Owner ruling (2026-09-30, straight from the live-testing loop): when the
depth anchor is vertical, the central pole (center-of-mass gravity)
should create forces on the x axis ONLY.
Half of this was already true: structured propositions have had x-only
gravity in vertical mode since the 2026-09-13 depth projections (the
depth force owns y). The change extends it to the one branch that still
pulled on both axes — the orphan mask (unstructured propositions, and
since 02a58db the imp geometry points): in vertical mode everyone gets
the x-only pull; the full regular pull survives only in radial mode
(where the rings own the radius) and in mode-off (plain forceX/forceY).
Why this is coherent: y in vertical mode belongs to the depth rows and
to nothing else. A structured node sits on its row; an unstructured
node has no row to sit on — and now no pole to sag toward either. Its
y is free (charge/springs only), so orphans keep their seeded or
warm-started height instead of piling onto the center line, and imp
bundles settle purely by their springs between premise and conclusion
levels.
Amended the ORPHAN RULE comments to state the new law, plus the imp-
exemption comment (gravity is horizontal-only in vertical mode "like
everyone"). Radial and mode-off paths untouched.
Tests: the ORPHAN RULE pin rewritten to the amended law (orphan's y
untouched at its seed, x still converges on the pole — the old pin
asserted y converging on gravity's center); new explicit pin in the
logical-graph describe (lonely node: |x| < 50, |y − seed| < 5); the
02a58db exemption fixture's comment updated to match (springs alone
place arg_x between levels).
Owner-approved brief (orchestrator, physics arc): two laws.
1. IMP-NODE CLUSTER ASSIGNMENT. Imp nodes were unclustered (the partition
runs over stored propositions only) — no centroid pull, outside the
painted hulls, bundles sitting on the periphery pointing outward.
Now: a derived imp node's cluster is a function of its derivation —
MAJORITY among its PREMISES' birth sessions (owner: premises, NOT the
conclusion), ties to the chain's OWN birth (its provenance's first
point — the asserting session; deterministic, coincides with the
unanimous common case). Imp nodes are always re-derived, never
birthed, so the assignment must be exactly this.
Seam chosen: core/session-clusters.ts exports impClusterKey + a
shared attachImpToCommunities that mutates a communities list's
members IN PLACE. graphSnapshot attaches AFTER the hull filter (a
2-proposition community + its bundle never resurrects a hull — the
filter counts propositions); settleGraphLayout attaches to the
unfiltered partition (settle pulls every community; hulls are a
canvas-only concern). Both cluster-membership consumers — the sim's
centroid pull and buildRegions' rasterization — read it through the
members lists that went through the one helper, so the resting
ledger and the live sim agree on where bundles belong.
2. DEPTHS OVER THE LOGICAL GRAPH. inferenceDepths ran Tarjan over the
DRAWN edges (premise→imp→conclusion), inflating every multi-premise
conclusion one hop (depth(imp)+1 instead of depth(premises)+1) and
ranking the geometry point itself. Now:
- deriveView additionally emits logicalEdges — every chain contracted
to direct premise→conclusion arrows over PROPOSITION ids only
(per-premise, deduped — a conclusion's rank is max over premises,
which a single arbitrary premise edge could not express).
- GraphSnapshot carries logicalEdges; createGraphSimulation /
incrementalLayout accept a logicalEdges option: the depth
machinery (orphan detection AND the rank pass) reads it, springs
keep the drawn edges. Absent = edges (legacy behavior).
- Imp nodes join the ORPHAN-EXEMPTION mask explicitly — never pinned
to a level, keep the full regular forces (gravity, cluster pull,
springs), settle naturally between premise and conclusion levels;
the rank map is computed over propositions only, so arg_ ids are
absent from it by construction.
Wiring: settle + canvas (CanvasData.logicalEdges → buildSim) +
replay-layout all pass the logical set.
EXTRA FIX (in-slice discovery, one line, graph-server domain):
server/graph.ts graphClusters — the practice picker's /api/graph/
clusters — partitioned snap.NODES (the canvas image, imp nodes riding
it since chains-primary), leaking arg_ ids into nodeIds: pickable ids
that silently vanish inside chainsForSelection while nodeCount lied.
Now partitions snap.propositions — same purity law as the chain
table's 767a559 fix.
Tests (+13): impClusterKey pins (unanimous; cross-session majority; tie
→ chain's own birth, not the conclusion's); attach pins (members gain
the imp id, sorted; single-premise attaches nothing — no node exists;
dangling mints nothing; home absent from the list stays unattached);
snapshot pins (imp id rides cluster members to both consumers; the hull
filter counts propositions); logical-depth pins (multi-premise
conclusion at premises'+1 NOT +2; imp absent from the rank map);
depth-force exemption pin (rows pin crisply, arg_x floats unpinned —
old behavior stamped it onto the conclusion's row); deriveView logical
arrows (per-premise, deduped, proposition ids only).
Owner-approved brief (orchestrator): the canvas stops drawing implication
nodes as first-class nodes and starts drawing them as what they are — the
point where co-premise lines converge.
- deriveView (core/graph.ts): single-premise chains collapse to ONE direct
premise->conclusion arrow — no imp node minted (a chain is always N-in/
1-out; one premise is the degenerate case). Multi-premise chains keep
the imp node + fan. Dangling guard unchanged.
- physics (core/layout.ts createGraphSimulation): per-link rest length —
a link touching an arg_-prefixed endpoint gets HALF the base link
distance, default or user-tuned alike; everything else about imp-node
physics citizenship unchanged.
- canvas (components/graph-canvas.ts): imp nodes are PURE GEOMETRY —
invisible (no disc, no label) and unpickable (excluded from pickAt's
hit-test projection). Edges INTO an imp node: headless, shaft runs to
its CENTER (toRadius 0, no head triangle). Edges OUT: shaft starts at
the center (fromRadius 0), arrowhead lands on the conclusion's disc
edge. Single-premise direct arrows render as today's plain arrows.
