Scenario diagrams are very rigid and its controls are bad #20
No Assignees
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies
No dependencies set.
Reference: sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio#20
Reference in New Issue
Block a user
You can't spread lifelines (to void clipping of call names), you can't move arrows aroud, you can't resize stuff and other similar issues...
Current controls implemented via strange draggable rectangle is strange, unintuitive and hard to use. It should be easy to edit scenario diagrams. As easy as editing and working with architecture diagrams. So, simple, generally accepted (and intuitive because of that) controls should be implemented. You can explore original ARCADIA Capella to see their solution for this
This is a part of #1
Codex-ytr83r /root claims the scenario direct-editing outcome, extending the existing #2 layout work; current #20 comments show no other owner. Immediate isolated branch codex/behavior-anchor-plan-ytr83r-20260912 starts from published66a1f1690f778c8814bfefff7f46fe7f6bbe520e and tests exact placement before any production schema selection. Live dependency record remains here, with current evidence and falsifiers.
Acceptance: ordinary direct controls for lifeline spacing, whole-message movement, route/label editing and relevant frame/box sizing; no draggable-rectangle-only substitute. Preview/commit/reopen and graphical/text/API values must agree; zero motion must preserve latent authored values, Undo/Redo restores exact state, stable occurrence identities and semantic membership/lifetimes remain intact, and real Windows small/large scenario workflows must be exercised. The current seed-spacing floor is not accepted. Cross-event movement and frame-enclosure policies must be explicit rather than silently becoming semantic reorder or clamping.
Codex-956atf retains #16 general/architecture resize and #21 nested activation work. I will coordinate the shared frame/anchor/activation interfaces, retain lifetime clipping in a combined renderer and avoid editing that peer's source. #7 prospective schema8 is not adopted or exclusively reserved by this claim. Initial tests remain a probe, not completion of this issue; Linux remains user-paused.
Codex-ytr83r /root: the complete-anchor Scene experiment is committed and published at 4b782a71fc011defd39331d3d6d5b73c1506275c, branch codex/behavior-anchor-plan-ytr83r-20260912. All 21 changed artifacts were read back with matching Git blob hashes and byte counts, including the original two candidate snapshots and raw patches. Reproduction, independent numeric expectations, review corrections and limitations are accessible to peers without local paths.
This source is formatted and independently reviewed, but not compiled or executed yet. The planned single-binary gate selects 10 existing floor/lifetime tests plus 13 complete-anchor tests, with explicit counts preventing zero-test acceptance. The three preserved static falsifiers exposed split frame-header geometry, a Create marker outside the actual root lifetime span, and an operand scope escaping its enclosing fragment. Bounded corrections now reject those unsupported positions and retain non-vacuous positive geometry/lifetime checks. No runtime failure/pass is inferred from those reviews.
This tests exact placement through the existing renderer; it does not adopt unrestricted chronology crossing, a public layout schema or production drag/Undo behavior. Primary Sirius evidence and the two remaining gesture candidates are recorded in the report. Peer #21 retains typed-activation/lifecycle integration. The corrected 12-test core gate remains active on the other frozen worktree; I am keeping one compiler owner and will run the 23-test experiment after it closes. Linux remains user-paused.
Codex-ytr83r /root: current
4b782a7Windows check passed (cargo check -p oa-desktop --bin arcadia-studio --tests --locked --offline, exit0). The test executable/listing is now compiling; no 23-test runtime result yet.New source-verified finding changes the next implementation scope: widening lanes alone cannot reveal longer names. Both our4b782a7 and peer
aadc6396paint short(&l.label,32), independently of available lane gap. views::short normalizes whitespace and keeps31 graphemes plus ellipsis. The225-unit backplate is only an estimated rectangle, not a matching text clip. Existing release1 oa_conversation already loses the tail of real call/reply occurrence names. Our behavior/scenario/usage.rs also hardcodes the same32 limit when deciding visible operation-label membership; changing only paint would break that agreement.The bounded candidate is one measured, geometry-dependent displayed label feeding paint, backplate, hit bounds and navigation visibility. It must be resolved after activation endpoint alignment, handle reversed/self messages and preserve bar continuity/precise hits. Actual-render evaluators must prove the full known name appears when the lane gap permits, distinguish channel A/B suffixes, cover CJK/combining text, and preserve all message anchors/source. Wrapping remains a separate collision/row-height decision, not silently adopted. This is a source finding and evaluator proposal, not an implemented/passing label fix.
Persistence comparison provisionally favors existing Diagram identity with typed behavior layout over an owner-only map; fresh critique is in progress. Shared schema/reference/source seams are coordinated in #7 comment756; no competing schema8 contract has been adopted.
Codex-ytr83r /root: reviewed scenario layout direction is committed/pushed/read back at75cb09dade2cf4b9a176b5e6159f43e2345d196e on codex/scenario-layout-ytr83r-20260913. This selects the storage direction, not a new public schema or completed behavior: existing Diagram identity, Scenario projection first, typed sparse authored layout. Process/FunctionalChain use topology, so an unused Process sequence projection is excluded from this first increment while full behavior editing remains required.
Fresh critique made three requirements explicit: gestures distinguish derived unsaved versus saved representations and view visits; copying a view keeps semantic references while creating only a new Diagram identity; isolated appearance editing constrains authored records/semantic IDs rather than forbidding legitimate dependent rendered movement. The report also defines projection dispatch, reference/remapping/deletion, no-motion/history and source/REST/native acceptance obligations. Schema8/shared-file coordination remains pending in#7; no core fields or syntax changed.
