former erased border bands repaired, and the Inspector states agree with the claimed call/reply selections. This is evidence for this particular correction and fixture, not the later lifecycle union, palette acceptance or complete application acceptance.
+
+## Identity and preservation evidence
+
+Read manifest, launch, closure, stage manifest, both checkpoint records/logs, fixture identities and launcher/checkpoint procedures. Independently recomputed **all 43 payload sizes and SHA256 hashes**, with no discrepancy. Independently compared complete bytes of all four baseline/preflight/final-Save files; all three copies match for each file.
+
+Launch identifies source d61, PID 10792 and executable SHA256 `c990fa05772c60666ecf96ab808e6140e57542ad448ddd092b977be0b587136f`. The staged manifest agrees and records executable size 113,939,456. Closure refers to the same PID, exit 0, 23:51:20 UTC, after launch at 23:46:20. The launch procedure checks staged artifacts and same-source full/Clippy/GUI results before launching under a private profile. All three archived stage results identify d61, exit 0, and no changed inputs. I did not rerun those gates or the native executable.
+
+The final checkpoint at 23:51:02 precedes closure. Its identified oracle returns `PASS same: complete Project and exact SourceBundle restored`; retained warnings are two explicitly reported `unallocated_leaf` completeness warnings, not errors. The checkpoint's oracle identity is correctly separated from the native executable's source. The final `bound-saved-0.png` says “All source files saved.” These results support the documented preservation outcome. The root's recorded input sequence supplies the Ctrl+S/click actions; static screenshots independently establish visible result states, not the entire input history.
+
+## Visual findings checked against original images
+
+| Witness | Independent visible result |
+|---|---|
+| `oa-outer-former-label-shoulder-0.png`, `oa-outer-r2-label-shoulder-0.png`, `oa-outer-r1-label-shoulder-0.png` | OA nested scenario; C1 selected in tree and Inspector, name C1 420 kPa, alias `bound_1040`. The outer left border is continuous through the C2, R2 and R1 label bands; the inner execution still occupies its distinct offset interval. |
+| `oa-c2-exact-receive-endpoint-0.png` | C2 380 kPa, alias `bound_1030`; inner execution and C2 line highlighted. |
+| `oa-r2-exact-send-endpoint-0.png`, `oa-r1-exact-send-endpoint-0.png` | R2 378 kPa `bound_1060` and R1 418 kPa `bound_1050`, respectively; selected dashed reply visible. These endpoints did not result in the outer C1 Inspector state. |
+| `oa-reentrant-outer-label-shoulder-0.png`, `oa-reentrant-inner-0.png` | OA reentrant outer C1 `bound_3040` and left inner C2 `bound_3030`; reverse paths and both respective execution outlines remain visible. |
+| `sa-outer-former-label-shoulder-0.png`, `sa-r2-exact-send-endpoint-0.png` | SA nested outer C1 `bound_2040` versus R2 `bound_2060`; repaired outer border and separate inner execution are visible. |
+| `sa-minimum-100-0.png` | Actual image size 1102×732, scale display 100%; right participant header partly clipped. The release note acknowledges this rather than claiming all content fits. |
+| `sa-minimum-fit-0.png`, `sa-minimum-fit-outer-shoulder-0.png`, `bound-saved-0.png` | Same outer dimensions, toolbar displays 66%. Fit restores the header within the canvas. Shoulder-selected and saved states show C1 `bound_2040`, with a continuous outer border. Small text/unselected outlines remain faint. |
+
+Arrowheads and text remain visible in these witnesses. Cursor/blue pointer halo covers a small local area in individual screenshots, so multiple selected-outer witnesses were used to inspect the same border bands away from the pointer. I did not infer concealed pixels from a single cursor-covered endpoint.
+
+## Discriminating read-only pixel cross-check
+
+After visual inspection, read pixels from original PNGs with Pillow without modifying or generating screenshots. In the two d61 OA selected-outer images `oa-outer-former-label-shoulder-0.png` and `oa-outer-r1-label-shoulder-0.png`, checked each row in y=432…452, 524…544, and 616…636 at x=661…664. A row counts as having the teal border when any pixel satisfies `R < 85`, `70 < G < 180`, `G > R + 35`, and `B > R + 25`.