- comment repairs (same commit): the two stale double-shaft claims
(CanvasEdge doc + the draw-pass block) rewritten to the truth — plain
single shafts; bundles are headless converging lines + one arrowed
out-edge; no double-shaft glyph exists anywhere.
- tests (+9): deriveView pins (single-premise collapse, multi-premise
fan, shared-conclusion distinctness, dangling drop); imp-link half-
distance settle pins; arrowGeometry zero-radius laws + isImpNodeId
pin; graph.test.ts's snapshot invariant now counts only MULTI-premise
live chains (its fixture's single-premise chains mint zero imp nodes);
layout settle fixture updated for the collapse.
The owner's live test surfaced it: after importing notes, the chains view
listed implication nodes as bogus singleton "chains" — and each carried
the same arg_ id as the real stored chain, tripping React's duplicate-key
error (chain-table.tsx:372).
Root cause: graph-view passed snapshot.nodes — the derived canvas view
(propositions + implication nodes) — into ChainTableOverlay, whose
chainsForSelection turns every unchained node into a singleton chain.
An implication node is never a chain member (members are proposition
ids), so every imp node minted a bogus singleton with a colliding id;
its row was even selectable, leaking arg_ ids into practice input.
Fix (owner-approved shape): GraphSnapshot gains `propositions` — the
stored-truth node list riding beside `chains` for exactly this class of
consumer. The chain table now receives snapshot.propositions; the canvas
keeps snapshot.nodes (imp nodes are meant to be drawn). Practice pipeline
unaffected (it already read getGraph, which is propositions-only).
Test: the snapshot split pinned as an invariant in graph.test.ts — image
= truth + one imp node per fully-live stored chain; truth never carries
an arg_ id.
- architecture.md section 6 rewritten: stored truth = propositions + chains
(chains.jsonl); deriveView as the lossy image (implication nodes +
untyped arrows, rebuilt per read); the bijection framing (independent
arguments for one conclusion stay distinct — the corruption the edge
store invited); new deletion-semantics paragraph (proposition death
cascades to every referencing chain; arg_ death = one argument);
supports retirement stated plainly; auditor's propositions-only scope;
clusters stated as birth-session partition truth (no Louvain claim)
- section 7 practice chain model: stored-chains inclusion law replaces
follows-edge grouping; chainsToGraph bijection claim deleted
- README: graph clauses (stored chains, derived view, chain dedupe),
practice clause, ledger inventory, and two long-stale line-5 claims
(ledger events, semantic top-K) corrected
- contracts/graph.ts GraphSnapshot comment: Louvain claim replaced with
birth-session truth; extraction.ts comments no longer narrate the
dead expandFindings/chainsToEdges seam
Owner rulings 2026-09-30: reasoning chains are the stored truth; the graph
canvas renders a lossy derived image. No migration, no backcompat — old
graph data was wiped.
- contracts: GraphChain (arg_-minted id, premises, conclusion) replaces
typed edges; GraphEdge survives only as the untyped derived arrow;
GraphSnapshot carries stored chains; supports edges retired entirely
- store: chains.jsonl ledger (edges.jsonl purged at load alongside legacy
events.jsonl); readChains/appendChain seam; merge dedupes by
(sorted premises, conclusion), re-assertions append under the same arg_ id
- core: deriveView mints implication nodes (name ⟹, statement via
formatChainLine) plus premise→imp→conclusion arrows; clusters stay
proposition-only (birthSessionPartition); chainsForSelection now groups
STORED chains (chain rides iff every member selected) — independent
arguments for one conclusion never union; chainsToGraph/chainsToEdges die
- extraction: extractor submits chains natively (expandFindings deleted);
auditor receives propositions only; supports fan-out gone
- deletion: full death of a proposition kills every referencing chain;
arg_-prefixed node deletes kill that chain; chainsRemoved stats
- UI: every arrow renders the ⟹ double shaft; supports toggle + thickness
slider and detail-card edge sections deleted (card keeps name +
proposition); chain table + practice pipeline read stored chains
- tests: 1188 green across the new seams
'A → B → C' misread as chained implication when A and B are
CO-premises. The honest shape (owner, 2026-09-30): premises join
with the LaTeX LAND (∧), the conclusion separates by the LaTeX
IMPLICATION (⟹) — A ∧ B ⟹ C.
The glyphs are REAL KaTeX renders — components/latex-glyph.tsx wraps
katex.renderToString (cached per command; the app's math engine, the
stylesheet already rides app-wide from app/layout.tsx). No SVGs, no
font-dependent unicode. PROMINENT in the theme foreground (white in
the dark theme) per the owner's same-round ruling — the logic is the
payload, not the old dim gray. A lonely chip carries no glyph (it
reads as a standalone proposition); the plain-text '→' survives only
in the row's aria-label (formatChainLine, the screen-reader form).
Owner 2026-09-30: the confirm dialog's pre-flight impact read had to
go — what full death takes is obvious, the per-open fetch flickered,
and richer facts would only confuse as deletion semantics evolve
(rewiring is on the table). The screen is now: Delete node? / Delete
N nodes?, the names in the mono block, one permanence line, Cancel /
Delete. No loading state, no gone state (a 404 mid-run lands in the
honest failure line), no sessions join — the joins prop died too.
The dead path is deleted end to end: GET /api/graph/nodes/[id],
graphNodeImpact (server), nodeDeletionImpact (core) and their tests.
WORDING: node/node(s) is THE UI word for graph objects, standardized
across every surface's copy (owner, same ruling): the dialog titles,
the chain table's counts/search/summary/delete aria-labels, the
practice dialog's cluster counts, selection line, and empty-cluster
hint. Internal identifiers (selection.propositions) unchanged.
Rewritten dialog pins (tests/delete-node-dialog.test.tsx): minimal
contract — no facts/loading/fetch copy, singular/plural titles, the
cap, 409 dock phrasing, busy states, no 'proposition' left in the
dialog.