A separate two-file measured-label candidate is now implemented but unwired/unformatted/uncompiled. It uses the actual Iced text allocator, zoom/font metrics and original-source visibility mapping; six candidate tests use independent Paragraph measurements. Fresh code review is underway. The frozen4b782a7 test executable is still compiling, and its source remains unchanged. Linux stays paused.
Codex-ytr83r /root: actual parser/Document/Scene experiment gates are now closed on source
4b782a71fc. Windows GNU LLVM: cargo check desktop bin/tests exit 0; exact listing selected 10 floor/lifetime + 13 complete-anchor cases; execution 23 passed, 0 failed, 0 ignored (895 filtered). All 574 captured input paths, sizes and SHA-256 values remained unchanged. Passing scoped-restoration cases intentionally emit panic messages; no crash is inferred.Published result commit
436d8ee068, with all 11 evidence files read back by exact Git blob and byte count: http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/436d8ee06871a20815616cb4f9ba263fe4a6afea/harness/experiments/behavior-anchor-plan-gates-20260913/README.md . This preserves the earlier prepared experiment source unchanged. The floor-policy counterexample remains a rejection of that policy; successful experiment execution is not persisted-layout, drag, source/API parity, native UI or full-regression acceptance.Next: measured-label review corrections (font artifact lifetime, a vacuous cache test, finite world dimensions) in the isolated scenario-layout contribution; separately run the navigation/rename union208 gates for #27. Linux remains user-deferred.
Codex-ytr83r /root: measured-label/corridor evaluator now executed successfully on exact source903d85dda403b93731c05a08b97fa7d257d012dd. A portable standalone wrapper imports the actual label and corridor modules without wiring the desktop. Windows rustc1.98.1 gnullvm compilation with warnings denied passed; exact listing18, normal17 passed/0 failed/1 ignored, then the one real-font test passed alone in a fresh process. Its valid Iced-Icons load increased face count167→168 and font Version0→1; all old-label consumers and old-session resolution rejected stale artifacts. All five captured source/lock/wrapper inputs remained unchanged; exact binary hash and dependency artifacts are recorded.
Source/preparation903d85d (18 files) and result6a8650669fb0ffe37a2412e5a342724e6394491b (24 files) are published with exact remote blob/byte readbacks. Report: http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/6a8650669fb0ffe37a2412e5a342724e6394491b/harness/experiments/scenario-label-gates-20260913/README.md . Original review candidates and failed standalone module-path/link attempts are preserved. No peers need my .local directory.
Remaining boundary: these modules are still unwired. Actual Scene/camera integration must resolve geometry first, zoom second, one shared label artifact third; operation navigation must preserve its chosen destination zoom. Corridors subtract blockers across the entire padded label band, not merely baseline/paint order. Settled-font lifetime rejection is tested; dynamic WGPU recovery, ink/overhang, production self/reversed placement, native hit/navigation, persisted layout and drag are not accepted. Independent corridor source review is in progress. #27 union10bd check passed; its exact-membership test binary is building. Linux stays user-deferred.
Codex-ytr83r /root: independent review caught a real f32 corridor reconstruction defect after the18-test baseline: finite endpoints could subtract to infinite width, or rounded width could cross a blocker (right2.125 versus blocker2.1). Fixed source345f7b3d5b64cef6e75f907c4d47f5b5658f1eba converts conservatively and rounds inward; two regressions first prove the old arithmetic fails, then require finite contained output. Scoped independent re-review found no remaining conversion/use issue.
The corrected isolated executable compiled with warnings denied, listed20, passed19 ordinary tests plus the exact real-font mutation alone (20 total;0 failed). All five source/lock/wrapper inputs and the executed binary remained unchanged. Published source/result2f90cf25d11c295a0ae41f0e5bd9c8cb5d648fdb, all17 new code/evidence files exact-readback verified: http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/2f90cf25d11c295a0ae41f0e5bd9c8cb5d648fdb/harness/experiments/scenario-label-rounding-gates-20260913/README.md . Earlier18-test result remains historical evidence and is superseded for corridor acceptance. The helper is still unwired; native paint/ink and Scene/camera/navigation/persistence/drag acceptance remain open.
Codex-ytr83r: published the independently reviewed, corrected standalone WGPU evaluator at
e409107a63, harness/experiments/scenario-label-wgpu-20260913/README.md; all3 source/runner/doc files exact-readback verified. It prepares32 real Frame/WGPU readbacks, font-coverage and transform controls, empirical ink/backplate/corridor findings, and source/dependency/executable/output hashes. It is NOT yet compiled or executed; prior20 standalone measurement/corridor tests remain separate evidence. The compiler/GPU gate stays sequential with navigation build. In parallel, the Scenario-specific production contribution authorized in #7 comment785 now has typed sparse model, scoped commands, deletion/remap preflight and source row-identity edits plus authored regressions; it is still uncommitted/uncompiled and not a peer import yet. Public schema version and aggregate accounting remain the coordinated codec-owner gate; no source8 compatibility claim.Codex-ytr83r: actual WGPU evaluator compiled and executed32 probes, all font/manual-payload/translation controls valid, but returned2 with8 italic corridor findings (12 advance-spill cases total). Every sample remained inside its 3x2 padded backplate and left blocker pixels unchanged; the rejected policy placed text at the corridor edge without reserving left ink overhang. This is a caller-policy finding, not a violation of the helper's narrower advance-bounds contract. Complete evidence is published at http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/31695dcc496758d43e57ae2018e39dc0e7541bbf/harness/experiments/scenario-label-wgpu-rejection-20260913/README.md . All47 files exact-readback verified; pixels.zip's225 raw outputs match the original output manifest. Binary and all explicit dependency/native inputs remained stable. A second empirical policy will reserve an inset inside the unchanged corridor; no production/native acceptance claimed.
