You can't select multiple items in diagrams and perform actions on them #29

Open
opened 2026-09-13 16:06:39 +00:00 by sorokin.oleg.edu · 37 comments
Owner

For example - you can't select multiple functions and move them all at once. Classically - selecting multiple elements is done via Click + Shift combination
Similar use cases should be discovered and implemented

For example - you can't select multiple functions and move them all at once. Classically - selecting multiple elements is done via Click + Shift combination Similar use cases should be discovered and implemented
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root claims the multiple-selection and group-action outcome. Planned branch codex/multiselect-9e8r6t-20260923 will start from the published b8685416f5 canvas checkpoint, after fetching and inspecting it. My prior transition lifecycle contribution is delivered separately in #28/#27; no compiler or GUI is running.

Initial scope is a coherent selection/gesture contract across existing diagram families, beginning with the reported Shift+click and moving several functions together. I will map realistic related actions and current storage/projection semantics before implementation, including nested ownership, explicit versus inherited motion, connection routes/labels, cancellation, Undo/Redo, source persistence and pending/read-only state. Acceptance must cover a user-visible group action as one coherent edit with unchanged semantic identities and independently checked geometry; tests alone will not substitute for the native workflow.

This claim does not adopt a resize policy or take over #16/#27, State bend/attachment work already delivered in #23/#33, or the peer's ongoing traceability-view work #31. I will partition concrete shared-file interfaces after inspecting current branches and record overlap before implementation. It does not presume all diagram kinds have the same positioning semantics or reduce the request to an ordinary-diagram-only feature.

Codex-9e8r6t /root claims the multiple-selection and group-action outcome. Planned branch codex/multiselect-9e8r6t-20260923 will start from the published b8685416f56e53e30bd11ecf93a54cea10ac8458 canvas checkpoint, after fetching and inspecting it. My prior transition lifecycle contribution is delivered separately in #28/#27; no compiler or GUI is running. Initial scope is a coherent selection/gesture contract across existing diagram families, beginning with the reported Shift+click and moving several functions together. I will map realistic related actions and current storage/projection semantics before implementation, including nested ownership, explicit versus inherited motion, connection routes/labels, cancellation, Undo/Redo, source persistence and pending/read-only state. Acceptance must cover a user-visible group action as one coherent edit with unchanged semantic identities and independently checked geometry; tests alone will not substitute for the native workflow. This claim does not adopt a resize policy or take over #16/#27, State bend/attachment work already delivered in #23/#33, or the peer's ongoing traceability-view work #31. I will partition concrete shared-file interfaces after inspecting current branches and record overlap before implementation. It does not presume all diagram kinds have the same positioning semantics or reduce the request to an ordinary-diagram-only feature.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t design checkpoint: fetched exact b8685416f5 and created the isolated codex/multiselect-9e8r6t-20260923 worktree. Two independent source investigations agree on a material foundation: sequential MoveNode batches fail to translate authored pins between independently selected roots. I am implementing a pure simultaneous placement planner (union of selected roots/visual descendants, one route pass, existing atomic EditNode/SetEdgeRoute batch). It introduces no wire command or source schema.

Concrete ownership for that step: new core diagram_edit module, its lib export and group_movement tests. Desktop selection and gesture adapters will be separate changes after the contract review. Process/Scenario are derived-order surfaces: their appropriate group operation is stable-block reorder with existing owner/topology/temporal validation, not invented free XY layout. Allocation group drag must retain assignment meaning and use one all-or-nothing destination plan; explicit Arrange-only remains geometry-only. Shared primary/selection identity must preserve qualified occurrences and exact placements.

This is implementation in progress, not passed feature acceptance. #16 resize policy and #31 traceability navigation remain peer-owned. A subsequent desktop change will touch ordinary/State selection/gesture paths and shared app admission; those will be partitioned explicitly before implementation. Group removal and native cross-family verification remain in scope.

Codex-9e8r6t design checkpoint: fetched exact b8685416f56e53e30bd11ecf93a54cea10ac8458 and created the isolated codex/multiselect-9e8r6t-20260923 worktree. Two independent source investigations agree on a material foundation: sequential MoveNode batches fail to translate authored pins between independently selected roots. I am implementing a pure simultaneous placement planner (union of selected roots/visual descendants, one route pass, existing atomic EditNode/SetEdgeRoute batch). It introduces no wire command or source schema. Concrete ownership for that step: new core diagram_edit module, its lib export and group_movement tests. Desktop selection and gesture adapters will be separate changes after the contract review. Process/Scenario are derived-order surfaces: their appropriate group operation is stable-block reorder with existing owner/topology/temporal validation, not invented free XY layout. Allocation group drag must retain assignment meaning and use one all-or-nothing destination plan; explicit Arrange-only remains geometry-only. Shared primary/selection identity must preserve qualified occurrences and exact placements. This is implementation in progress, not passed feature acceptance. #16 resize policy and #31 traceability navigation remain peer-owned. A subsequent desktop change will touch ordinary/State selection/gesture paths and shared app admission; those will be partitioned explicitly before implementation. Group removal and native cross-family verification remain in scope.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t: the first pure simultaneous-movement gate passes 5 new group tests plus 13 existing State-view tests on 722 unchanged captured inputs (Windows Rust 1.98.1); these are local foundation results, not GUI acceptance. Independent review found no blocking correctness defect and requested direct Allocation/Traceability ancestry coverage plus nondefault attachment/anchor preservation. Those evaluator extensions are underway.

Next concrete desktop ownership: new diagram_selection and app/multiselect modules; minimal app.rs field/event/admission hooks; ordinary diagram.rs selection/gesture rendering; passive modifier propagation in diagram/focus.rs; scoped group controls/context actions in views.rs/model_menu.rs. Existing diagram_usage identity types are reused without editing that peer-owned module. This may overlap #31's views.rs/app.rs lines but does not change its projection explanation, placement destination logic or traces review. I will preserve actual peer changes during integration. State/Allocation/derived behavior adapters and aggregate removal remain subsequent work within this same claim, not waived scope.

Codex-9e8r6t: the first pure simultaneous-movement gate passes 5 new group tests plus 13 existing State-view tests on 722 unchanged captured inputs (Windows Rust 1.98.1); these are local foundation results, not GUI acceptance. Independent review found no blocking correctness defect and requested direct Allocation/Traceability ancestry coverage plus nondefault attachment/anchor preservation. Those evaluator extensions are underway. Next concrete desktop ownership: new diagram_selection and app/multiselect modules; minimal app.rs field/event/admission hooks; ordinary diagram.rs selection/gesture rendering; passive modifier propagation in diagram/focus.rs; scoped group controls/context actions in views.rs/model_menu.rs. Existing diagram_usage identity types are reused without editing that peer-owned module. This may overlap #31's views.rs/app.rs lines but does not change its projection explanation, placement destination logic or traces review. I will preserve actual peer changes during integration. State/Allocation/derived behavior adapters and aggregate removal remain subsequent work within this same claim, not waived scope.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t local checkpoint: ordinary saved-view adapter now includes exact typed multi-selection, Shift toggle, selected-group movement with one simultaneous geometry plan, captured context menu Add/Remove/Inspect, visible group count and primary-property scope, and atomic Hide. Unsupported mixed/work Allocation movement refuses the entire gesture; stationary clicks still collapse normally. Other diagram-family adapters and aggregate model deletion remain required work, not completed scope.

Windows full desktop gate passed 1,254 tests / 0 failed / 6 existing ignored on 729 unchanged captured inputs (Rust 1.98.1, single Cargo job, incremental disabled). It covers four new mounted modifier/focus tests, exact model/source history, stale/ABA event rejection, mixed-selection/cancellation/pan lifetimes and legacy queued-singleton protection. Prior failed gates retained: initial missing-field/private-method wiring errors, then a real Placement-properties reconciliation regression found by the broader suite and corrected. A subsequent small viewport check delegates to the frozen geometry gesture too; affected final checks remain pending. Expanded core/native-checker tests, strict lint and final GUI build are next, followed by native verification. All code/evidence remains uncommitted/local-only and is not yet a peer handoff or full issue acceptance.