"This is really the view deletion should be done in" — the chain table
becomes the graph's MANAGEMENT surface. The floating selection bar
gains Delete FENCED at its right end (owner-approved placement): a
divider quarantines the destructive action from Clear and Generate,
red destructive pair + trash icon, opening the SAME full-death confirm
dialog the canvas uses.
DeleteNodeDialog extended from one node to an array:
- one node renders exactly as always; many pluralize the title
(Delete N propositions?) and list the names in the mono block,
capped at 8 + 'and K more'
- the pre-flight impact read aggregates: summed edge counts, unioned
referencing sessions (deduped, first-seen order); all-404 = gone
- confirm runs the per-node DELETEs SEQUENTIALLY — a failure stops
the run (extraction_running is never plowed through); onDeleted
now carries every id that actually died
- the chain table prunes its selection on delete and announces
lh:graph-revision so the snapshot refetches
Drift fix found en route (surfaced as NaN in the aggregated facts):
the server's NodeDeletionImpact has been {edges, sessions} only since
the quiz-events ledger died in the practice-arc schema slim — the
dialog kept rendering quizEvents/observations as undefined. The dead
fact lines are removed; the dialog now shows exactly what the server
can honestly report.
The chains-overlay TopBar had dead drag zones (counts, around search,
close gap) — cause: app-region subtraction resolves by DOM ORDER, not
z-index; the graph chrome's lh-no-drag column came later in the DOM and
punched holes through the overlay's drag band despite sitting visually
underneath (z-40 vs z-10).
Two laws, per the owner's standardization ruling:
- AUTO CARVE-OUT (globals.css): inside any .lh-drag band, every native
interactive element (button/input/textarea/select/a/summary/
[contenteditable]) is automatically a no-drag island — draggable
anywhere that is not a clickable element becomes structural. Manual
lh-no-drag is only for clickable non-natives.
- THE OVERLAY DOM LAW: a surface containing a TopBar that covers other
content must be the LAST child of its container — ChainTableOverlay
moved after the chrome column (verified live: last child, after the
column; auto-carve rule compiled; search/close/sidebar-toggle all
still click).
The tree threads no longer touch their arrows. Each thread is
BRACKETED by checkbox bottom edges (live-measured anchors):
- starts at its parent row's checkbox bottom edge — a visible gap
below the arrow's stroke (the stroke ends ~2.4px above the anchor)
- terminates exactly at the LAST child row's checkbox bottom edge
(cluster: top-[23px]/bottom-[8px] incl. the 1px group rule; chain:
top-[22px]/bottom-[8px]). Verified live: 23=23 top anchor, bottom
ends within 0.13px of the last checkbox at both levels.
- TREE THREADS: open folders and chains drop a vertical guide from
their expander arrow straight down through their children — at the
arrow's own column (37px clusters / 73px chains), subtle border/50.
Live-measured pixel-exact: arrow center = thread x (325=325, 361=361).
- The framed table: a rule under the header and under the last group
join the between-group separators; rows stay lineless.
Each staircase step is now TWO columns (36px): chains pl-12 — the
checkbox aligned with the cluster's FOLDER icon — and statements pl-21
— the checkbox where a chain icon WOULD sit (the chains lost theirs;
the pattern continues anyway). Live-measured: chain checkbox = folder
icon (336=336); statement checkbox = chain checkbox + 36 (372).
- chain rows lose the WaypointsIcon (owner: not needed — the chips +
connectors already read as chains); folders keep their icons.
- THE ALIGNMENT STAIRCASE: every level's checkbox sits directly under
its parent's expander arrow. The expander now shares the checkbox's
14px width (h-5 w-3.5), making each nesting step exactly 18px —
clusters pl-3 (12px) → chains pl-7.5 (30px, the cluster expander) →
statements pl-12 (48px, the chain expander). Live-measured: 318=318,
336=336.
- components/top-bar.tsx: THE shared top bar (standardization ruling) —
h-15, lh-drag + carve-outs, select-none, SidebarToggle reopen with the
Electron traffic-light gutter; adopted by chat (rename keeps its
drag={false} escape hatch), new-session, practice-list, practice-exam,
and the chains overlay.
- chain table: prominent indentation (pl-11 / pl-[4.75rem]), the ONLY
lines are the separators between cluster groups (row + vertical lines
gone), plain statement rows (no conclusion marker), all three columns
sortable (Props too) with a small chevron on the active header.
- full-bleed: blur + translucent surface IS the overlay, no inner card;
own top bar (info + search + close, lh-no-drag so home's drag mask
never eats the X — the clickability bug)
- three levels, one click each: cluster (birth session; a chain lives in
its CONCLUSION's cluster) → chain → proposition STATEMENTS revealed
directly (names never twice; singletons one click); all collapsed by
default
- proposition names as outlined chips, → connectors between; lonely chip
= standalone proposition — the '(no premises)' annotation is dead in
the visible UI (survives only as aria-label); Folder/Waypoints icons;
rotating chevrons; deep statement indent
- real table look: hairline row + column lines; sortable Name + Created
headers (click toggles asc/desc; size is text, not a control)
- selection never shifts layout: floating bottom bar (Google-Photos
pattern) with N propositions → M chains + Clear + Generate
- fuzzy search grouped + auto-expanding clusters
live-verified end-to-end on the owner's dev server; 15 rewritten render
pins; gates: tsc 0, 1179/1179, lint 0, build 0
- core formatChainLine: names + arrow one-liner, singleton marker, pure
- graph-view Chains button (chrome row, empty-graph hidden) opens the
overlay: fuzzy search (names/aliases/statements), collapsible chain →
member → statement rows, birth-session + created columns, no
understanding-levels column
- pinned Selected section derives the agents' actual input live
(chainsForSelection over the selection; premise without its
conclusion shows as the singleton it becomes)
- Generate opens the creation dialog in CUSTOM mode: selection summary
+ dated default title, posts {nodeIds, params, note}; cluster mode
untouched on /practice
- live-verified on the owner's dev server: 219 chains, derived preview,
search-never-filters-Selected, dialog handoff (selection pass-through
bug caught + fixed en route), Esc/backdrop dismiss, zero writes
- practice UI files re-normalized to tabs (my earlier prettier runs had
drifted them to the 2-space default; whitespace-only)
17 render/unit pins added; gates: tsc 0, 1174/1174, lint 0, build 0
- dialog: optional 'Anything else?' textarea (typing-only, 2000-char mirror)
- API: body gains note? — trimmed, whitespace-only omitted, hard 400 over 2000
- pipeline: note persisted on the set and threaded to both agent stages
- agents: THE LEARNER'S NOTE prompt block (present only when set) + the
weighed-never-owed stance pinned in both doctrines
- fix en route: doubled THE PARAMETERS heading in both prompts since slice 3
(renderParams owns the heading; the literal blocks removed)
Rulings: each problem generation is its own visible dock job (the
extraction per-chunk pattern), and practice shares extraction's
semaphore — one process-wide 3-permit pool for ALL background LLM
jobs; total background LLM concurrency bounded at 3.