First
ecc49e0core compile rejected one missing EditContext argument in source_project/source_migration.rs. All584 gate inputs stayed unchanged; this failure is preserved. The call is corrected for the next frozen candidate. A separate source audit found direct SVG export could silently emit a blank Scenario image despite App's existing guard; a narrow fallible exporter correction and regressions are prepared, uncompiled. Public schema integration remains pending with #7 owner.Codex-ytr83r: the revised standalone WGPU caller policy passed32 probes,0 invalid controls,0 findings;12 advance-spill cases remain correctly distinguished from ink bounds. The unchanged160/760 corridor now reserves3 units on each side. Exact source
a4d1efc, dependency/native/source/executable stability and all225 raw output ZIP entries are verified. Published report: http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/51797790bd21e4c61b2de9c331c84cdc64379f15/harness/experiments/scenario-label-wgpu-inset-20260913/README.md . All65 files across both new evidence archives were read back by exact blob/size. This is bounded empirical evidence, not universal overhang, production Scene or native label acceptance.Corrected core candidate
aed07176abis published (fixture file exact-readback verified). Actual26 Scenario model/source/reference lifecycle cases passed,0failed/ignored. The preceding9245 run exposed18 fixture admission failures because participant lifelines were placed in a default work viewpoint; correction sets explicit ParticipantInteraction in the two fixture scenarios and does not relax production validation. Earlier missing-context compile failure and fixture failure remain preserved. Broader core all-target tests are running on frozen584 inputs; strict/core aggregate codec/version and desktop projection/export gates remain pending. No schema-version or gesture acceptance claim.Codex-ytr83r /root checkpoint: core gates are closed successfully on
aed07176(26 focused,471 full executed,1ignored,strict core Clippy; unchanged584 inputs). Published evidence and two preceding failures: http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/e7ceff11afb85f5e944fa3a818acc04e464af2d3/harness/experiments/scenario-core-gates-20260913/README.md . Desktop all-target check found one test reading expected.project instead of expected.decoded.project; isolated one-line correction694efd6 has a fresh frozen desktop gate with exact12 focused regressions pending.Continuing owned renderer work in separate branch codex/scenario-renderer-bridge-ytr83r-20260913 so the gate source remains frozen. Narrow next slice follows published http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/e7ceff11afb85f5e944fa3a818acc04e464af2d3/harness/scenario-renderer-bridge.md : pure complete geometry resolver and actual Scene test adapter, consuming selectively imported #21 typed activation semantics from
aadc6396. Local import695685a preserves our label helper and omits unrelated Remove/header changes; not yet published/compiled and not a peer handoff. No workspace/gesture/camera/usage wiring or new crossing/fallback policy yet. Acceptance requires real geometry/nonmutation and typed activation/lifetime falsifiers before production paint integration.Codex-ytr83r /root: published combined renderer candidate
68a81c3f50on codex/scenario-renderer-bridge-ytr83r-20260913; all13 changed files sinceaed07176exact Gitea blob/size readback verified (598,495 bytes). It selectively imports #21 typed activation semantics, adds a pure complete saved/derived Scenario geometry resolver and actual Scene adapter, and adds an actual HTTP sparse-position round-trip/atomicity/no-op regression. No workspace/gesture/camera/usage wiring yet. Combined Windows listing →87 focused→full desktop→full server→strict desktop/server→GUI build is now started against591 frozen source inputs; no pass claimed yet. Linux remains user-paused.Source review rejected exact-lane float reconstruction, float anchor cancellation, missing lifetime/marker admission after operand movement, and origin-zero negative bounds. Corrected source preserves exact planned send coordinates, compares actual missing geometry diagnostics, and retains real bounds origin. Original rejected source, review, corrected manifest and bounded review limitations are accessible at http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/920b718f62c20ba3c58f664dae3c5ec6b0e65ce6/harness/experiments/scenario-resolver-review-20260913/README.md . Plan update plus prior694 desktop evidence totals51 published/readback-verified files,1,714,672 bytes.
694efd6desktop gate closed with check,965-test listing and exact12 focused passes; no full/Clippy/GUI result at694. Those broader gates are deliberately consolidated on68 to avoid duplicate builds. Archive: http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/920b718f62c20ba3c58f664dae3c5ec6b0e65ce6/harness/experiments/scenario-desktop-focused-20260913/README.md . Existing bridge note records the next reversible UI choice: preserve saved coordinates and present complete automatic fallback with explicit status when authored geometry is unsupported; no fallback edits or partial authored projection. This is design, not implemented acceptance.Codex-ytr83r /root actual combined68 gate: Windows all-target test build succeeded,1010 actual tests listed, all87 required members present. Focused run CLOSED86pass/1fail/0ignored/923filtered in18.67s,591 inputs unchanged before/after. Failure is the new feasible second-message520 control in post_fragment_death_cannot_disappear_and_feasible_operand_spacing_retains_its_marker. All53 typed activation/lifecycle/direct/atomic cases (including WGPU border continuity),12 dispatch/export/rename and21/22 resolver cases passed; no full/server/strict/GUI gate ran after the failure.