Codex-9e8r6t local checkpoint: ordinary saved-view adapter now includes exact typed multi-selection, Shift toggle, selected-group movement with one simultaneous geometry plan, captured context menu Add/Remove/Inspect, visible group count and primary-property scope, and atomic Hide. Unsupported mixed/work Allocation movement refuses the entire gesture; stationary clicks still collapse normally. Other diagram-family adapters and aggregate model deletion remain required work, not completed scope. Windows full desktop gate passed 1,254 tests / 0 failed / 6 existing ignored on 729 unchanged captured inputs (Rust 1.98.1, single Cargo job, incremental disabled). It covers four new mounted modifier/focus tests, exact model/source history, stale/ABA event rejection, mixed-selection/cancellation/pan lifetimes and legacy queued-singleton protection. Prior failed gates retained: initial missing-field/private-method wiring errors, then a real Placement-properties reconciliation regression found by the broader suite and corrected. A subsequent small viewport check delegates to the frozen geometry gesture too; affected final checks remain pending. Expanded core/native-checker tests, strict lint and final GUI build are next, followed by native verification. All code/evidence remains uncommitted/local-only and is not yet a peer handoff or full issue acceptance.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t verification checkpoint: ordinary saved-view source is committed locally as 12a7352dde on codex/multiselect-9e8r6t-20260923, still unpublished. Exact Git-blob comparison confirms all 729 captured build/test inputs match that commit (input-map SHA256 55a5f354bb5049a8c77ba9bafa833438ebf754649b0cf5d175d0c8dcfcedd7bb). Windows desktop-4 passes 1,256 tests / 0 failed / 6 existing ignored; core-3 passes 7 group + 13 State + 10 independent-checker tests; strict Clippy for oa-core/oa-desktop all targets passes. Single Cargo job, incremental disabled, Rust/Cargo 1.98.1 gnullvm.

Fresh review found and corrected held Shift being lost when save/export replaced the canvas tree. The owner now retains passive modifiers while still retiring pointer gestures; mounted tests cover Shift before busy, release during busy and window unfocus. Earlier failed gates remain captured, including the Placement-properties regression and checker rejection of ordinary completeness warnings; the checker still rejects source errors and whole-model drift. Native checker and Windows GUI builds are now being captured from the identified source commit, then actual native move/save/Undo/Redo/Hide/reopen checks follow. No native acceptance, peer handoff, integration or full #29 closure claimed. State adapter design is recorded locally; State/Allocation/Process/Scenario and aggregate model deletion remain required work.

Codex-9e8r6t verification checkpoint: ordinary saved-view source is committed locally as 12a7352ddef5f69a144ead8219a50916233d63a9 on codex/multiselect-9e8r6t-20260923, still unpublished. Exact Git-blob comparison confirms all 729 captured build/test inputs match that commit (input-map SHA256 55a5f354bb5049a8c77ba9bafa833438ebf754649b0cf5d175d0c8dcfcedd7bb). Windows desktop-4 passes 1,256 tests / 0 failed / 6 existing ignored; core-3 passes 7 group + 13 State + 10 independent-checker tests; strict Clippy for oa-core/oa-desktop all targets passes. Single Cargo job, incremental disabled, Rust/Cargo 1.98.1 gnullvm. Fresh review found and corrected held Shift being lost when save/export replaced the canvas tree. The owner now retains passive modifiers while still retiring pointer gestures; mounted tests cover Shift before busy, release during busy and window unfocus. Earlier failed gates remain captured, including the Placement-properties regression and checker rejection of ordinary completeness warnings; the checker still rejects source errors and whole-model drift. Native checker and Windows GUI builds are now being captured from the identified source commit, then actual native move/save/Undo/Redo/Hide/reopen checks follow. No native acceptance, peer handoff, integration or full #29 closure claimed. State adapter design is recorded locally; State/Allocation/Process/Scenario and aggregate model deletion remain required work.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t native checkpoint (still local-only): run-1 against source12a7352 completed actual context Add, group drag, Save, one-step Undo/Redo, group Hide and reopen. All nine saved complete-Project checks passed; moved A/B/child and internal pins share delta(100,60), all other records preserved. Exact nine-file source inventories restore through both history sequences; only views/diagram_oa_view.arcadia changes. Normal close0, empty app logs, pinned binaries/fixture unchanged. Native context Add does not claim held-Shift injection or SA native coverage.

The run exposed selection feedback resizing/refitting the canvas: forming a group shifted nodes under the pointer. Independent review confirmed it. A narrow correction now reserves a fixed selection/status strip and exposes the Shift-click hint. Full Windows desktop-5 passes1257/0/6existingignored on729 unchanged inputs (map99dc46645236e674244e7c4867595a6000d3d85b54bcc9ab2b0c601923ecf66c), including actual mounted canvas/camera equality across0/1/group/mixed transitions. Correction remains uncommitted while strict lint runs; build and fresh native run-2 follow. Both native runs and prior failures will be retained in portable evidence before peer handoff. No integration/full-issue acceptance claimed; State/Allocation/Process/Scenario/aggregate deletion remain required.

Codex-9e8r6t native checkpoint (still local-only): run-1 against source12a7352 completed actual context Add, group drag, Save, one-step Undo/Redo, group Hide and reopen. All nine saved complete-Project checks passed; moved A/B/child and internal pins share delta(100,60), all other records preserved. Exact nine-file source inventories restore through both history sequences; only views/diagram_oa_view.arcadia changes. Normal close0, empty app logs, pinned binaries/fixture unchanged. Native context Add does not claim held-Shift injection or SA native coverage. The run exposed selection feedback resizing/refitting the canvas: forming a group shifted nodes under the pointer. Independent review confirmed it. A narrow correction now reserves a fixed selection/status strip and exposes the Shift-click hint. Full Windows desktop-5 passes1257/0/6existingignored on729 unchanged inputs (map99dc46645236e674244e7c4867595a6000d3d85b54bcc9ab2b0c601923ecf66c), including actual mounted canvas/camera equality across0/1/group/mixed transitions. Correction remains uncommitted while strict lint runs; build and fresh native run-2 follow. Both native runs and prior failures will be retained in portable evidence before peer handoff. No integration/full-issue acceptance claimed; State/Allocation/Process/Scenario/aggregate deletion remain required.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root delivered the ordinary saved-view contribution at 7e348d967d on codex/multiselect-9e8r6t-20260923; push/exact remote ref and report/pin-file blob readback confirmed. Final source is f6a6010bae, following 12a7352, based on b868541.

Report, reproduction commands and portable evidence: exact typed multi-selection, context Add/Remove/Inspect, one atomic group move including visual descendants/internal pins, and placement-only group Hide with primary-only property editing. Whole-set/stale admission and modifier/pointer lifetimes are preserved. Native run 1 exposed a selection-driven viewport jump; f6a6010 reserves fixed feedback space, and run 2 verifies the correction across selection and Hide/Undo. No new schema/wire command.

Final Windows desktop 1,257 passed / 0 failed / 6 existing ignored; core 7 group + 13 State + 10 checker tests passed; strict core/desktop all-target Clippy, formatting and both builds passed. Both native runs closed normally with empty app logs, 18 complete-Project checks and exact nine-file Undo/Redo/reopen relationships. Only the OA saved-view source file changes. All 729 final captured inputs equal the committed Git blobs. Portable checks preserve 19 runs including five failed historical gates; separate incident preserves one checker launch without runtime environment and the successful byte-identical retry. Parent reverified all 41 evidence files exported from the staged Git index, including both archives and source identity.

Scope limits remain explicit: native context Add is not held-Shift injection; native fixture is OA Activities while App tests exercise SA Functions. Minimum-window/DPI and full combined release are not claimed. State, Allocation, Process/Scenario group adapters and aggregate semantic deletion are still required; #29 remains open and owned here. Next is the State adapter under the published State design/critique. Linux remains user-paused.

Codex-9e8r6t /root delivered the ordinary saved-view contribution at 7e348d967d1787c052a145b7448636613a6a7054 on codex/multiselect-9e8r6t-20260923; push/exact remote ref and report/pin-file blob readback confirmed. Final source is f6a6010baed9e6164a1fcc7ecd58256a562827d7, following 12a7352, based on b868541. [Report, reproduction commands and portable evidence](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/7e348d967d1787c052a145b7448636613a6a7054/harness/multiselect-saved-view-20260923.md): exact typed multi-selection, context Add/Remove/Inspect, one atomic group move including visual descendants/internal pins, and placement-only group Hide with primary-only property editing. Whole-set/stale admission and modifier/pointer lifetimes are preserved. Native run 1 exposed a selection-driven viewport jump; f6a6010 reserves fixed feedback space, and run 2 verifies the correction across selection and Hide/Undo. No new schema/wire command. Final Windows desktop 1,257 passed / 0 failed / 6 existing ignored; core 7 group + 13 State + 10 checker tests passed; strict core/desktop all-target Clippy, formatting and both builds passed. Both native runs closed normally with empty app logs, 18 complete-Project checks and exact nine-file Undo/Redo/reopen relationships. Only the OA saved-view source file changes. All 729 final captured inputs equal the committed Git blobs. Portable checks preserve 19 runs including five failed historical gates; separate incident preserves one checker launch without runtime environment and the successful byte-identical retry. Parent reverified all 41 evidence files exported from the staged Git index, including both archives and source identity. Scope limits remain explicit: native context Add is not held-Shift injection; native fixture is OA Activities while App tests exercise SA Functions. Minimum-window/DPI and full combined release are not claimed. State, Allocation, Process/Scenario group adapters and aggregate semantic deletion are still required; #29 remains open and owned here. Next is the State adapter under the published State design/critique. Linux remains user-paused.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root continues the owned State adapter outcome on follow-up branch codex/multiselect-state-9e8r6t-20260923 from delivered 7e348d967d. Saved-view delivery branch remains fixed for integration. State design and falsification review is the starting contract, not implementation evidence.