A. SHARED POOL: new src/agent/subagents/bg-llm-semaphore.ts —
globalThis __lhLlmSlots, PERMIT_COUNT 3 (the ruling), the
fresh-take/handed-off-permit deadlock discipline preserved for
BOTH callers. extraction.ts's withExtractSlot is now a thin
wrapper (job-row signal → withBgLlmSlot); __lhExtractSlots and
__lhPracticeSlots both die. The partitioner now acquires a permit
too (it's a background LLM job — it didn't before).
B. REGISTRY ROWS: the aggregate setId:generation / setId:grading rows
are replaced by setId:partition (phase partitioning, label
'Partitioning — title'), setId:gen:problemId (queued→generating,
'Problem i/N — title'), setId:grade:problemId (queued→grading,
'Grading i/N — title'). Each row carries its OWN abort controller
and its OWN usage (one PracticeStepLog per row — the aggregate
partitioner/generator/grader folding dies). Row key = feed id =
abort key (the dock dup-key law).
C. ABORT SEMANTICS: abortPracticeRow(key) routes by shape — gen row:
THAT problem only (error 'Aborted', siblings continue, set settles
ready with one errored problem); partition row: the whole run;
grade row: that grade drops (answer kept, re-submittable).
abortPractice(setId) composes from row aborts + the synchronous
persisted marks (a set-abort's verdict stands before the settles
re-read it — the settle step keeps an existing error status).
/api/activity/abort kind practice now takes the ROW key (charset
admits ':').
D. FEED + DOCK: ActivityPractice/FeedPractice carry per-row identity
(id = row key, problemIndex/problemTotal); dock blobs render per
row, labels carry the i/N; the aggregate row is gone.
E. Boot sweep unchanged at set grain; the live-row check is now a
key-prefix scan (any live row of the set protects it). The
updatedAt heartbeat covers the new row scheme as-is.
Tests (20 in the pipeline suite): per-problem row shape/uniqueness/
i-N labels (partition row frozen behind a gated partitioner; per-row
usage ISOLATION pin — b's log never shows on c's row); abort-one-gen
(sibling completes, set ready with one errored problem); partition-
row abort; queued grade-row abort (dead-ticket path: answer kept,
re-submittable, sibling lands); shared-pool identity + contention
(practice queues behind extraction-style holders); registry/dock
feed mapping. Test isolation hardened: unique per-store set ids,
afterEach registry/lock/pool reset (a timed-out test can no longer
poison the rest).
architecture.md: jobs-pattern paragraph rewritten (per-problem rows,
shared pool, abort routing).
1149/1149, tsc 0, lint 0, build 0.
Prior state: zero formatting guidance anywhere in the agent module —
models wrote prose-only by default.
GENERATOR_DOCTRINE Part III gains the FORMATTING bullet (after the
THE PARAMETERS bullet, before PREVIOUS PROBLEMS): statement, solution,
and rubric render as full Markdown — math always LaTeX (inline $…$,
display $$…$$), code/pseudocode/formal systems in fenced blocks with
a language tag, identifiers inline as `code`, tables for parallel
structure, lists for enumerations; prose-only renderings of
mathematical or structured content are a defect.
GRADER_INSTRUCTIONS gains the feedback-formatting paragraph (before
the OUTPUT section): full Markdown, LaTeX math, fenced code, lists/
tables where they carry structure — teach the boundary in properly
formatted prose, not plain text.
PARTITIONER gets nothing (machine-shaped output).
Tests: substring pins on the exported doctrine constants — the exact
FORMATTING sentence + ordering (after presentation, before previous
problems), the exact grader paragraph + before-OUTPUT ordering.
Architecture.md §7 one clause (the formatting doctrine in the
generator's prompt inventory).
1144/1144, tsc 0, lint 0, build 0.
Owner report: created a set, 'Interrupted (server restarted)' showed
on list + set views, generation proceeded and overwrote it. The
sweep's 'generating + no registry row' test had a false-positive
mode: it ran at EVERY pipeline instantiation, and an instance could
evaluate against a registry whose fresh row it couldn't observe.
Three guards, per ruling:
1. HEARTBEAT: ProblemSet.updatedAt? (contract + doc) — bumped on
every store write; createSet stamps it = createdAt; saveSet
re-stamps (validator tolerates absence for legacy rows).
2. ONCE PER PROCESS: the sweep guards on globalThis
.__lhPracticeSweepDone — no instance re-evaluates after the
process's first sweep.
3. GRACE WINDOW: only sets whose heartbeat (updatedAt ?? createdAt)
is older than 120s are stamped. A live run saves at every phase/
problem transition, so it is structurally unreachable; a true
orphan is minutes stale at next boot. One [practice <id>] log
line per stamped set (the extraction/jobs console.error idiom).