Parent and independent critic confirmed a production false rejection: frame148..567 retained92px padding below descendant475; moved message520 requires operandend570 and frameend612, but the old conditional tested raw footprint520 against567 before preserving padding. Corrected37be41092beb1c940f345072df1e017ce45fe2fc now compares the padded extent. Same test strengthened with exact actual Scene/frame/scope assertions; following Delete631 and two MissingGeometry negative controls retained. Fix published and both files decoded exact-readback verified (74,249bytes); no correction pass yet. A fresh gate is being prepared; old failure evidence remains intact and is being archived.
Workspace preparation is published/readback verified at75d4c39bd72fcc6ebf79eaa5280baa32267eed19 (7files48,679bytes): http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/75d4c39bd72fcc6ebf79eaa5280baa32267eed19/harness/experiments/scenario-workspace-preparation-20260913/README.md . Actual workspace wiring still waits for a passing geometry foundation. The separately prepared pure display adapter has bounded source review only. Current short32/heuristic label limitation is explicit; measured-label integration remains a separate actual-Scene/font/camera gate. Linux remains user-paused.
Codex-ytr83r /root publication follow-through for859: original failed68 renderer gate is now accessible at http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/0de2dfa1ed03553281b6a345c4a05f10ca7f589b/harness/experiments/scenario-renderer-gates-68a81c3-20260913/README.md . All30 new/changed archive files decoded exact-readback verified,1,133,542bytes. Preserves all26 original gate records,86/1 failure,591-input bindings and explicitly post-execution test-binary hash; no executable/full/GUI acceptance implied. Corrected37 fresh Windows listing is compiling, no new test result yet.
Separate prepared source
aa62f42b81on codex/scenario-workspace-ytr83r-20260913 contains the pure Scenario display adapter plus37's padding correction. Its4net files against37 are published and decoded exact-readback verified (188,344bytes). Source review found no bounded adapter defect; five new tests remain UNEXECUTED. It distinguishes requested Saved identity from complete Derived fallback geometry, exposes success diagnostics and saved latent IDs, refuses structural/identity errors, and separates inspection geometry from coordinate input. No actual workspace/controller/camera/usage/gesture wiring yet; those remain this session's owned next increment after a passing geometry foundation.Codex-ytr83r /root: corrected source
37be41092bpassed all87 exact focused Windows tests (0failed,0ignored,923filtered,18.98s), including the feasible520 frame/scope control and all retained activation/lifecycle negatives. All591 source inputs unchanged; listing contains1010 actual tests. Full desktop gate now running; server/strict/build remain pending. The passing geometry prerequisite allows the already-owned next workspace increment on codex/scenario-workspace-ytr83r-20260913 (published baselineaa62f42). Partitioned controller/explicit saved identity, origin-aware camera, and usage/reveal work; acceptance remains published workspace-preparation notes, including Saved A/B isolation, stale visit refusal, guarded Back, honest complete fallback, and real draft/history preservation. No workspace runtime or native acceptance claimed. Complete37 gate evidence will be published once closed; Linux remains paused.Codex-ytr83r /root: saved Scenario workspace candidate46e106c04e82e3d5b0acac43c99c7ee3e5a9c1b5 is committed/published on codex/scenario-workspace-ytr83r-20260913. All25 changed files (8added/17modified,940242bytes) decoded exact Gitea blob/size/local readback verified. This is SOURCE ONLY: formatting and bounded independent source review completed; no UI compilation/runtime/native pass. It wires explicit Saved/Derived identity and stable visits through workspace, controls, Back, actual Scene/query/reveal, complete fallback, unavailable state and origin-aware tiny Fit. Direct arrangement picker added; no new spacing gesture or measured-label policy. Corrections cover stale events clearing pending reveal, forged usage bounds, suspended Saved return, cross-layer retarget, deleted view/Undo and explicit Process/State navigation. Prepared tests use exact document/source/history and actual input/mounted paths.
Frozen foundation37be410 has now passed87 focused, full desktop1007/0failed/3ignored and all57 server tests, including scenario_layout::saved_scenario_positions_roundtrip_through_http_without_partial_or_noop_writes. All591 input bindings unchanged. Strict desktop/server Clippy running; foundation GUI build and UI gate still pending. Complete gate artifacts will be published when closed. Linux remains paused; #27 release ownership unchanged.
Codex-ytr83r /root: foundation37 gate is closed: 87 focused pass, full desktop1007 pass/0fail/3ignored, server57 pass, all591 inputs unchanged. Strict Clippy rejected five collapsible_if findings in the renderer; failed raw evidence is preserved and publication is being verified. No foundation GUI build ran. Style-only correction
aaf5fec28bis published, cherry-picked into the saved Scenario workspace as2c9cd2b3e6. No corrected-source runtime pass yet.The combined UI gate has started at2c9cd2b with fresh601 source/build/fixture inputs, one initial capture and workspace-package clearance preserving dependencies. Actual listing must match1045 source-derived expected tests;224 focused include all35 additions and affected Scenario/control/usage/reveal suites. Sequence list→focused→full desktop→strict desktop→GUI build; unchanged server/core scope retains exact37 server provenance. This consolidates UI and renderer style validation instead of repeating a standalone foundation GUI build. Native Saved A/B/Automatic, Fit, usage/Back, fallback repair and save/reopen remain pending. Linux remains paused and #27 integration/release ownership unchanged.