+
+Both d61 images have **zero missing rows in all three 21-row bands**. For a negative control, inspected the original 83 image `harness/experiments/canvas-native-83f53c7-20260912/evidence/oa-outer-activation-selected-0.png`: same 1442×932 dimensions, same nested fixture and `bound_1040` selection. That image visibly has gaps and the same read-only scan reports **21 missing rows in each band**. The discriminator therefore detects the original defect rather than accepting a generic selected border elsewhere. The scan is narrowly coordinate/fixture/palette-specific, not a general renderer acceptance test or a monitor contrast measurement.
+
+## Scope assessment
+
+The release note is appropriately bounded: it does not convert the same-source automated gates into native evidence for unexercised workflows. It explicitly excludes a new self-call/ALT/PAR/lifecycle-marker result, architecture/state Save/Undo repetition, palette correction, lowest-zoom readability, complete OA/SA release acceptance and Linux. Its minimum-window clipping/66% faintness statements agree with the images.
+
+The evidence supports retaining the stated d61 native paint acceptance. f659 introduces additional lifecycle markers, lane rendering and header clipping and still needs its own combined gates/native witnesses. Issue #26 remains open on the demonstrated faint unselected geometry and small text; this review did not test a new palette.
@@ -0,0 +1,47 @@
+# Lifecycle and typed activation integration
+
+Source **aadc6396d39ff336d05381d58d545093d3f37a73** integrates the reviewed
+f6595eb contribution without changing its six source files. It combines the
+published lifeline lifecycle rendering with typed nested activation bars and the
+independently verified d61 label-paint correction. This is an integration
+checkpoint, not combined release or native acceptance.
+
+[Exact source, implementation contract and independent review](experiments/nested-lifecycle-union-20260912/README.md)
+distinguish logical call/reply correlation from visible fragments clipped to the
+receiver's lifetime and scope. Delete terminates an unanswered execution; clipping
+cannot invent a Reply endpoint. Conditional death retains sibling uncertainty
+without reviving the old execution after a later Create. Fully bound invalid
+post-death/recreation fixtures remain rejected by core admission; defensive raw
+Scene checks do not turn them into admitted authoring workflows.
+
+## Executed Windows checks
+
+All three gates use **536 unchanged committed inputs**, input-manifest SHA-256
+`a03c6f7c5a700fbce64a4808f81bd118f689cc9a5ebb377b921a98f5b58ce8ec`:
+
+| Gate | Result | Closed UTC, 2026-09-13 |
+| --- | --- | --- |
+| `scenario_lifecycle` | 36 passed, 0 failed/ignored | 00:09:22 |
+| `scenario_activation` | 14 passed, 0 failed/ignored | 00:10:50 |
+| `graphical_call_reply_is_atomic_correlated_and_source_equivalent` | 1 passed, 0 failed/ignored | 00:11:23 |
+
+The lifecycle scope includes all 17 retained renderer tests, nine combined tests
+and ten lifecycle projection tests. It compiled in 12m21s and ran in 3.43s. The
+activation scope includes the real WGPU border-continuity test and actual
+pointer/shoulder identity tests; it ran in 4.80s. The atomic authoring test retains
+exact source and Undo checks and ran in 0.49s. These are **51 distinct targeted
+tests**, not a full-suite result. The executable reports 862 total tests before
+any palette additions.
+
+[Archived commands, logs and input manifests](experiments/diagram-removal-windows-20260912/archive-manifest.json)
+retain each result separately. The earlier d61 full/strict/GUI/native results do
+not establish this source's full or native acceptance.
+
+## Remaining verification
+
+The final combined source still needs full desktop and strict lint checks,
+a matching staged GUI, and native lifetime/activation acceptance. Native cases
+include delayed Create→nested Call/Reply→Delete, self-event clearance, long
+Latin/Unicode headers and birth capsules under pan/zoom, incomplete replies,
+and unresolved operands. The separate palette candidate must retain these
+geometry and selection invariants when combined. Linux remains user-deferred.