Tests: stale orphan stamped; FRESH generating set untouched (grace);
once-guard (second factory instantiation never re-sweeps); live-row
protection re-armed via resetSweep() test seam; store pins for
updatedAt birth-stamp + re-stamp + legacy tolerance. Architecture.md
sweep sentence updated (once-per-process + grace semantics).
1142/1142, tsc 0, lint 0, build 0.
Contracts: LadderRung 0-4, CueDistance 0-2, Presentation theory|
application; PracticeParams carries the three named levels. Doc
comments hold the three definition tables verbatim (rung names +
definitions from the ladder doctrine; cue levels; presentation
levels).
Core: LADDER_RUNGS/CUE_LEVELS/PRESENTATIONS tables in src/core/
practice.ts (definitions verbatim) — ONE source spoken by the agents'
prompts, the dialog's stepped controls, and the exam header; core
barrel re-exports practice.ts (pure domain, browser-safe).
Agents: Part I's ladder intro now 'five rungs, numbered; the request
arrives as a rung' with bullets numbered 0-4 (definitions untouched);
Part III's parameters block replaced with the named-level doctrine
(rung = exact class, no continuum; cue counts lesson examples AND
previous problems' situations; presentation dresses, never changes);
partitioner's RESPECT THE PARAMETERS replaced (low rungs = many small
assignments, high = larger; far cue makes confusables-together MORE
important; presentation does not shape the partition). renderParams
outputs the exact named-level block. Anchor/0..1 language swept dead.
Service + store: strict union validation — floats between levels,
out-of-range, wrong strings, legacy dial shapes all 400 at the API
and fail isProblemSet (legacy sets skipped from lists; no migration —
data/practice is disposable scratch, owner wipes before testing).
UI: dialog = 5-detent ladder slider + 3-detent cue slider (each shows
the level NAME + one-line definition) + Theory|Application segmented
toggle; defaults rung 2 / cue 1 / theory; Create posts the new shape.
Exam header gains the levels line ('Direct exercise · Adjacent
context · Theory').
Tests: renderParams exact-block pin; strict-validation pins (new
tests/practice-service.test.ts — bad unions 400, legacy shape 400);
store pins (legacy floats + 2.5 rung fail); render pins (detents +
names + definitions, defaults, detent-swap, toggle active segment,
levels line); every params fixture moved off floats. 1138/1138, tsc
0, lint 0, build 0.
Docs: architecture.md — discretization paragraph (compact tables,
named-level invocation, defaults, one-table source), UI mentions;
README axes sentence.
Owner escalation on deviation 1: practice availability must not
inherit a visual-rendering threshold. graphClusters() now runs
birthSessionPartition(snap.nodes) directly (same size-desc/id-asc
ordering) instead of reading the snapshot's MIN_CLUSTER_SIZE-filtered
clusters array — MIN_CLUSTER_SIZE stays a hull-drawing rule only.
Label join mirrors the snapshot's (chat title / notes path, null when
the naming record is gone). Contract doc + architecture.md sentence
corrected to match; empty-picker copy reworded ('once a session births
its first proposition' — no 3+ mechanics). Render pins: new empty line
+ a 1- and 2-proposition group listing pin. 1130/1130, tsc 0, lint 0,
build 0.
Owner ruling: 'problem sets always take in nodes — graph objects' —
practice is graph-domain, not chat-domain. No session-created sets.
API: POST /api/practice/sets takes {nodeIds, params, title?} ONLY —
the chatId branch, UnknownChatError, and the any-provenance filter are
deleted; the selector is nodeIds (readNodes filtered to the selection,
unknown ids drop, empty live intersection → 400 empty_selection);
title optional from the UI (the picker's cluster label), dated default
stays. chatStore leaves the pipeline deps entirely (labels resolve
store-side in the clusters service).
GET /api/graph/clusters (new): the birth-session groups the graph view
renders — graphSnapshot's clusters verbatim (same ordering, same
MIN_CLUSTER_SIZE presentation filter), mapped to {key, kind
chat|notes, label (null when the naming record is gone — honest,
never guessed), nodeIds, nodeCount}; corrupt/empty graph → empty
list. GraphClusterGroup contract in core/contracts/graph.ts (client-
safe — the dialog imports it).
practice-dialog: session picker → cluster picker (rows show label +
proposition count, notes clusters marked); Create posts the cluster's
nodeIds + label as title + params. 400 empty-selection copy reworded
for the vanished-nodes edge ('Nothing practicable is left in that
cluster — the graph changed.'); 503 deep link unchanged. Preselected
mode gone — the dialog is the only creation entry for now (the graph-
view cluster entry comes later with free-form selection).
Sidebar: session right-click 'Practice this session's propositions'
removed (item + state + dialog wiring); the /practice nav row stays.
Tests: pipeline — chatId/any-provenance tests die, nodeIds selection
pins added (unknown-id filtering, dated-default title, title hint
rides, empty/vanished → EmptySelectionError); render — cluster picker
pins (label+count rows, notes kind, unlabeled cluster muted, empty
graph line), preselected pins removed; 16 render + 13 pipeline.
Docs: architecture.md §7 API+UI paragraph rewritten (graph-domain
ruling, /api/graph/clusters, cluster picker as the only entry, no
404-unknown-chat); README creation-flow line updated.
1130/1130, tsc 0, lint 0, build 0.
docs/architecture.md: new §7 'Practice — strengthening, not assessment'
(purpose ruling + parked exam machinery; the chain bijection with
follows-edges, supports invisible, exactly-once partition; self-
contained sets frozen at creation; two-stage generation — partitioner,
one generator per problem with YOUR TARGET echo law + THE FULL SET
minimal-use doctrine, commit-before-pose, failure isolation, dedup
across sets; feedback-only grading; registry-not-JobRecords jobs
pattern and WHY — not chat-scoped, never wakes the teacher, boot
sweep; API + UI surfaces; three strong-pinned roles on the shared
runSubmitAgent seam). Sections 7-13 renumbered to 8-14; the §9
cross-ref in the deferred list updated. Cross-referenced enumerations
updated: §1 six-systems table + row, §2 layer count 25→28 routes,
§2.2 seven contract files + practice.ts, §3 PracticeStore port +
adapter + composition-root bullets + PORTSBOX, §4 six-systems heading
+ PRACTICE mermaid box + practice-request protocol, §6 practice-
territory sentence now points at the landed module, §10 observability
practice rows + abort kinds, §11 testing strata, §12 seam directory
row.