Codex-ytr83r /root publication follow-through: closed37 renderer evidence is accessible at http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/c26ee6d2634376b41a64b50230a68a640559c67d/harness/experiments/scenario-renderer-gates-37be410-20260913/README.md . All42 initial changed paths (2,146,070 bytes) were decoded Gitea/local/blob verified; parent independently compared all37 archived originals against the actual gate directory and all42 receipt records. The one-paragraph follow-up separately passed exact readback and clarifies retained57 server provenance versus fresh601 UI full/strict/GUI work. Includes all raw list/focused/full/server/failed-Clippy logs, sequential receipts, eleven identical591-input captures and explicitly post-execution-only test executable hash. No GUI acceptance at37 and no UI test pass yet. Source2c9cd2b is still compiling; native preparation is ready, pending actual fixture/test/build admission.
Codex-ytr83r /root continuation within owned #20 scope: while immutable UI2c runs its Windows gate, preparing an isolated next prototype on codex/scenario-spacing-ytr83r-20260913 from2c. No edits to the frozen UI worktree. Bounded target is existing Saved views: horizontal owned-lifeline spacing and vertical rendered Exchange-occurrence spacing using existing sparse core commands/actual resolver. No schema/version change, expanded-reference editing, resizing, route editing or label-policy claim.
Independent policy critique favors view-local body/label spacing plus a named explicit Reorder action over implicit semantic crossing, provisionally subject to native discoverability tests. Do not invent a new no-crossing chronology rule: successful resolver diagnostics stay visible; unsupported geometry must be refused without promising fallback as the drag preview. Concrete constraints: preserve dragged semantic selection (position commands return Diagram IDs), freeze displayed Fit camera during gestures, preserve exact sparse source/redo on zero motion/cancel, validate captured view visits, and make preview/commit/Undo/reopen agree. Existing same-parent SetSteps alone may leave saved absolute arrows stationary; its complete reorder/layout policy remains unresolved before gesture adoption. First independently implement only the pure spacing command/preview boundary and authored tests; no parallel compiler/native launch.
Codex-ytr83r /root first workspace gate2c is CLOSED at listing compilation: Cargo101, exactly two compile errors, all601 captured inputs unchanged before/after. No tests were listed/executed and no focused/full/strict/GUI stages ran. E0063: app/process_canvas.rs Scope constructor omitted scenario_view. E0433: new mounted adoption test requested iced::futures::executor, disabled in existing dependencies.
Corrected83e840e37f3c3d230382722e99e87bf865abb12e is committed/published on the same workspace branch: Process Scope has scenario_view:None; mounted test uses existing #[tokio::test] async harness with all assertions retained. No dependency/features or product requirement change. Formatting/diff checks pass; fresh same224/expected1045 gate preparation is underway. Preserve failed2c raw records; portable archive publication follows. The independent spacing prototype remains separate/uncompiled.
Codex-ytr83r /root: failed UI2c compile evidence is now portable at http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/31d2d7374484e6248a63bbc35e3d38fe66433604/harness/experiments/scenario-workspace-gates-2c9cd2b-20260913/README.md . All24 published archive paths exact-readback verified; parent independently compared all21 originals byte-for-byte. Corrected83 two files also decoded Gitea/local/blob verified (40024bytes).
Fresh83 listing gate now dispatched after desktop-only package clearance (same worktree; core/server/dependencies retained),601 inputs,224 focused/1045 expected members. Strict will explicitly run both -p oa-desktop -p oa-server --all-targets -D warnings: prior37 desktop failure never established server strict acceptance, so the earlier desktop-only retry plan was insufficient. Server test57 provenance is still retained without a redundant server test run. No fresh runtime pass yet.
Codex-ytr83r /root: isolated pure spacing prototype is published at
28b7dc5b30on codex/scenario-spacing-ytr83r-20260913 (457a2c2prototype plus83 compile correction). All3 net files against83 exact decoded Gitea/local/blob readback verified,182380bytes. Nine tests authored, UNEXECUTED; module remains cfg(test), with no shipped drag feature. Capture uses actually drawn owned lanes/Exchange occurrences; preparation returns no-op, structured refusal, or existing core command + proposed Project + actual resolved Scene. It retains exact sparse source/redo on zero motion and refuses fallback as a promised preview. Independent source review found one geometry-evaluator omission; corrected comparison now includes ordered insertion-slot parent/before/y/label. No remaining demonstrated bounded source defect; Create/Delete/Timer/nested-operand motion and runtime preview cost remain untested.A separate source critique of intentional Saved Reorder confirms no generic anchor-permutation policy yet: sparse records position messages, while mixed automatic shapes and already-crossed rows lack interchangeable position slots. Preserving another view's coordinate records does not guarantee unchanged appearance after shared semantic reorder. Next gesture work must keep view-local spacing separate, retain honest sequence-order actions, and preview actual resolved geometry before promising a Saved graphical reorder. Native discoverability and precise post-commit selection/camera are still acceptance gates.
UI83 listing is still compiling; compiler reported private_interfaces on Scope.scenario_view exposing crate-private Representation. Parent will collect focused runtime findings before correcting that visibility warning and starting full/strict/GUI validation. No current UI test pass.
Codex-ytr83r /root resumed Windows workspace acceptance. UI83 compiled and listed1045 tests; the original selection check failed because two expected names used canvas_workspace::tests instead of canvas_workspace::camera_policy_tests. The preserved listing archive is published at http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/deaec47a12eacf4c2c341488f3c6099d7f302d99/harness/experiments/scenario-workspace-list-83e840e-20260913/README.md (25 paths exact remote readback).
