43 lines
2.6 KiB
Markdown
43 lines
2.6 KiB
Markdown
# Independent cache and evaluator review
|
|
|
|
Read-only GPT-6 Astra review of
|
|
`636093aae67aa48fa1d35e403a205227e81d04de`, 2026-09-25. The reviewer did not
|
|
edit files, compile, launch a desktop window or control the user interface.
|
|
|
|
No concrete cache-key, lifetime or drawing-order defect was found. The review
|
|
checked Iced 0.14 source as well as the application: Iced compares exact cache
|
|
size, explicit camera changes clear geometry, and context/gesture retirement
|
|
retains the model-independent grid. Normal canvas state survives view rebuilds;
|
|
the focus wrapper's suspension reset causes a safe cold miss. Cached and live
|
|
mesh submissions retain their invocation order. Background geometry has no
|
|
text/images, and existing model transforms still apply to the live scene.
|
|
|
|
The evaluator uses an independent copy of the original grid painter, rather
|
|
than calling the candidate's painter to produce its expected image. It compares
|
|
the former combined frame with the split cached background, including opaque
|
|
and translucent foreground, text, overlay, fractional inputs and live edits.
|
|
The real DiagramCanvas check demonstrates changing selection/model revision
|
|
pixels while the grid construction count remains one, then checks pan/resize
|
|
invalidation. It exercises retained-state drawing and scene invalidation;
|
|
event-driven native gesture acceptance is outside that test.
|
|
|
|
The reviewer inspected `grid-tests-01.log`: all three tests pass, none fail or
|
|
are ignored, 1,547 are filtered, and execution takes 2.97s. Source identity is
|
|
provided by the accompanying run record and clean tracked implementation, not
|
|
by an embedded hash in the Cargo log. Full-suite/build/Clippy results published
|
|
later remain separate evidence and must be read in their own logs.
|
|
|
|
The measurements support avoiding repeated grid construction for an unchanged
|
|
camera. They do not establish native FPS, performance on another renderer, or
|
|
improvement during continuously changing pan/zoom. No broad final application
|
|
or release acceptance is claimed by this review.
|
|
|
|
A second read-only audit checked the full desktop log's 1,550 distinct names,
|
|
1,543 passes and seven ignored cases against `context.json`. It verified all
|
|
three recorded log hashes, driver-source hash, committed grid blob, linked Iced
|
|
and Tokio libraries, timing tables, sample method and rejected-batch ranges.
|
|
It did not independently verify the probe executable, execution chronology,
|
|
Clippy/build gates or environment assertions. It clarified that run 04's generic
|
|
cold-and-warm marker is not a production-cache warm-pixel check; that assertion
|
|
belongs to the separate committed tests.
|