README.md: practice paragraph in Key mechanisms at the same grain
(feedback-only problem sets, partitioner/generator/grader, registry
jobs); the graph paragraph's 'assessment becomes practice-module
territory' forward-reference resolved to the landed module.
Docs-only — no code changes. 1129/1129, tsc 0, lint 0, build 0.
components/practice-dialog.tsx: portal dialog (delete-session shape),
three dial rows (SettingSlider markup, anchor text as display:
flashcard-competition / near the lesson-far transfer / theory-
application, defaults 0.5), session picker (generic mode, /api/chats)
or preselected lock (right-click path); 400 empty_selection renders
'This session has no propositions yet', 503 renders the server line +
Open settings deep link (useSettingsDialog, zero-keys precedent).
Pure body exported for SSR pins.
components/practice-list.tsx: rows (title, date, ready/total problems,
graded count, status word; destructive tint on error), click-through,
delete affordance → portaled confirm (DeleteSetBody: no mode checkbox
— a set has no preserve-graph question), 2s reveal-poll while any set
is partitioning/generating. components/practice-exam.tsx: numbered
problems; generating stubs (BrailleSpinner + 'Generating problem…',
propositions never surface); ready statements/solutions/rubrics/
feedback as MessageResponse markdown with restoreMathEscapes at the
display seam; per-problem textarea + useDictation instance with the
DictationBar rendered only on box focus; one Submit answers POST per
set; graded reveal (verdict chip, feedback, model solution, rubric)
with read-only answer; polling while not ready OR grading-live
(activity feed practice rows — dropped grades terminate the poll).
app/practice/page.tsx (force-dynamic, listPracticeSets) + app/practice/
[id]/page.tsx (getPracticeSet + notFound). Sidebar: quiet Practice nav
row under New session (GraduationCapIcon, active on /practice) +
'Practice this session's propositions' in the session right-click
below the hairline, above CoverageMenuBlock — opens the dialog
preselected.
tests/render-practice.test.tsx — 15 pins: dials + anchors, picker
selection gating, preselected lock, empty-selection line, 503 deep
link, list rows/counts/empty, delete confirm + inline failure, exam
generating (no proposition text, no answer boxes, no submit), ready
(markdown statement, gated submit), graded reveal + read-only + sibling
answerable, failed problem/set lines, math healing. 1129/1129, tsc 0,
lint 0, build 0.
src/agent/subagents/practice.ts: createPracticeAgents(deps) with the
ExtractionModels mirror (per-stage engine overrides + engineFor +
providerKeyMissing + refuseIfStagesUnready, all three roles strong-tier).
Generator doctrine = the owner's problem-engineering framework verbatim
(minus Sources) + Part III wiring section per the green-lit amendments
(FULL SET input with minimal-use doctrine; degradation never in
meta-commentary). Partitioner: true-partition doctrine, validate via
chainCoverage + exactly-once + unknown-ids, error-back retries through
runSubmitAgent's new validate hook (ToolInputError → error tool result).
Generator: echo law (chains set === target). Grader: verdict union +
nonempty feedback (schema-enforced). renderChains/renderPropositions/
renderParams/renderPreviousProblems. BACKGROUND_MODEL_ROLES extended with
the practice trio (settings override symmetry). runSubmitAgent gains the
validate seam (null = accept). 16-test faux-engine suite incl. retry
paths, refusal gates, neverSubmitted.
runSubmitAgent moved verbatim from extraction.ts to src/agent/subagents/
submit-agent.ts (exported; extraction imports it — zero behavior change,
extraction suites green untouched). New optional prepareArguments seam:
extraction wires its healStringifiedArrays heal; default is identity
pass-through. ModelRole += partitioner | problemGenerator | grader;
ROLE_SLOT pins all three to strong (quality-critical trio, plan default).
Note: BACKGROUND_MODEL_ROLES (per-role settings overrides) deliberately
NOT extended — settings-surface decision, flagged for the planning
session.
PRICES must stay a generated static table (core is client-safe; the
renderer folds costs and reading the catalog JSON needs fs), so the
forgetting-the-sync failure mode is guarded instead of eliminated.
- sync-pricing.ts: buildPrices() extracted (the pure catalog walk),
exported for the test; main() now guarded by an entry-point check so
importing the module runs nothing
- tests/prices-sync.test.ts: asserts PRICES equals EXACTLY what the
script would generate now — unpriced new models, drifted prices, and
keys gone from the catalog all fail with 'run npx tsx
scripts/sync-pricing.ts'. Verified it fires by deleting the
deepseek-v4.1-flash entry (1 unpriced, actionable message)
- sync script's embedded header template corrected to match prices.ts
(no bare-slug legacy claim) + drift-guard note, so the next
regeneration keeps the honest docs
Costs were rendering '—' for tonight's extraction runs. Root cause: the
pi family bump (df1328e, 0.85.1 -> 0.87.1) added deepseek-v4.1-flash to
the shipped catalogs, but scripts/sync-pricing.ts was never re-run after
it — src/core/prices.ts was still the 2026-09-25 generation. The design
itself is sound and matches the owner's expectation: nothing stores
dollars; records keep tokens + model string; callCost infers at read
time from PRICES[model]. So the re-sync retroactively re-prices every
run the moment the entry lands.