A separate direct-binary recovery used the corrected224 exact names and the same compiled83 executable: 222 passed,2 failed,0 ignored,821 filtered,146.41s;601 source inputs unchanged after execution. Failures are production_scenario_camera_external_controls_bounds_and_retained_deltas_cancel_old_drags (pan assertion) and production_scenario_canvas_keeps_bounds_draft_identity_and_camera_through_editing (insertion slot assertion). Diagnosing production behavior versus stale coordinate assumptions before correction. Private-interface warning also remains to fix. No full UI, strict, or GUI pass claimed. Closed focused evidence is being published; same owned workspace scope, parent compiler slot, Linux remains user-paused.
Codex-ytr83r /root: focused83 failure archive is now portable at http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/c455b7ce9d2661405623efaeb0c958df8b701b07/harness/experiments/scenario-workspace-focused-recovery83-20260913/README.md . All18 archive paths exact-readback verified; parent independently compared all15 originals.
Correction
cb5d50de03is published on the same workspace branch; both changed files exact remote/local/blob verified (92033bytes). The failures exposed stale evaluator assumptions: Iced scrollable operations report unscrolled child bounds, while retained focus has scrolled the palette; the test now clicks the actual visible Action center and explicitly checks Choose(Action) before its unchanged insertion/draft/history guards. The pan test now uses the displayed Fit camera, then checks ordered screen deltas, retained scale and exit from Fit; all stale-event/source guards remain. Production camera/tool behavior is unchanged. Scope.scenario_view is narrowed to pub(crate), resolving the reported visibility mismatch. Formatting/diff check pass; corrected runtime not yet executed. New list→224focused→full desktop→strict desktop+server→GUI recipe is being finalized, retaining same1045 expected membership and existing dependency cache.Codex-ytr83r /root: Windows UIcb5d50de03a002079da17e6f92ea44c32f7ece75 now compiles and passes exact1045 listing and224 focused tests (0 failed/ignored,821 filtered,111.21s), including both corrected mounted interaction evaluators. All601 captured inputs unchanged; test binary149771264bytes SHA256 d6922e9263106d8f0182670492c4ccd3a604fc7a274688bed6a9ceb650eca0a7 retained across focused execution. Full desktop suite is now running; both desktop/server strict and GUI build remain pending.
New primary Capella native comparison is published: http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/34cdca132e6d8f64c99e7b8f691f31c4b4c62ef2/harness/experiments/capella-scenario-observations-20260913/README.md . All30 archive files exact-readback verified. In one isolated OA scenario, receiver-execution drag moved the whole message79px while semantic .capella bytes stayed exact and .aird changed5 lines; header drag moved one lifeline80px. Two separate Undo actions plusSave restored BOTH original files byte-exact. Two arrow-body drag attempts did not visibly move the message; this is bounded observation, not a universal Capella claim. App closed normally after saving.
Separate spacing branch now has explicit drawn hit roles under source review, preserving existing selection precedence; App-owned preview/session integration is in progress there, with original-camera deltas, cached actualScene, one Document command on release, and token/stamp cancellation. No spacing runtime or native acceptance yet. UIcb5 source remains frozen, with one parent-owned build/test slot.
Codex-ytr83r checkpoint: desktop full run on
cb5d50de03closed with 1,040 passed, 2 failed, 3 existing ignored, 0 filtered (974.39s). All 601 captured inputs and executable SHA d6922e9263106d8f0182670492c4ccd3a604fc7a274688bed6a9ceb650eca0a7 remained unchanged. The preceding exact focused224 passed. Strict desktop/server and GUI build were not run after this failure.Both failures occur before their behavioral assertions: legacy fixtures directly assign page/owner fields and skip the new Scenario representation/live-visit initialization. Bounded corrections use actual navigation messages and retain/strengthen source-history and stale-context assertions; no production fix is indicated by those failures. Exact failed-run evidence is being published in the existing evidence branch.
The separate Saved-spacing implementation now has cached immutable previews, frozen press camera, explicit header/message hit roles, atomic Document commit, cancellation, and 36 new evaluators (pure/controller/App/mounted/hit-role). Source review found and corrected a zoom-sensitive re-hit mismatch. This code is uncompiled/unexecuted. To avoid two successive expensive rebuilds, the next candidate combines the fixture corrections with this spacing change, then runs actual listing, targeted/full tests, both strict checks, build and native workflows. No release or completion claim; Linux remains user-paused.
Codex-ytr83r: failed cb5 run is now portable at http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/d6dd2b0920e062bdb33aa014f3bff85b158b8e49/harness/experiments/scenario-workspace-gates-cb5d50d-20260913/README.md . All37 archive files were byte/blob verified remotely; parent independently compared all34 original payloads (1,925,092 bytes) to the closed local run. Fixture corrections
fa694664a2are published and both full files remote-readback verified.Combined spacing candidate07e611fb9432b5164e43c326f3e3c7e75e1e6567 is committed and push-confirmed on codex/scenario-spacing-ytr83r-20260913, including those corrections. Production source review found no remaining concrete blocker after the scaled hit-revalidation fix; this is not runtime acceptance. Candidate gate is being finalized for1,082 listed tests,288 focused,4ignored (the fourth is a separate20-lane/1000-message/3-view timing diagnostic). Compilation/tests/strict/build/native remain pending at this checkpoint. The prior shared spacing decision is published at5bd2c0bec82ebf0e3a94b9d37828f4a1f9b541ae; DECISIONS exact remote readback passed.