Scope: exact State placement/edge/action-row selection and primary inspection, contextual Add/Remove, unsnapped captured placement-group movement using the existing simultaneous planner, diagram-only preview, and atomic placement-only Hide. Preserve ordinary ten-unit movement, State five-unit bend editing, boundary-projected entry/exit geometry, route/attachment metadata, draft/read-only guards and early stale rejection. Row targets must not promote to owner placements; unsupported mixtures and aggregate model deletion remain explicit refusals until their own whole-set operations exist.

Acceptance: independent complete-Project/source/history expectations for State groups including unrelated roots, selected ancestor/descendant, boundary entry/exit cases, internal/external pins and row reassignment; ordered pointer/focus/cancellation and stale document/view/owner/tool tests; relevant existing State bend/attachment regressions; actual native State group move/Hide/history/reopen on an identified Windows build. No schema changes or takeover of resize/traceability/integration ownership. New branch is local-only at this claim; no compiler or GUI is running.

Codex-9e8r6t /root continues the owned State adapter outcome on follow-up branch codex/multiselect-state-9e8r6t-20260923 from delivered 7e348d967d1787c052a145b7448636613a6a7054. Saved-view delivery branch remains fixed for integration. [State design and falsification review](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/7e348d967d1787c052a145b7448636613a6a7054/harness/multiselect-state-adapter-design-20260923.md) is the starting contract, not implementation evidence. Scope: exact State placement/edge/action-row selection and primary inspection, contextual Add/Remove, unsnapped captured placement-group movement using the existing simultaneous planner, diagram-only preview, and atomic placement-only Hide. Preserve ordinary ten-unit movement, State five-unit bend editing, boundary-projected entry/exit geometry, route/attachment metadata, draft/read-only guards and early stale rejection. Row targets must not promote to owner placements; unsupported mixtures and aggregate model deletion remain explicit refusals until their own whole-set operations exist. Acceptance: independent complete-Project/source/history expectations for State groups including unrelated roots, selected ancestor/descendant, boundary entry/exit cases, internal/external pins and row reassignment; ordered pointer/focus/cancellation and stale document/view/owner/tool tests; relevant existing State bend/attachment regressions; actual native State group move/Hide/history/reopen on an identified Windows build. No schema changes or takeover of resize/traceability/integration ownership. New branch is local-only at this claim; no compiler or GUI is running.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root State checkpoint, local-only above7e348d9 on codex/multiselect-state-9e8r6t-20260923. Exact placement/edge/row selection, State primary inspection, contextual target transport, unsnapped shared group gesture/diagram-only preview and atomic Move/Hide are implemented. Fixed-height State selection feedback and an always-reserved unplaced-picker slot address selection/Hide-driven viewport refit; new mounted tests exercise all-placed→missing→Undo.

Fresh independent review found two concrete issues being corrected: native checker f32 delta inference from a nonzero anchor can falsely reject correct fractional movement; same-context queued legacy State Select/Move/Remove refusal occurs after reveal/allocation side effects. Corrections are queued with nonbinary-delta and complete shared-state regression assertions. Added singleton-route selection-path checks are also being prepared; older None-selection canvas tests alone are insufficient.

First native checker test command passes11/0, but the wrapper correctly rejects its evidence capture because formatting changed model_menu.rs during that run (core source itself unchanged); a stable-input rerun is required and the first receipt is retained. Desktop compilation is running and has reported a test-helper name collision to fix. No native State run, final gate, publication or integration acceptance is claimed yet. Prior ordinary delivery7e348d9 remains the verified handoff; Linux remains paused.

Codex-9e8r6t /root State checkpoint, local-only above7e348d9 on codex/multiselect-state-9e8r6t-20260923. Exact placement/edge/row selection, State primary inspection, contextual target transport, unsnapped shared group gesture/diagram-only preview and atomic Move/Hide are implemented. Fixed-height State selection feedback and an always-reserved unplaced-picker slot address selection/Hide-driven viewport refit; new mounted tests exercise all-placed→missing→Undo. Fresh independent review found two concrete issues being corrected: native checker f32 delta inference from a nonzero anchor can falsely reject correct fractional movement; same-context queued legacy State Select/Move/Remove refusal occurs after reveal/allocation side effects. Corrections are queued with nonbinary-delta and complete shared-state regression assertions. Added singleton-route selection-path checks are also being prepared; older None-selection canvas tests alone are insufficient. First native checker test command passes11/0, but the wrapper correctly rejects its evidence capture because formatting changed model_menu.rs during that run (core source itself unchanged); a stable-input rerun is required and the first receipt is retained. Desktop compilation is running and has reported a test-helper name collision to fix. No native State run, final gate, publication or integration acceptance is claimed yet. Prior ordinary delivery7e348d9 remains the verified handoff; Linux remains paused.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root State validation checkpoint (still local-only above7e348d9): corrected core checker passes11/0; full Windows desktop passes1,286/0/6existingignored, including all29 new helper/App/mounted/canvas cases plus existing State bend/attachment/reconnect regressions. Both use733 unchanged inputs, map9cf85879dfb0bb5ec3b15c66b23df316e6bfe8451b6cf0c895bf7b9b5fbdde4a; map-to-archive bytes independently checked. Full command: cargo test -p oa-desktop --message-format=json -- --test-threads=1 under Rust/Cargo1.98.1 gnullvm, one job, incremental off. Compile13m20s; tests607.72s.

Fresh review's checker-origin and early queued-singleton admission fixes are applied and re-reviewed. Added SelectionSome singleton route tests pass, preserving5-unit bend snapping and reconnect/cancel behavior. Mounted State controls retain canvas/camera through selection and all-placed→Hide→Undo/Redo picker changes. First failed desktop compilation (test-helper name collision) and invalid first checker capture are retained as historical evidence.

Strict core/desktop all-target lint is now running. Matching GUI/checker builds and actual native State workflow remain required; no publication/integration/native acceptance yet. A read-only Process adapter candidate plus independent critique is buffered in versioned local documents, not implementation: column-slot permutation avoids invisible source-only reorder, and future aggregate removal must consider explicit→legacy interpretation changes. Current priority remains finishing and publishing the State contribution.

Codex-9e8r6t /root State validation checkpoint (still local-only above7e348d9): corrected core checker passes11/0; full Windows desktop passes1,286/0/6existingignored, including all29 new helper/App/mounted/canvas cases plus existing State bend/attachment/reconnect regressions. Both use733 unchanged inputs, map9cf85879dfb0bb5ec3b15c66b23df316e6bfe8451b6cf0c895bf7b9b5fbdde4a; map-to-archive bytes independently checked. Full command: cargo test -p oa-desktop --message-format=json -- --test-threads=1 under Rust/Cargo1.98.1 gnullvm, one job, incremental off. Compile13m20s; tests607.72s. Fresh review's checker-origin and early queued-singleton admission fixes are applied and re-reviewed. Added SelectionSome singleton route tests pass, preserving5-unit bend snapping and reconnect/cancel behavior. Mounted State controls retain canvas/camera through selection and all-placed→Hide→Undo/Redo picker changes. First failed desktop compilation (test-helper name collision) and invalid first checker capture are retained as historical evidence. Strict core/desktop all-target lint is now running. Matching GUI/checker builds and actual native State workflow remain required; no publication/integration/native acceptance yet. A read-only Process adapter candidate plus independent critique is buffered in versioned local documents, not implementation: column-slot permutation avoids invisible source-only reorder, and future aggregate removal must consider explicit→legacy interpretation changes. Current priority remains finishing and publishing the State contribution.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root State checkpoint, still local-only on codex/multiselect-state-9e8r6t-20260923: full desktop-2 source is now identified as 2a3b9ba822, exact Git-blob match for all 733 captured inputs. Strict lint first found large_enum_variant caused by the new optional exact menu target; 3480b54201 boxes that target (3-file change). Final strict core/desktop all-target Clippy and format pass, with 735 unchanged inputs exactly equal to final committed Git blobs (map4215d0ca0319282768f1acdf05c2c094ea7432e17ed3a715df73aa05cef851bf).

Input audit enumerated 71 literal Rust include references and found two compile-time fixtures outside the historical capture directory list: core attachment-workshop fixture and CLI textual-authoring fixture. Final helper includes both explicitly; old captures/helpers remain untouched. This does not invalidate desktop-2 or checker-2 actual dependencies, but old lint-1 is both failed and incomplete for its all-target source scope. Targeted State/menu execution is compiling at final source; Windows GUI/checker builds and native acceptance remain pending. No remote State handoff or integration claim yet. Updated actual-main AGENTS differs only in slash spacing; retained locally. I read #27 integration audit1094 and preserve release ownership.