- npx tsx scripts/sync-pricing.ts: 1495 keys (+314/-173 lines);
openrouter:deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash = 0.15/0.6/0.003 (matches the
catalog the picker serves)
- glm-5.3-flash price drift (0.075/0.25 -> 0.15/0.5, cacheRead 0.015 ->
0.05): four pinned-cost tests re-derived (usage, cost-summary via
callCost, activity-dock, stats-bar)
- prices.ts header: dropped the false bare-slug-legacy claim (the table
has zero bare keys; sync emits provider-qualified only) and noted the
forgetting-the-sync failure mode
Observed live: the auditor looped find for a very long time, never touching
list_sessions/list_propositions. Root cause was the prompt: its only
procedure text was 'For each proposition, search the graph (its key words,
its synonyms, its phrasings)' — a per-proposition find loop with no
starting point, no sense of the space's extent, and no termination rule.
And find returned id+name+statement with no session pointer, so results
never composed with the listing tools (owner diagnosis, 2026-09-29).
- AUDITOR_INSTRUCTIONS now prescribes the process: (1) list_sessions ONCE —
the graph is small and finite, this shows its entire extent; (2) read
plausibly-related sessions with list_propositions (full text) — every
realistic candidate seen in a few calls; (3) find as the targeted sweep;
(4) SUBMIT once related sessions are read — never re-search seen ground
- find hits now carry 'born in: <session id>' — results point at sessions
the auditor can read whole (legacy no-provenance nodes name none)
- identity doctrine untouched: equivalence bias, linkTo mechanics,
verdicts-only deliverable
Diagnosis on tonight's data (4 sources, 173 nodes, 216 edges): supports is
62-83% of edges, topology is hub-and-spoke (34/94 libertarianism nodes are
degree-1 leaves), hub edges read as essay-flow not logic, 33-41% of nodes
are degree<=1 across sources. The old doctrines asked for exactly this:
'every distinct proposition' + 'lonely nodes = failed extraction' +
'COMPLETENESS... omitting is the main way extraction fails'.
Owner rulings, prompt-only (data model untouched, both prompts):
- strict reasoning bar: a proposition earns its node by being a premise,
step, or conclusion of an argument the source actually makes; isolated
facts, name-drops, asides, trivia, example enumerations are dropped
- supports tightened: ONLY explicit grounding acts in the text, rare
exception, genuinely argumentative relations are almost always follows
- completeness inverted: precision over recall, WHEN IN DOUBT OMIT,
never connect merely-related propositions
- MUST-connect clause dropped; corrections of misconceptions stay in
(argumentative by nature)
Identity doctrines untouched (established-terminology names, MERGE YOUR
OWN OUTPUT, aliases) — zero near-duplicate statements proves they work.
A LINEAR 0–1 multiplier of Edge width (default 0.5, dead-center at step
0.1 — 11 stops like the ladder rows but ratio-valued), grayed out by the
supports-edges toggle (the Dilation dependency pattern). Renderer splits
supports shafts into their own Path2D and strokes a second pass at
edgeWidth × supportsWidth; arrowheads stay full-geometry in the one shared
path (owner pick: shaft only). A true 0-width stroke is undefined on
canvas — the 0 end floors to a 0.5px on-screen hairline; hiding remains
the toggle's job. Sanitizer: real numbers clamp to [0,1], everything else
resets to 0.5; clamps pinned in render-settings.test.
Off hides supports edges from the canvas: the renderer skips them when
building the shaft/head paths (draw-only — the physics sim still feels
them and detail cards still list them; settings never shift the graph).
Server-persisted with the rest (render-settings.json); sanitizer takes
real booleans only, anything else (missing key, legacy file) loads ON —
today's look. Toggle row styled as the Background-colors row; sanitiser
pinned in render-settings.test.
The persisted (chatId, sourceId)→node table was a shared namespace across
independent chunk/batch jobs: each chunk's extractor mints local ids fresh
(p1..pN), so later chunks collided with earlier ones — propositions silently
skipped as 'already resolved' (coverage checkpointed anyway: permanent silent
loss) and edges resolved onto the wrong nodes (the 'everything links to
everything' mush). Owner ruling 2026-09-29: mergeFindings resolves THIS job's
ids in memory, nothing persists between jobs; cross-job identity is the
auditor's linkTo verdicts alone.
- contracts: NodeMapping dies; NotesSource.contentFp — sha256 of the text at
the last run, the re-import guard (unchanged re-import = TRUE no-op, no
model calls, no usage; changed text re-runs; legacy unstamped sources
re-run once)
- merger: job-local resolution map, in-submit duplicate ids skip once,
edges resolve extractor-local ids only
- ports/store: appendMapping/readMappings, LEDGER_FILES.mappings,
rewriteLedgers.mappings gone (stale data/graph/mappings.jsonl just stops
being read)
- session-clusters: birthSessionOf is provenance-only — the legacy
mapping-line fallback for provenance-empty notes nodes dies
- deletion: no mapping rows to strip; stats lose mappingsRemoved
- replay-layout batches nodes by first provenance point
- graph.test pins the new independence semantics (re-merge re-creates;
duplicate ids within one submit resolve once); extraction tests pin
per-chunk merges + the fingerprint guard
The reveal rule (c902bc6: a run leaving the feed means its merge is on
disk, so refetch immediately) was tracking chatId sets — fine when one
row meant one source, but per-chunk jobs made it re-batch the reveal:
chunks finish one by one, each row leaves, but the source's chatId stays
present until its LAST chunk drains, so a big import showed nothing
until it fully completed. The exact batching bug the rule exists to
prevent.
Track by row id (the registry job key) in both the snapshot-reveal poll
and the per-run costs refresh — a chunk row disappearing IS that
chunk's merge landing.
The graph page's pipeline pills keyed rows by run.chatId — the source id,
shared by every chunk job of a fan-out (the dock got the same fix in
8f66f47; this consumer was missed). /api/graph/status rows now carry an
id (the registry job key: source id, or 'src#i'), and the pills key by
it. chatId stays the SOURCE id — the reveal refetch and per-run cost
refresh track chatId SETS, which dedupe naturally and fire when the
source's LAST row leaves the feed.