The user explicitly reaffirmed that ALL Codex peers in Gitea operate on completely separate machines. Build slots, disk space, and native input are local per machine; only subagents of this task share my workspace. Peer handoffs continue to use Gitea-accessible artifacts. Linux remains paused by the user.
Codex-ytr83r /root: combined Saved Scenario source
c4a2cf63f11818cf7fc766acf3a2779768a2a658oncodex/scenario-spacing-ytr83r-20260913now compiles on Windows. Actual desktop inventory passed: 1,082 tests, all 288 exact focused names present, 610 source/config inputs unchanged; bound test EXE 150,361,088 bytes, SHA256cf31c674a7ef6c19dbe72f65c660030b5af6127d6450e35117ffc201ef813249. Focused execution is now running; full/strict/native acceptance remains pending. These new gate logs are currently local-only and will be published as a closed evidence archive. The c4 commit adds only the user's updated AGENTS.md above production 07e611f; compiled inputs remain the reviewed combined spacing + navigation-fixture correction.The next label work remains separate and unwired. Published font-lifetime source investigation resolves initial font/renderer ordering. A bounded field-geometry experiment will use actual winning shaped-buffer clusters and explicit unsupported-coverage outcomes; it does not change the current frozen candidate. No production measured-label, Linux or release claim.
Codex-ytr83r /root: c4 focused run is closed: 286 passed / 2 failed / 0 ignored / 794 filtered, 610 inputs and the exact listed EXE unchanged. The first failure is stale fixture admission: presentation_tests toggled coordinate capability but supplied no new spacing Stamp, so no gesture was captured. Its old no-message assertion also predates the explicit Cancel packet. The second complete-Project failure differs only at A.updated_report.send_y (271.99994 versus 272): the fixture's fractional f32 screen start plus10 did not encode exactly10 units of displacement. Independent arithmetic reproduces the precision mechanism; production already uses actual submitted screen delta over captured scale.
Corrected test candidate 0409a481 is published on
codex/scenario-spacing-fixes-ytr83r-20260913; parent verified all three remote files (44,555 bytes). It establishes real Ready→fallback stamped cancellation, verifies an exact20-unit mounted packet while retaining the complete Project272/source/Undo/Redo assertions, and adds an independently specified fractional-packet regression. Test changes only; formatted and source-reviewed, NOT executed yet.I am running the complete 1,082-test inventory directly against the unchanged c4 executable before rebuilding, to expose other regressions in the same cycle. This is an explicitly separate diagnostic after a failed focused gate, not a full-gate pass. The frozen source and old evidence remain unchanged; corrected acceptance and GUI/native checks follow.
Codex-ytr83r /root: complete c4 diagnostic closed with 1,076 passed, the same two known failures, four ignored, zero filtered (765.34s). Exact 1,082-test inventory, all 610 source inputs, executable and runtime bindings remained unchanged. This remains diagnostic evidence after failed focused acceptance.
The complete closed archive is now published at fdfe43f4. Parent independently compared all 45 original payloads (2,519,298 bytes), then verified all 48 published files (2,535,834 bytes) by exact remote readback. Raw logs are included; peers need no access to local directories.
Reviewed test corrections
0409a481c7are now fast-forward integrated and published on codex/scenario-spacing-ytr83r-20260913. Attempt 3 captures 610 inputs, exactly three changed test files, expected 1,083 total / 289 focused / four ignored. Actual listing rebuild is currently compiling oa-desktop in the original workspace with the existing core cache retained. Corrected test/full/strict desktop+server/GUI/native acceptance remains pending. New native preparation preserves the old recipe and updates its explicit membership contract; no staging or launch has occurred. Linux remains user-paused.Separate source experiment handoff: 11c605f9, branch codex/scenario-label-fields-ytr83r-20260913, is now published and all three changed/new files exact-readback verified (53,161 bytes). It remains UNWIRED and UNCOMPILED, separate from frozen spacing0409.
The candidate extracts winning shaped-buffer cluster rectangles with explicit covered/truncated/unresolved source ranges. Fresh review prompted RTL-leading full and ellipsized paragraph cases and complete independent rectangle-set comparisons; corrected source review found no further concrete issue. There are 12 new normal field tests plus one ignored bounded lookup diagnostic, all unexecuted. System-font identities are diagnostic metadata, not pinned font bytes. A small isolated harness is being prepared to test this module without another desktop/core rebuild; no production navigation/paint adoption or performance claim.
Codex-ytr83r /root checkpoint: corrected spacing source
0409a481c7completed actual desktop listing (1,083 exact tests) and focused verification (289 passed, 0 failed, 0 ignored, 794 filtered; 377.92 s). All 610 source inputs stayed unchanged and both stages bind the same test executable. The two prior c4 failures and the added fractional-pointer regression now pass.Published portable archive: commit
dbf0661ce3on codex/behavior-anchor-plan-ytr83r-20260912, harness/experiments/scenario-spacing-gates-0409a48-20260913/README.md. Parent verified all 38 published files (1,497,017 bytes), including both raw logs, against local originals. Source and commands/environment/receipts are linked in that note. Prior failed diagnostic evidence remains preserved separately.This is focused regression evidence only; full desktop, desktop/server Clippy, GUI build and native acceptance remain outstanding. A concrete Scenario Details Properties route correction is source-reviewed and published on codex/scenario-details-ytr83r-20260913 at
8bf7607a3f, tracked in #24; next combined gates will include it. Unwired label experiment compiled separately, but execution is not accepted yet. Linux remains user-paused.Codex-ytr83r /root: the unwired label experiment at11c605 compiled successfully against the closed0409 library graph. Actual explicit listing admitted25 tests; serial normal execution reported21 passed,2 failed,2 ignored (25.45s), with unchanged source/executable bindings. Both failed before field_layout: the generic font did not form the tests' required ffi cluster. This is an evaluator/font precondition finding, not a demonstrated field-geometry defect.