Codex-9e8r6t /root State checkpoint, still local-only on codex/multiselect-state-9e8r6t-20260923: full desktop-2 source is now identified as 2a3b9ba822a49ead233c4b5f98412a07c1c1da12, exact Git-blob match for all 733 captured inputs. Strict lint first found large_enum_variant caused by the new optional exact menu target; 3480b54201a5f361cca0bcd0d45dd6546a7a7bc9 boxes that target (3-file change). Final strict core/desktop all-target Clippy and format pass, with 735 unchanged inputs exactly equal to final committed Git blobs (map4215d0ca0319282768f1acdf05c2c094ea7432e17ed3a715df73aa05cef851bf). Input audit enumerated 71 literal Rust include references and found two compile-time fixtures outside the historical capture directory list: core attachment-workshop fixture and CLI textual-authoring fixture. Final helper includes both explicitly; old captures/helpers remain untouched. This does not invalidate desktop-2 or checker-2 actual dependencies, but old lint-1 is both failed and incomplete for its all-target source scope. Targeted State/menu execution is compiling at final source; Windows GUI/checker builds and native acceptance remain pending. No remote State handoff or integration claim yet. Updated actual-main AGENTS differs only in slash spacing; retained locally. I read #27 integration audit1094 and preserve release ownership.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root delivered the State contribution at bed7f825fd on codex/multiselect-state-9e8r6t-20260923. Push, exact remote ref, report and checks/native/source pin-file blob readback confirmed. Source commits are 2a3b9ba822 followed by the small message-size boxing correction 3480b54201, above ordinary delivery7e348d9.

Report, reproduction commands and portable evidence: exact placement/edge/row multi-selection and primary inspection; atomic unsnapped placement-group Move/Hide; authored anchors, visual descendants and eligible internal route pins; early stale/legacy refusal; stable State viewport through selection/Hide/history. No schema or wire command added.

Windows full desktop at2a3:1286 passed/0 failed/6 existing ignored; core evaluator11/0. Final3480 focused State/menu122/0, strict core/desktop all-target Clippy, format, GUI/evaluator builds pass. Exact733/735 captured input blobs match the respective source commits. Native final3480 run:35 observations,10 independently expected complete-Project checks, exact nine-file Move/Hide Undo/Redo and reopen relationships, only State-view file changes, normal close0 and empty logs. Parent reverified all34 portable evidence files from a fresh staged Git export; historical failures and invalid first capture remain separately preserved. Fresh independent code/native reviews informed corrected findings and claim limits.

Native context Add is not held-Shift injection; mounted tests cover Shift. Reopening refits surviving content, not persisted camera. Picker Escape defect remains #35; multiline transition label overlap is recorded in the report. Linux stays paused. No combined integration/release/full#29 closure claimed. Process, Allocation, Scenario group adapters and aggregate semantic deletion remain owned here; next Process work uses a separate follow-up branch and the published candidate/experiment, preserving this delivery branch.

Codex-9e8r6t /root delivered the State contribution at bed7f825fd00ec32299032a664a5f5d753aad86d on codex/multiselect-state-9e8r6t-20260923. Push, exact remote ref, report and checks/native/source pin-file blob readback confirmed. Source commits are 2a3b9ba822a49ead233c4b5f98412a07c1c1da12 followed by the small message-size boxing correction 3480b54201a5f361cca0bcd0d45dd6546a7a7bc9, above ordinary delivery7e348d9. [Report, reproduction commands and portable evidence](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/bed7f825fd00ec32299032a664a5f5d753aad86d/harness/multiselect-state-20260923.md): exact placement/edge/row multi-selection and primary inspection; atomic unsnapped placement-group Move/Hide; authored anchors, visual descendants and eligible internal route pins; early stale/legacy refusal; stable State viewport through selection/Hide/history. No schema or wire command added. Windows full desktop at2a3:1286 passed/0 failed/6 existing ignored; core evaluator11/0. Final3480 focused State/menu122/0, strict core/desktop all-target Clippy, format, GUI/evaluator builds pass. Exact733/735 captured input blobs match the respective source commits. Native final3480 run:35 observations,10 independently expected complete-Project checks, exact nine-file Move/Hide Undo/Redo and reopen relationships, only State-view file changes, normal close0 and empty logs. Parent reverified all34 portable evidence files from a fresh staged Git export; historical failures and invalid first capture remain separately preserved. Fresh independent code/native reviews informed corrected findings and claim limits. Native context Add is not held-Shift injection; mounted tests cover Shift. Reopening refits surviving content, not persisted camera. Picker Escape defect remains #35; multiline transition label overlap is recorded in the report. Linux stays paused. No combined integration/release/full#29 closure claimed. Process, Allocation, Scenario group adapters and aggregate semantic deletion remain owned here; next Process work uses a separate follow-up branch and the published candidate/experiment, preserving this delivery branch.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root continues owned #29 on local follow-up branch codex/multiselect-process-9e8r6t-20260923 from published bed7f825fd00ec32299032a664a5f5d753aad86d; State delivery branch stays fixed. Scope: exact local/qualified/link Process selection and primary inspection, captured whole-set admission, same-column local contribution group reorder as one SetSteps/history edit with stable original block order and exact other-column indices. Qualified contents stay read-only; links and unsupported mixtures refuse as a whole. No arbitrary XY or fabricated ordered-arrow identity. Before/After selected-card anchors are no-op; unselected anchors reach changed gaps.

Production planner first, then App/input/preview adapter. Acceptance includes OA Process/SA FunctionalChain, noncontiguous reverse-click selection, different card kinds/heights, legacy/cycle refusal, acyclic peers beside cycles, incomplete owner steps/linked endpoints, no-op history, exact source roundtrip/Undo/Redo, stale/pending/tool/focus cancellation and actual native slot feedback/save/reopen. Shared singleton reorder must use the same column-slot semantics, with an explicit source-order regression. Aggregate deletion remains a later acceptance slice with mode-switch and contextual-link impacts, not silently implemented as Hide.

Fresh read-only review found the proposal could panic on a core-valid incomplete process with a linked occurrence omitted from steps; tightening admission and source-level graph handling before adoption. Full Project validation/layout must not run on every pointer sample. No Process implementation or native acceptance claimed yet; no compiler/GUI currently running.

Codex-9e8r6t /root continues owned #29 on local follow-up branch codex/multiselect-process-9e8r6t-20260923 from published bed7f825fd00ec32299032a664a5f5d753aad86d; State delivery branch stays fixed. Scope: exact local/qualified/link Process selection and primary inspection, captured whole-set admission, same-column local contribution group reorder as one SetSteps/history edit with stable original block order and exact other-column indices. Qualified contents stay read-only; links and unsupported mixtures refuse as a whole. No arbitrary XY or fabricated ordered-arrow identity. Before/After selected-card anchors are no-op; unselected anchors reach changed gaps. Production planner first, then App/input/preview adapter. Acceptance includes OA Process/SA FunctionalChain, noncontiguous reverse-click selection, different card kinds/heights, legacy/cycle refusal, acyclic peers beside cycles, incomplete owner steps/linked endpoints, no-op history, exact source roundtrip/Undo/Redo, stale/pending/tool/focus cancellation and actual native slot feedback/save/reopen. Shared singleton reorder must use the same column-slot semantics, with an explicit source-order regression. Aggregate deletion remains a later acceptance slice with mode-switch and contextual-link impacts, not silently implemented as Hide. Fresh read-only review found the proposal could panic on a core-valid incomplete process with a linked occurrence omitted from steps; tightening admission and source-level graph handling before adoption. Full Project validation/layout must not run on every pointer sample. No Process implementation or native acceptance claimed yet; no compiler/GUI currently running.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root local Process implementation checkpoint, uncommitted above bed7f82 on codex/multiselect-process-9e8r6t-20260923. The column-slot planner now captures steps/adjacency/integer ranks once, replans only changed destinations without Project cloning or full scene construction, and shares the renderer's rank calculation. It refuses incomplete linked membership before layout; renderer safely omits edges to unlisted nodes. Singleton reorder uses the same planner. No runtime acceptance yet.

Typed selection, cached insertion-slot input, whole-set refusal, exact menu transport and primary inspection are wired locally. Reused occurrences/preview links inspect the actual defining object read-only; explicit Open definition restores editing. This requires a narrow ProcessOccurrence subject-selection change in app/diagram_usages.rs while keeping the caller owner and qualified usage target. Shared canvas_workspace/viewport.rs also needs passive modifier retention/replay, with mounted Process/Scenario regression coverage, because its keyboard gate otherwise loses Shift during busy/unfocused periods.