Hypothesis under test by the owner: coherent extractions turn to mush
after merging because the auditor minted too many bridging edges of its
own — inference, not identity, and out of the auditor's scope. The graph
now connects across sources solely through identified equivalences;
relations between propositions come from the extractor alone.
- auditSchema drops 'edges' (submit_review = links only); the submit-seam
required-field doctrine reworded per tool
- AUDITOR_INSTRUCTIONS: the BRIDGING EDGES section dies; deliverable is
the identity verdicts only
- AuditVerdicts drops edges; ExtractedEdge endpoints are extractor-local
ids only; mergeFindings stops consuming verdict edges and its resolve()
drops the raw-node-id branch (dead — the extractor never sees graph ids)
- extractor untouched: submit_findings keeps propositions + follows/
supports edges, required as before
- tests: 17 submit fixtures + 9 typed verdict literals slimmed to links
- docs: architecture.md division-of-trust + pipeline diagram updated
The live import surfaced it: a multi-chunk notes source renders N feed
rows, and the dock keyed every one by run.chatId (the SOURCE id) —
React's duplicate-key error. The activity feed also dropped run.part
entirely, so all chunk rows showed identical titles.
- ActivityExtraction/FeedExtraction gain a unique row id (source id, or
'src#i' for chunk jobs) and part; the feed title carries the '· i/N'
suffix like the graph status route
- toBlobs keys extraction blobs by the row id; chatId stays the SOURCE
id (identity for links)
- abort sends the SOURCE id for extractions — aborting any chunk row
kills the source's whole fan-out (the new source-wide abort), and the
abort route's id charset rejects '#' anyway
- new pin: one source, two chunk rows → two blobs, distinct ids, same
chatId; dock fixtures updated
Every notes chunk and chat coverage batch is its own job — registry row,
usage record, failure domain. Extracts fan out process-wide behind a
3-permit extract semaphore on globalThis (new 'queued' phase); audits and
merges stay serialized behind the existing FIFO gate ('waiting'), so each
auditor explores the graph after every earlier job's merge.
- ExtractionPhase gains 'queued'; RunningExtraction gains part {i,n};
the feed shows one row per job with a '· i/N' suffix (status route)
- abortExtraction is source-wide: every job of a fan-out dies together;
merged jobs keep their coverage checkpoints
- failure isolation at the fan-out (Promise.allSettled + aggregation):
a failed chunk no longer kills its siblings — the run returns what
actually merged; job-level aborts log, pre-fan-out errors still throw
- usage ledgers: one record per job (source-keyed), failed jobs bill
their partial spend
- runJob/aggregateJobs helpers; setPhase/recordStep/extract/audit/
notesExtract key the registry by jobKey (src#i) — notesExtract's
signal lookup was the one real bug the new tests caught (source-id
lookup meant fan-out aborts never reached the model call)
- semaphore is handoff-correct (fresh takes increment; handed-off
permits don't double-count — an inflated counter deadlocks at 3)
- tests: isolation pins rewritten (stage failure now resolves zeros),
single-flight/registry tails updated, per-job usage counts, and a new
describe pinning the fan-out: 3 extracting + 5 queued, parts 1..8,
source-wide abort, per-job usage on failure, extract peak == 3,
audit peak == 1
- docs/architecture.md: serialized-audit paragraph rewritten for
per-chunk jobs; two-front-doors wording aligned
The reported bug (2026-09-28): every chat ran glm-5.3-flash regardless of
any pick, while composer and settings UIs agreed with each other and lied
about the run. Root cause: a fossil default-settings record (settings.json
chat section, frozen pre-slots-wave) was stamped verbatim into every new
chat at birth by the new-session flow, and resolveConversationSpec prefers
the per-chat record over the strong slot forever.
Owner redesign — models are per session, always; the strong slot is the
new-session default:
- POST /api/chats stamps the newborn verbatim from the strong slot
(model + thinking level); no client settings PUT on create anymore
- the composer control is dual-bound: in-session it reads/writes the
session's own record (GET /api/chats/:id, PUT .../settings); on the
draft surfaces it binds the strong slot (picking there = changing the
default)
- thinking levels follow the identical mechanics (confirmed by owner)
- the zombie default-settings system dies whole: useDefaultSettings,
/api/settings/defaults, src/store/default-settings.ts, the chat
section of UserSettings (sanitizer strips fossil copies), the legacy
default-settings.json fold, and DEFAULT_SETTINGS_FILE
- catalogDefaultsFor collapses to the strong slot alone
- thinking display for a legacy unstamped session resolves exactly like
the engine (session ?? strong ?? model ladder)
Tests: new chat-birth-stamp suite pins the stamp, the unconfigured boot,
the unset level, and the copy-not-live-view regression; defaults pins
rewritten strong-only; legacy-migration suite deleted.
Owner ruling 2026-09-28: the auditor has no control over the
extractor's output and never alters it, so re-emitting the full
findings per submit was pure payload cost — the retry collapse the
schema slim attacked, halved again. submit_review is now links
(local proposition id -> existing graph node; EQUIVALENCE BIAS
carried in the linkTo description) + bridging edges ONLY; the
merger joins extractor findings + verdicts.
mergeFindings(chatId, findings, verdicts, ...) — propositions come
from findings verbatim, links join by id, edges emit extractor's
then auditor's through one dedup-preserving emitter. The old echo
form hid an accidental drop channel: an auditor that omitted a
proposition from its echo silently dropped it from the merge.
Verdicts-only removes it structurally — extractor output always
fully merges (tests updated to full-merge expectations).
AuditResult/AuditedProposition -> IdentityLink/AuditVerdicts;
audit() logs links/bridges; batch view renders anchorless like
transcriptView; auditor prompt rewritten to the verdicts-only
deliverable; architecture.md division-of-trust updated.
amosblomqvist