42 lines
6.4 KiB
Markdown
42 lines
6.4 KiB
Markdown
# Independent actual-output acceptance runtime review
|
|
|
|
Final source `edf096cd33350865ecfc3c65ec266a6c0d3c4000` satisfies the selected finite regression readback after one explicitly approved target-path spelling exception. All16 inherited failure bodies remain byte-identical after replacing numeric thread identifiers only; no failure-body exception exists. Full core tests still have16 failures and workspace format still exits1. No compiler, test executable, debugger or archived launcher was executed by this reviewer.
|
|
|
|
## Gates and bindings
|
|
|
|
Prepared read-only checker was run using bundled Python `-I -B`, args `edf096cd33350865ecfc3c65ec266a6c0d3c4000 edf096c 11`. Original strict helper refused exact environment comparison; CHECKER-NOTE.md preserves the refusal and original helper. Amended helper SHA256 `8fdf8c0ba848d8f61cb09739961239c316fdb0eb17e4b64b88ae34274cce0f53` then completed all checks and exclusively wrote ACCEPTANCE-RUNTIME-READBACK.json.
|
|
|
|
Readback JSON SHA256 `88cb21bc89a1337b32f74ec2fe8adc6dc2835ccea17bb313b5a7e2433fce4fd2`.
|
|
|
|
| Gate | Exit | Actual result |
|
|
| --- | ---: | --- |
|
|
| Focused |0|11 new acceptance tests passed;281 filtered |
|
|
| Full |101|292 names:276 passed,16 failed, zero ignored |
|
|
| List |0|292 unique names, exactly full runtime inventory |
|
|
| Strict core all-target Clippy |0|Locked/offline `-D warnings` completed |
|
|
| Workspace format |1|Exact prior raw output retained |
|
|
|
|
All281 predecessor outcomes are unchanged. Focused is exactly the11 added names and every new result is passed. Independently compared raw failure blocks as well as the checker result:16 match after replacement of numeric thread identifiers only, including whitespace and framework lines. Format SHA256 remains `c1c6b12861c8117ce6ffc6d6742ebf92618aafb10160ec6f99d370ca72ebab2d`.
|
|
|
|
Baseline2941713 full/list/fmt raw logs and receipts match the locally committed entry evidence ZIP SHA256 `19a87583a8dc4c22f35999044de5cac2c2c97b04fb457d2c3df3f6d2c054c865`. No remote publication claim is made here.
|
|
|
|
All five receipts bind current clean source,559 declared inputs and actual Git blob/disk byte equality, unchanged inputs through each run, exact commands and one captured launcher. Input manifest SHA256 `6be8ae8911bb3d0aee346b137930d2b27a7d0ed4e77c4c9502b60d07982bd028`. Current focused/full/list executable is43,066,880 bytes, SHA256 `7bc17993f265bdf7dc79b7ea5191401dd853f1dd47517235663113e4571031bb`; checker reread actual bytes. Full raw log SHA256 `5df6602c3d62c776720aa97916f0bf740de5488773d25601600aea8de27515e2`; Clippy raw SHA256 `83248e15864952f5d00a212d9a8ac3e6fc136cec5ff0b927328c20b022c7fff5`. Exact per-gate raw/receipt pins are in the JSON.
|
|
|
|
Actual captured launcher SHA256 `a17935d88ccb953f441b8939ccf2dc6aabcd6ea406d9a3754e3e8306a5bd26ce` differs from previously reviewed entry launcher only by source pin/description and output directory. It preserves exact source-before/after checks, unfiltered merged process logs, actual exit codes, helper capture and Cargo-reported artifact hashing. Reviewer inspected this delta without running the launcher. Jobs1, incremental0 and all other recorded environment values are exact baseline matches; stack/lifecycle/compiler overrides remain absent. Only CARGO_TARGET_DIR forward slash versus backslash changes, with both exact strings resolving to the same required target. See CHECKER-NOTE; this is not generalized path normalization.
|
|
|
|
These checks establish declared-input/recorded-artifact concordance, not independently reproducible compiler provenance or coverage of undeclared/untracked dependencies.
|
|
|
|
## Initial failed attempt and correction
|
|
|
|
Preserved initial source `4872141c036c16825f1c098bd7cf44709897e814` focused run exited101:9 passed/2 failed. Both failures were explicit empty-warning assumptions in rich OA/SA and four-file tests. Raw log SHA256 `b26d046e8b6284b5080ecbd6486c04f5556e1866292d5ac52f27893e69906371`, receipt `ff17f718a831784334443438ff444f6cc441a96ddd896fb1afd8e5602d9ed21a`; independently confirmed receipt/log match and counts. Initial artifact43,060,224 bytes, SHA256 `cba18de5758cac531dd166c95081fdcb390c2ceb295c06e09a26f3aa998e073c` is its own recorded identity, not the final artifact.
|
|
|
|
Final diff changes only new test expectations/helper and implementation note. Production unchanged. WARNING-FIX-ORACLE derives both legitimate ordered diagnostics and W227/W221 from validator/mapper source and literal expected bytes, not runtime diagnostic output. Final tests SHA256 `e42fd54b157a47a69c8de2ea379b375b797a971b5bb604be572ea1f45b55b73d` require complete warnings and final rich/four-file inventories. Earlier review's missed empty-warning assumption remains explicitly recorded in TEST-REVIEW.
|
|
|
|
## Scope of runtime and frame evidence
|
|
|
|
Final full log has eleven stack-named passing tests:ten inherited controls and the new scoped acceptance test. The latter contains five workers:deep128-node success and mismatch, wide129-node success and mismatch, plus real inherited151-byte late refusal; setup outside workers, actual verify/assert/destruction inside128KiB workers. Deep name mismatch may short-circuit before expression equality; deep success traverses actual expressions. These finite results do not establish universal stack headroom or whole predecessor setup on128KiB.
|
|
|
|
Read initial/final captured acceptance prologues: production verify8648, parse_entry_producers568, equal_target312, warning_inventory776, check_destination456 selected reservation bytes are unchanged by the test-only repair. Final capture has135 records versus initial125, including test/generic machinery, not135 live frames. Existing stack/active phase observations and separate source review retain their own scope. Explicit subtractions exclude pushes/caller overhead/uncaptured callees; captured64-byte ranges may cross symbol boundaries, so no whole-stack bound is inferred. Parsing, resolution and equality/destination transfer are sequential verification phases; summing all phase reservations as simultaneously live is invalid.
|
|
|
|
Finite actual-output admission, owning model/warnings, exact152/151 and161/160 behavior, nonvacuous actual-E fault control and corrected rich whole-byte/model/warning assertions passed on this artifact. Internal fault controls are not authentic emitted histories or real late-cap proofs. This remains private acceptance, not public source8, installation/history, GUI integration, repeated carried-source editing, all-heap accounting or closure of declared scratch exclusions.
|