Independent static review found three integration defects, now corrected with App tests being added: process menu context not rebound after epoch advance; generic menu preselection invalidating qualified navigation; readonly draft not restored when opening the already-selected definition or leaving Behavior. The source is still being finalized; eleven App cases plus planner/input/mounted tests are unexecuted. A separate native fixture/checker is being prepared before freezing source for captured compilation. No compiler or GUI running; Linux remains paused. Shared integration/release ownership unchanged.

Codex-9e8r6t /root local Process implementation checkpoint, uncommitted above bed7f82 on codex/multiselect-process-9e8r6t-20260923. The column-slot planner now captures steps/adjacency/integer ranks once, replans only changed destinations without Project cloning or full scene construction, and shares the renderer's rank calculation. It refuses incomplete linked membership before layout; renderer safely omits edges to unlisted nodes. Singleton reorder uses the same planner. No runtime acceptance yet. Typed selection, cached insertion-slot input, whole-set refusal, exact menu transport and primary inspection are wired locally. Reused occurrences/preview links inspect the actual defining object read-only; explicit Open definition restores editing. This requires a narrow ProcessOccurrence subject-selection change in app/diagram_usages.rs while keeping the caller owner and qualified usage target. Shared canvas_workspace/viewport.rs also needs passive modifier retention/replay, with mounted Process/Scenario regression coverage, because its keyboard gate otherwise loses Shift during busy/unfocused periods. Independent static review found three integration defects, now corrected with App tests being added: process menu context not rebound after epoch advance; generic menu preselection invalidating qualified navigation; readonly draft not restored when opening the already-selected definition or leaving Behavior. The source is still being finalized; eleven App cases plus planner/input/mounted tests are unexecuted. A separate native fixture/checker is being prepared before freezing source for captured compilation. No compiler or GUI running; Linux remains paused. Shared integration/release ownership unchanged.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root Process local validation checkpoint on codex/multiselect-process-9e8r6t-20260923, still uncommitted/unpublished above bed7f82. Independent complete-Project evaluator passes 5/5 with unchanged captured 742-input source. First desktop compilation succeeds; focused run94 passed/8 failed. Six failures are fixture alias collisions (links generated against the same pre-insertion Project), one old qualified-selection event/subject expectation, and one incorrectly assumed collapse hides the first preview tile (it retains four). Corrected fixtures/assertions preserve exact identity, read-only, source and history checks; no product relaxation.

Fresh input review found a real hit-precedence defect: Shift on a visible selected singleton link handle toggled the underlying card. Fixed rendered-handle priority and added OA/SA singleton reconnect/stationary/Shift-handle plus mixed-set refusal tests. Mounted group reorder and background Clear/pan now span separate press/motion/release tree rebuilds. Second captured desktop run is underway; no new pass claim until result. Matching GUI/native acceptance remains outstanding. Local-only helpers/evidence are not a remote handoff; State delivery bed7f82 remains unchanged.

Codex-9e8r6t /root Process local validation checkpoint on codex/multiselect-process-9e8r6t-20260923, still uncommitted/unpublished above bed7f82. Independent complete-Project evaluator passes 5/5 with unchanged captured 742-input source. First desktop compilation succeeds; focused run94 passed/8 failed. Six failures are fixture alias collisions (links generated against the same pre-insertion Project), one old qualified-selection event/subject expectation, and one incorrectly assumed collapse hides the first preview tile (it retains four). Corrected fixtures/assertions preserve exact identity, read-only, source and history checks; no product relaxation. Fresh input review found a real hit-precedence defect: Shift on a visible selected singleton link handle toggled the underlying card. Fixed rendered-handle priority and added OA/SA singleton reconnect/stationary/Shift-handle plus mixed-set refusal tests. Mounted group reorder and background Clear/pan now span separate press/motion/release tree rebuilds. Second captured desktop run is underway; no new pass claim until result. Matching GUI/native acceptance remains outstanding. Local-only helpers/evidence are not a remote handoff; State delivery bed7f82 remains unchanged.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root Process full-suite checkpoint: local commit1711bff650dabb1df3a9bc37f19060d5db297feb on codex/multiselect-process-9e8r6t-20260923 passes1317 desktop tests,0 failed,6 existing ignored; all742 captured input blobs match that commit exactly. Windows gnullvm, cargo/rustc1.98.1, one build job, incremental off. Full-suite capture inputs unchanged; format check passes. Commit is still local-only, not yet consumable by remote peers.

Strict all-target core/desktop Clippy found two payload-size errors (reorder Plan::Change Command and newly expanded menu Request). Narrow boxing corrections are now applied locally above1711, plus opt-in actual-WGPU before/after-motion readback for insertion-feedback inspection; neither has passed its next gate yet. No native acceptance or full#29 closure claimed. Native checker/capture helpers are prepared for matching GUI/checker build receipts, complete Project comparison and exact baseline/Undo and reordered/Redo/reopen source bytes. Source/evidence delivery will follow verification; State branch remains fixed atbed7f82.

Codex-9e8r6t /root Process full-suite checkpoint: local commit1711bff650dabb1df3a9bc37f19060d5db297feb on codex/multiselect-process-9e8r6t-20260923 passes1317 desktop tests,0 failed,6 existing ignored; all742 captured input blobs match that commit exactly. Windows gnullvm, cargo/rustc1.98.1, one build job, incremental off. Full-suite capture inputs unchanged; format check passes. Commit is still local-only, not yet consumable by remote peers. Strict all-target core/desktop Clippy found two payload-size errors (reorder Plan::Change Command and newly expanded menu Request). Narrow boxing corrections are now applied locally above1711, plus opt-in actual-WGPU before/after-motion readback for insertion-feedback inspection; neither has passed its next gate yet. No native acceptance or full#29 closure claimed. Native checker/capture helpers are prepared for matching GUI/checker build receipts, complete Project comparison and exact baseline/Undo and reordered/Redo/reopen source bytes. Source/evidence delivery will follow verification; State branch remains fixed atbed7f82.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root native acceptance found a concrete Process return-context mismatch before delivery. Local b15345123a passes147 affected desktop tests,5 final-source core evaluator tests, strict all-target lint/format and matching GUI/checker builds. OA/SA actual-WGPU insertion feedback inspected independently; source/camera/count remain stable at1440x900. Still local-only/unpublished.

Native run1 passes baseline, mixed card+link whole-set drag refusal, two distinct qualified paths and readonly drag/Delete refusal, all three saved complete-Project comparisons unchanged. Explicit Open definition correctly restores the real leaf editor. However Back to caller restores outer-reference Properties while also painting the qualified leaf highlight. This violates primary/visual consistency and needs correction; native acceptance is withheld. Saved model remains unchanged; run1 closed normally exit0 with emptylogs and unchanged fixture/binaries. Preserving screenshots26/27 and partial receipts as failed acceptance evidence; narrow fix plus missing Open/Back regression and rerun follow. No combined release claim.

Codex-9e8r6t /root native acceptance found a concrete Process return-context mismatch before delivery. Local b15345123a7feaf630ef24d45f591c76c6715778 passes147 affected desktop tests,5 final-source core evaluator tests, strict all-target lint/format and matching GUI/checker builds. OA/SA actual-WGPU insertion feedback inspected independently; source/camera/count remain stable at1440x900. Still local-only/unpublished. Native run1 passes baseline, mixed card+link whole-set drag refusal, two distinct qualified paths and readonly drag/Delete refusal, all three saved complete-Project comparisons unchanged. Explicit Open definition correctly restores the real leaf editor. However Back to caller restores outer-reference Properties while also painting the qualified leaf highlight. This violates primary/visual consistency and needs correction; native acceptance is withheld. Saved model remains unchanged; run1 closed normally exit0 with emptylogs and unchanged fixture/binaries. Preserving screenshots26/27 and partial receipts as failed acceptance evidence; narrow fix plus missing Open/Back regression and rerun follow. No combined release claim.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root corrected the native Back identity defect at local commit ff712b2419. Explicit object navigation now leaves qualified context, including same-ID defining-leaf selection; Back reconstructs the validated exact leaf, primary and read-only inspector. Requested nonprimary Open paths are captured explicitly. Independent review found no remaining concrete regression. Windows focused150/0, full1320/0/6 existing ignored, strict core/desktop all-target lint and format pass; all742 captured input blobs match ff712 exactly. Still local-only/unpublished pending native delivery.

The added test's first attempt had a duplicate expand toggle and an unreachable selected-group menu setup; corrected without relaxing product admission. Historical desktop4 invalid CLI and desktop5 fixture failure remain preserved. Native1 remains failed acceptance.

Root also found an evaluator discrimination limit: selecting C then A and dragging A after B can give the same order as singleton A. Evaluator-only successor b743a10d51 prescribes Inspect C without changing membership, then dragging C after B; singleton primary/pressed C would be unchanged. Five core evaluator tests and its strict lint/format pass; production desktop is unchanged from ff712. Matching GUI/checker builds are in progress; native2 must still establish exact qualified return, group membership, one-step history and saved bytes. No combined/release/full#29 closure.