The complete nonbinary evidence is published at
e859d65de5on codex/behavior-anchor-plan-ytr83r-20260912, harness/experiments/scenario-label-fields-11c605f-20260913/README.md. Parent verified all24 remote files (571,614 bytes), including raw failures and the earlier runner-dispatch diagnostic; no passing gate was substituted for the failure.Source-reviewed correction4c9bc87e4e66bba573dd63b23df5ea039f85d0ca is published on codex/scenario-label-fields-ytr83r-20260913. The two tests use an unmodified byte-pinned Noto Sans fixture with full OFL license and verify actual resolved face bytes/index. Original positive ffi and complete geometry assertions remain; the Auto case also proves real Basic clusters before final Advanced shaping. Font-loading cases must each run alone in a fresh process, so normal membership becomes21 with4ignored and all three font-related isolated checks remain separately required. Corrected compilation/execution is pending; production algorithm and font policy are unchanged.
Primary Scenario/Details source8bf7607 is now integrated and published on the spacing branch. Its fresh1089/295 gate has611 unchanged captured inputs at admission and is currently compiling oa-desktop from the original checkout. Full/strict/GUI/native acceptance remains open.
Codex-ytr83r /root continuing owned label outcome: corrected4c9 experiment now compiled and actually passed all25-listed functional partition checks on Windows (21 normal,4 ignored; each of three mandatory font-sensitive tests separately passed1/24filtered). Evidence is local-only pending portable archive publication; no native rendering/navigation acceptance.
The optional real4096-scalar diagnostic also passed exact coverage/geometry assertions but exposed slow field lookup in debug: plain scalars6.647/3.877/2.402 seconds; combining-heavy1.504/1.904/1.268 seconds. Source inspection finds repeated all-cluster/all-span scans and linear rectangle dedup. This changes the next step: I am taking the bounded lookup performance correction within this owned experiment on planned remote branch codex/scenario-label-lookup-ytr83r-20260913. Acceptance: preserve complete old/new outputs (including ordering, shared ligatures, bidi pieces, unresolved/truncated distinctions and guards), all existing functional checks, and measured improvement on the same long-field workloads. No claim of a native responsiveness threshold or production adoption. Published4c9 remains the comparison baseline.
Separately, combined8bf desktop LIST passed1089 exact names with611 inputs unchanged. Focused295 dispatch exceeded the Windows command-line limit before Cargo/test launch; a bounded exact-name batch runner is being prepared, preserving closed listing evidence. Full/strict/GUI/native work remains outstanding; Linux stays user-paused.
Portable corrected label evidence is published at
1d8a0dd8b6on codex/behavior-anchor-plan-ytr83r-20260912: report. Parent compared all29 copied originals and all34 committed files (655,003 bytes), confirmed push, and read back the remote report exactly. Raw receipts/logs preserve original line endings.All24 functional cases passed (21 normal plus3 separate font-sensitive tests); the optional timing case passed exact geometry but measured the slow debug whole-field lookups recorded in comment969. This is the actual 4c9 baseline, not production/native acceptance. The resulting lookup correction now has a bounded interval index, stable rectangle deduplication and four differential tests against the unchanged original algorithm. Parent and independent source review found no blocker; compilation/timing verification is still pending on its separate branch. Existing source limits, geometry/coverage semantics and renderer adoption scope are unchanged.
The repaired desktop focused runner has actually launched its first107-test batch using the original8bf executable; no relisting or source rebuild was needed. Aggregate295/full/strict/GUI/native acceptance remains open.
Codex-ytr83r /root: indexed label source
9b99e7c626now passed all28 functional cases (25 normal plus3 fresh-process font checks), and the separate timing diagnostic passed exact old/new full results and independent Paragraph geometry. Published evidence atad4fce6280on codex/behavior-anchor-plan-ytr83r-20260912: report, recipes and raw results. Parent compared29 originals and all34 committed files (672,807bytes), confirmed exact remote ref and report bytes. For the4096-plain-scalar debug sample, preserved old lookup took3387.5ms; indexed calls10.4–22.9ms, fresh resolution+lookup90.1–174.4ms. Combining samples and timing jitter are retained. This is an unwired CPU experiment, not a native latency threshold or renderer/navigation adoption.Combined8bf desktop focused295 passed in three actual107/101/87 batches. Its portable recovery evidence was published at7122f91671b56a5f23f1495ff2e78dcaec3661ed: report. No synthetic single-process filtered count is used.
The subsequent actual full desktop run closed0:1085passed,0failed,4designated ignored,0filtered,939.74s. Parent verified exact1089 raw membership, ignored benchmark identities, and unchanged611-source/same-EXE bindings. Full evidence is local-only pending the next portable gate archive. Desktop+server strict Clippy is now running; GUI and native acceptance remain pending. I have read #27's explicit stopped-session handoff; integration/release ownership remains with Codex-956atf. Linux stays user-paused.