Codex-9e8r6t /root corrected the native Back identity defect at local commit ff712b24190342363d0275467e96f181872da6ad. Explicit object navigation now leaves qualified context, including same-ID defining-leaf selection; Back reconstructs the validated exact leaf, primary and read-only inspector. Requested nonprimary Open paths are captured explicitly. Independent review found no remaining concrete regression. Windows focused150/0, full1320/0/6 existing ignored, strict core/desktop all-target lint and format pass; all742 captured input blobs match ff712 exactly. Still local-only/unpublished pending native delivery. The added test's first attempt had a duplicate expand toggle and an unreachable selected-group menu setup; corrected without relaxing product admission. Historical desktop4 invalid CLI and desktop5 fixture failure remain preserved. Native1 remains failed acceptance. Root also found an evaluator discrimination limit: selecting C then A and dragging A after B can give the same order as singleton A. Evaluator-only successor b743a10d51032dc1655b94fed5e49fbbbcee83f4 prescribes Inspect C without changing membership, then dragging C after B; singleton primary/pressed C would be unchanged. Five core evaluator tests and its strict lint/format pass; production desktop is unchanged from ff712. Matching GUI/checker builds are in progress; native2 must still establish exact qualified return, group membership, one-step history and saved bytes. No combined/release/full#29 closure.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root Process contribution is published and remote-ref/blob verified at 6d99aacab8 on codex/multiselect-process-9e8r6t-20260923, above fixed State delivery bed7f82. Report, source contract and portable evidence. Production ff712b2 passes full Windows desktop1320/0/6 ignored, focused150/0 and strict core/desktop all-target lint/format. Evaluator-only b743a10 passes5 core checks, scoped lint/format and matching GUI/checker builds; exact742 inputs match each tested commit.

Native run3 independently reviewed: current/nonprimary qualified Open/Back restores exact read-only leaf; explicit outer/same-ID Explorer navigation restores local editable subject. C then A, Inspect C, drag C After B produces source-order A,C as one group, preserves U/V, count2/primaryC, one Undo/Redo and in-process reopen. All8 complete-Project checks and10-file exact saved-byte history pass; only OA process source changes. Normal exit0, empty logs. Run1 identity failure and run2 preparation-only missing-DLL environment failure remain preserved. All5 portable verifiers plus review pins pass on47 exact staged/exported files. Native Shift/SA reorder/other DPI/full accessibility not claimed. Reordered links overlap visibly; routing is a documented remaining defect related to #32, not hidden by source equality.

#29 remains open: Allocation, Scenario and aggregate deletion still required. I retain those adapters and continue next on codex/multiselect-allocation-9e8r6t-20260923 in my separate machine/worktree. Immediate bounded acceptance: falsify mixed Arrange candidates using actual projection/combined geometry, preserve every allocation/role/source record, include folded-child collision and one-step history before deciding a contract amendment. Process delivery branch will remain fixed; no combined integration or release claim.

Codex-9e8r6t /root Process contribution is published and remote-ref/blob verified at 6d99aacab8ca1a91c857a2179baa14d80a2901e9 on codex/multiselect-process-9e8r6t-20260923, above fixed State delivery bed7f82. [Report, source contract and portable evidence](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/6d99aacab8ca1a91c857a2179baa14d80a2901e9/harness/multiselect-process-20260923.md). Production ff712b2 passes full Windows desktop1320/0/6 ignored, focused150/0 and strict core/desktop all-target lint/format. Evaluator-only b743a10 passes5 core checks, scoped lint/format and matching GUI/checker builds; exact742 inputs match each tested commit. Native run3 independently reviewed: current/nonprimary qualified Open/Back restores exact read-only leaf; explicit outer/same-ID Explorer navigation restores local editable subject. C then A, Inspect C, drag C After B produces source-order A,C as one group, preserves U/V, count2/primaryC, one Undo/Redo and in-process reopen. All8 complete-Project checks and10-file exact saved-byte history pass; only OA process source changes. Normal exit0, empty logs. Run1 identity failure and run2 preparation-only missing-DLL environment failure remain preserved. All5 portable verifiers plus review pins pass on47 exact staged/exported files. Native Shift/SA reorder/other DPI/full accessibility not claimed. Reordered links overlap visibly; routing is a documented remaining defect related to #32, not hidden by source equality. #29 remains open: Allocation, Scenario and aggregate deletion still required. I retain those adapters and continue next on codex/multiselect-allocation-9e8r6t-20260923 in my separate machine/worktree. Immediate bounded acceptance: falsify mixed Arrange candidates using actual projection/combined geometry, preserve every allocation/role/source record, include folded-child collision and one-step history before deciding a contract amendment. Process delivery branch will remain fixed; no combined integration or release claim.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root published the bounded Allocation Arrange policy/pure-planner checkpoint at eed80ffd6e on codex/multiselect-allocation-9e8r6t-20260923 (above fixed Process6d99aac). Remote ref and report/checks/review-pin blobs confirmed. Report, accepted amendment and portable evidence.

Actual OA/SA experiments support explicit Arrange for one or more work/performer placements: semantic work closure plus explicitly selected performer visual closure, one rigid delta, unchanged allocation/role/fold records. Complete scene checking catches unselected enclosure growth; required ancestor expansion catches moved hidden children. Unrelated folded interiors remain outside that diagnostic domain, explicitly tested against universal unfolding. Ordinary distributed assignment remains refused; Arrange is not a replacement for ordinary group assignment.

Pure planner source9b83f7ca0dcd34056765b9399863a21da72c3a9f passes70 focused production planner/Document tests, strict scoped Clippy and workspace format on exact746 input blobs. Independent review found no concrete planner defect; R1/R2 strengthened collision causes, simultaneous vacated-space and existing-overlap controls. Source/reopen/exact one-Undo/Redo, role-only/unplaced work, both anchor kinds, stale/tampered result and all selected headers are covered. Portable12-run package retains3 compile failures,8 source proofs and6 historical reviews; all11 staged/exported evidence files verified. This is pure/source evidence, not App/native acceptance.

I retain #29 Allocation/Scenario/removal ownership on this branch. Next: combined ordinary work-group semantic planner, then shared App input integration with exact whole typed selection, deferred selected-member collapse, irreversible threshold, one-shot Arrange on work/performer, dirty/stale/source-failure and native workflows. No UI delivery, combined release or full issue closure. Linux remains user-paused.

Codex-9e8r6t /root published the bounded Allocation Arrange policy/pure-planner checkpoint at eed80ffd6e94c7127491de1fd45c0415685f6328 on codex/multiselect-allocation-9e8r6t-20260923 (above fixed Process6d99aac). Remote ref and report/checks/review-pin blobs confirmed. [Report, accepted amendment and portable evidence](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/eed80ffd6e94c7127491de1fd45c0415685f6328/harness/allocation-arrange-planner-20260923.md). Actual OA/SA experiments support explicit Arrange for one or more work/performer placements: semantic work closure plus explicitly selected performer visual closure, one rigid delta, unchanged allocation/role/fold records. Complete scene checking catches unselected enclosure growth; required ancestor expansion catches moved hidden children. Unrelated folded interiors remain outside that diagnostic domain, explicitly tested against universal unfolding. Ordinary distributed assignment remains refused; Arrange is not a replacement for ordinary group assignment. Pure planner source9b83f7ca0dcd34056765b9399863a21da72c3a9f passes70 focused production planner/Document tests, strict scoped Clippy and workspace format on exact746 input blobs. Independent review found no concrete planner defect; R1/R2 strengthened collision causes, simultaneous vacated-space and existing-overlap controls. Source/reopen/exact one-Undo/Redo, role-only/unplaced work, both anchor kinds, stale/tampered result and all selected headers are covered. Portable12-run package retains3 compile failures,8 source proofs and6 historical reviews; all11 staged/exported evidence files verified. This is pure/source evidence, not App/native acceptance. I retain #29 Allocation/Scenario/removal ownership on this branch. Next: combined ordinary work-group semantic planner, then shared App input integration with exact whole typed selection, deferred selected-member collapse, irreversible threshold, one-shot Arrange on work/performer, dirty/stale/source-failure and native workflows. No UI delivery, combined release or full issue closure. Linux remains user-paused.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root published ordinary Allocation assignment foundation at 16b30a6760 on codex/multiselect-allocation-9e8r6t-20260923. Remote ref/report/evidence-index blobs verified. Report and portable evidence. Source33e8801:84 focused production planner/Document passes, strict scoped Clippy and format, exact750 captured Git blobs. Independent review found no concrete planner or blocking evaluator defect.

Combined assignment preserves per-root role provenance, normalizes original validated work identities, includes unplaced leaves, reserves IDs/aliases globally, compares whole semantic candidates, and uses one complete geometry/route map with final exact Batch. Fourteen added test families include OA/SA simultaneous vacated space, internal/external pins and attachments, own-route deletion across views, source-budget refusal with existing Undo/Redo, zero-delta semantics, composite/distributed distinction, stale/tamper and every selected header. Stable-command retry succeeds in a fresh normal-budget Document, not a same-session retry claim.

Initial successful captures had CRLF-only arrange.rs bytes that Git normalized; exact source comparison correctly refused them. Preserved these captures and diagnosis, reran all three gates on canonical commit bytes, and verified3 new source proofs. Seven-run portable package and5 review/design/diagnosis members verified from11 exact staged/exported evidence files. No App/full-desktop/native/release acceptance yet.

I retain Allocation/Scenario/removal ownership. UI design review found generic performer movement can bypass current Arrange ownership, stale legacy packets need origin epochs, and route handles must win over underlying cards; resolving these in the next shared App/canvas adapter. Pure planners now stay fixed during integration. Linux remains user-paused; release ownership unchanged.

Codex-9e8r6t /root published ordinary Allocation assignment foundation at 16b30a67600eff2b3e10d96376cb57585223995c on codex/multiselect-allocation-9e8r6t-20260923. Remote ref/report/evidence-index blobs verified. [Report and portable evidence](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/16b30a67600eff2b3e10d96376cb57585223995c/harness/allocation-assignment-planner-20260923.md). Source33e8801:84 focused production planner/Document passes, strict scoped Clippy and format, exact750 captured Git blobs. Independent review found no concrete planner or blocking evaluator defect. Combined assignment preserves per-root role provenance, normalizes original validated work identities, includes unplaced leaves, reserves IDs/aliases globally, compares whole semantic candidates, and uses one complete geometry/route map with final exact Batch. Fourteen added test families include OA/SA simultaneous vacated space, internal/external pins and attachments, own-route deletion across views, source-budget refusal with existing Undo/Redo, zero-delta semantics, composite/distributed distinction, stale/tamper and every selected header. Stable-command retry succeeds in a fresh normal-budget Document, not a same-session retry claim. Initial successful captures had CRLF-only arrange.rs bytes that Git normalized; exact source comparison correctly refused them. Preserved these captures and diagnosis, reran all three gates on canonical commit bytes, and verified3 new source proofs. Seven-run portable package and5 review/design/diagnosis members verified from11 exact staged/exported evidence files. No App/full-desktop/native/release acceptance yet. I retain Allocation/Scenario/removal ownership. UI design review found generic performer movement can bypass current Arrange ownership, stale legacy packets need origin epochs, and route handles must win over underlying cards; resolving these in the next shared App/canvas adapter. Pure planners now stay fixed during integration. Linux remains user-paused; release ownership unchanged.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root: Allocation App/native contribution is pushed and remote-ref-verified at 57aec979f6 on codex/multiselect-allocation-9e8r6t-20260923. Tested source is 495464e84b. Report and portable evidence.

Windows full desktop: 1,362 passed / 0 failed / 6 ignored; strict desktop all-target Clippy, format, matching GUI/checker builds, independent evaluator5/0 and its strict lint all pass on754 exact committed input blobs. Five actual native workflows cover OA/SA group assignment, OA/SA explicit mixed Arrange, ordinary OA performer movement, typed-port/mixed ordinary refusals, one Undo/Redo each, Save and OA in-process reopen. 95 accepted-workflow captures,26 complete-Project checks and5 exact16-file history checks; all normal exits0. Full archive retains102 captures, failed/preflight runs and predecessor gate failures. Both portable verifiers and exact staged Git bytes passed. Independent review found no remaining bounded acceptance blocker.

The adapter now owns all Allocation placement gestures, rejects stale bare move bypasses, validates original typed membership and preserves nonprimary anchors. Review fixes cover dirty route-control hit-domain focus and off-grid performer out-and-back no-op. No native held-Shift/interruption/held-preview/compact-window or SA-reopen claim; corresponding automated coverage is described precisely. Fixture18 advisory completeness warnings are explained. This is contribution acceptance, not combined integration/release acceptance.

I retain Scenario/removal scope. Next bounded step is strict same-immediate-parent Scenario stable-block reorder: semantic order, complete typed/list admission before no-op, whole-candidate temporal/lifecycle validation, exact frozen membership; cross-parent/fragment-child sets refuse rather than silently normalize. Independent policy review completed. Group removal remains subsequent work. Linux remains user-paused; release ownership stays Codex-956atf.

Codex-9e8r6t /root: Allocation App/native contribution is pushed and remote-ref-verified at 57aec979f640ba1b8aa6fcbb7d9e26b29cf51596 on codex/multiselect-allocation-9e8r6t-20260923. Tested source is 495464e84b5bae8ddad93e9fc69ef353e7f1c884. [Report and portable evidence](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/57aec979f640ba1b8aa6fcbb7d9e26b29cf51596/harness/allocation-group-app-20260924.md). Windows full desktop: 1,362 passed / 0 failed / 6 ignored; strict desktop all-target Clippy, format, matching GUI/checker builds, independent evaluator5/0 and its strict lint all pass on754 exact committed input blobs. Five actual native workflows cover OA/SA group assignment, OA/SA explicit mixed Arrange, ordinary OA performer movement, typed-port/mixed ordinary refusals, one Undo/Redo each, Save and OA in-process reopen. 95 accepted-workflow captures,26 complete-Project checks and5 exact16-file history checks; all normal exits0. Full archive retains102 captures, failed/preflight runs and predecessor gate failures. Both portable verifiers and exact staged Git bytes passed. Independent review found no remaining bounded acceptance blocker. The adapter now owns all Allocation placement gestures, rejects stale bare move bypasses, validates original typed membership and preserves nonprimary anchors. Review fixes cover dirty route-control hit-domain focus and off-grid performer out-and-back no-op. No native held-Shift/interruption/held-preview/compact-window or SA-reopen claim; corresponding automated coverage is described precisely. Fixture18 advisory completeness warnings are explained. This is contribution acceptance, not combined integration/release acceptance. I retain Scenario/removal scope. Next bounded step is strict same-immediate-parent Scenario stable-block reorder: semantic order, complete typed/list admission before no-op, whole-candidate temporal/lifecycle validation, exact frozen membership; cross-parent/fragment-child sets refuse rather than silently normalize. Independent policy review completed. Group removal remains subsequent work. Linux remains user-paused; release ownership stays Codex-956atf.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root: resuming retained Scenario scope while #37's separate build owner runs the frozen Windows candidate. Release fix/source/evidence are delivered in #37 through 93d2a6f; the separate-machine downloaded-package QA role remains active when assets arrive.

Post-prerelease work will use distinct branch codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924, based on the retrieved integrated897d9f04 source, in an isolated local worktree. I will port the preserved local-only Scenario sibling-block planner and verify it against the actual combined schema/behavior before adding App/canvas integration. This code is explicitly excluded from the current prerelease.

Bounded acceptance: exact original typed membership under one immediate Scenario/Branch parent, stable semantic order, no silent subset/parent/dependency expansion, selected-anchor and unchanged-list no-ops only after complete admission, full temporal/lifecycle candidate validation, literal complete-model and one-step source/history tests. Then captured input/primary/context and native usability checks are required for delivery. Aggregate removal remains subsequent owned work; this does not close #29. No overlapping peer claim was present in the current issue readback.

Codex-9e8r6t /root: resuming retained Scenario scope while #37's separate build owner runs the frozen Windows candidate. Release fix/source/evidence are delivered in #37 through 93d2a6f; the separate-machine downloaded-package QA role remains active when assets arrive. Post-prerelease work will use distinct branch codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924, based on the retrieved integrated897d9f04 source, in an isolated local worktree. I will port the preserved local-only Scenario sibling-block planner and verify it against the actual combined schema/behavior before adding App/canvas integration. This code is explicitly excluded from the current prerelease. Bounded acceptance: exact original typed membership under one immediate Scenario/Branch parent, stable semantic order, no silent subset/parent/dependency expansion, selected-anchor and unchanged-list no-ops only after complete admission, full temporal/lifecycle candidate validation, literal complete-model and one-step source/history tests. Then captured input/primary/context and native usability checks are required for delivery. Aggregate removal remains subsequent owned work; this does not close #29. No overlapping peer claim was present in the current issue readback.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root: published and ref-verified the post-prerelease Scenario planner foundation on codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924, delivery commit 47917dd0ef. Tested source is 7d3d7b23e7, based on integrated 8ddfadf440. This remains explicitly excluded from the current #37 prerelease.

Verification record and reproducible commands: all 12 new Scenario cases plus eight existing Process reorder tests pass; broader Scenario regressions pass 250/0/1 existing ignored timing diagnostic; workspace format and strict all-target desktop Clippy pass. The filters overlap. Every final gate captured 804 unchanged inputs with exact Git-blob source proofs. Windows gnullvm only; no Linux.

The immutable same-parent sibling-block planner performs whole-set typed/list/reachability admission and full baseline/candidate validation, preserves semantic order and every saved presentation record, and integrates the existing singleton wrapper. Literal complete-model/source/reopen/Undo/Redo tests cover nested reply/lifetime failures, ALT/PAR, warning-only states and nonempty affected/unrelated saved views. Independent source and delivery reviews found no material discrepancy in this bounded scope.

Portable raw evidence retains the first compile failure and corrected runs: ZIP 6,416,449 bytes, SHA-256 211530e47aec6254ee1476081352139497091aae6fef249274c20aa1808b741f. The failed source d79a5ed is separately preserved on codex/scenario-planner-first-gate-9e8r6t-20260924, not an accepted candidate. Original review/log bytes and 11 corruption-rejection selfchecks are retained.

Next in this retained scope: full Scenario event envelopes and representation-specific selection scopes, then an observable saved-view group reorder interaction. Independent critique found that exact authored Y can leave arrows visually unmoved after semantic reorder; compare a direct group handle plus operation-local order preview against an arm plus preview before accepting the latter. Preserve default saved spacing, reject stale selection/visit/gesture ABA before side effects, and close singleton/menu/Details bypasses. No group App/canvas/native or aggregate removal acceptance is claimed; #29 remains open. Current #37 downloaded-package QA still takes priority once the exact artifact is available.

Codex-9e8r6t /root: published and ref-verified the post-prerelease Scenario planner foundation on `codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924`, delivery commit **47917dd0efbd269a06c72bc788a5ef31f23a4229**. Tested source is **7d3d7b23e768b66b93b608bcc6b4fb1e7f972f89**, based on integrated **8ddfadf440b5c208b1adb6b211a97ba0c99cff04**. This remains explicitly excluded from the current #37 prerelease. [Verification record and reproducible commands](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/47917dd0efbd269a06c72bc788a5ef31f23a4229/harness/scenario-group-planner-20260924.md): all 12 new Scenario cases plus eight existing Process reorder tests pass; broader Scenario regressions pass **250/0/1 existing ignored timing diagnostic**; workspace format and strict all-target desktop Clippy pass. The filters overlap. Every final gate captured 804 unchanged inputs with exact Git-blob source proofs. Windows gnullvm only; no Linux. The immutable same-parent sibling-block planner performs whole-set typed/list/reachability admission and full baseline/candidate validation, preserves semantic order and every saved presentation record, and integrates the existing singleton wrapper. Literal complete-model/source/reopen/Undo/Redo tests cover nested reply/lifetime failures, ALT/PAR, warning-only states and nonempty affected/unrelated saved views. Independent source and delivery reviews found no material discrepancy in this bounded scope. [Portable raw evidence](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/47917dd0efbd269a06c72bc788a5ef31f23a4229/harness/scenario-group-planner-evidence-20260924/checks/README.md) retains the first compile failure and corrected runs: ZIP 6,416,449 bytes, SHA-256 `211530e47aec6254ee1476081352139497091aae6fef249274c20aa1808b741f`. The failed source d79a5ed is separately preserved on `codex/scenario-planner-first-gate-9e8r6t-20260924`, not an accepted candidate. Original review/log bytes and 11 corruption-rejection selfchecks are retained. Next in this retained scope: full Scenario event envelopes and representation-specific selection scopes, then an observable saved-view group reorder interaction. Independent critique found that exact authored Y can leave arrows visually unmoved after semantic reorder; compare a direct group handle plus operation-local order preview against an arm plus preview before accepting the latter. Preserve default saved spacing, reject stale selection/visit/gesture ABA before side effects, and close singleton/menu/Details bypasses. No group App/canvas/native or aggregate removal acceptance is claimed; #29 remains open. Current #37 downloaded-package QA still takes priority once the exact artifact is available.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root checkpoint; existing Scenario ownership and remote branch codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924 unchanged. Published planner foundation remains47917dd. Selection adapter is currently local-only, outside #37: exact rendered targets, full representation/visit plus shared selection snapshot, Shift toggle, deferred collapse, contextual selection actions, visible count, and whole-group refusal of unfinished movement/removal. Preserves first-press singleton saved spacing.

First Windows Scenario run at local879eb1d:263 passed/1 failed/1 ignored,809 unchanged inputs proven against Git. The failed older deletion test assumed its captured snapshot remained valid across owner change; new destination admission correctly rejects it. Corrected fixture retains real invalidation and independently isolates behavior_owner, with source/history/removal checks retained. Independent review also found same-press Clear interrupting background pan and legacy singleton A/B/A leaving old spacing Begin alive. Local correction retires canvas/spacing input without retiring the camera lifetime; adds both selection-route ABA checks and mounted Shift/Properties, first-press saved-spacing, singleton/group blank-pan evaluators. Corrective tests running; format passes. No native acceptance or remote adapter availability claimed yet; will publish code and immutable evidence before asking peers to consume it. Windows Gitea reads are working; Linux remains excluded from current prerelease.

Codex-9e8r6t /root checkpoint; existing Scenario ownership and remote branch codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924 unchanged. Published planner foundation remains47917dd. Selection adapter is currently local-only, outside #37: exact rendered targets, full representation/visit plus shared selection snapshot, Shift toggle, deferred collapse, contextual selection actions, visible count, and whole-group refusal of unfinished movement/removal. Preserves first-press singleton saved spacing. First Windows Scenario run at local879eb1d:263 passed/1 failed/1 ignored,809 unchanged inputs proven against Git. The failed older deletion test assumed its captured snapshot remained valid across owner change; new destination admission correctly rejects it. Corrected fixture retains real invalidation and independently isolates behavior_owner, with source/history/removal checks retained. Independent review also found same-press Clear interrupting background pan and legacy singleton A/B/A leaving old spacing Begin alive. Local correction retires canvas/spacing input without retiring the camera lifetime; adds both selection-route ABA checks and mounted Shift/Properties, first-press saved-spacing, singleton/group blank-pan evaluators. Corrective tests running; format passes. No native acceptance or remote adapter availability claimed yet; will publish code and immutable evidence before asking peers to consume it. Windows Gitea reads are working; Linux remains excluded from current prerelease.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root — Scenario selection adapter increment published and available to peers on codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924 at 3b2bb8ba78. Tested production source is ed55b1781d86ec49af5d2588cbd06f7b878d9009; delivery descendant adds records only. Remote branch readback and fresh downloads of all three evidence ZIPs exactly match local bytes.

Verification and behavior report. Exact rendered Scenario targets, full representation/visit + shared selection identity, Shift toggle, stationary collapse, contextual Add/Remove/Inspect/Select only, visible count and primary. Group drag/Delete/order paths refuse the whole group while unsupported. First-press singleton saved spacing is preserved. Review/runtime corrections cover same-press blank-pan interruption, legacy selection ABA and a newly scheduled reveal regression; historical failures and the deliberately interrupted changed-input attempt are retained honestly.

Final Windows GNU LLVM source: Scenario filter268 passed/0failed/1ignored; complete menu filter14/0/0 (filters overlap, do not sum). Format, strict desktop all-target Clippy, and desktop debug build pass. All809 captured inputs match exact source blobs; independent reviewer repeated all four historical source comparisons and all raw package comparisons. Native exercise: contextual two-member selection/primary, group refusal, blank clear+pan on one gesture, stationary collapse, first-press different-singleton spacing, A/B/Automatic/A navigation, Save all and one Undo. Selection-only and final saved file equal baseline bytes; the spacing snapshot changes only saved A updated_report send_y. Clean exit0 and empty logs. Native Shift/Redo/dirty Properties/stale events/group navigation/fallback C are not claimed; mounted-test coverage remains separate.

Portable evidence under harness/scenario-selection-evidence-20260924 at the delivery commit:

  • checks/evidence.zip: 12,926,901 bytes; SHA256 05d040e856d0b37adf44f6a9e3d2789d4d76c026e61e85fdfcab0e7bebca4dd4; 12 closed unchanged-input runs,3 recorded failures,12proofs,4capsules.
  • native/native.zip: 2,622,962 bytes; SHA256 391a91b55ab2c4c4d7663026d38a6485bfa5876d1205f40456da508978a69df3;99 original members, independently audited.
  • invalid-attempt-3/raw.zip: 3,192,626 bytes; SHA256 9afef85b7e395d811bf99cd3a49909da881403cac3bcfcaea9fdc701f4ee5180; excluded from accepted checks.

Verification after checkout: python -B harness/scenario-selection-evidence-20260924/checks/verify.py and python -B harness/scenario-selection-evidence-20260924/native/verify.py. Exact Cargo commands/environment and native launch provenance are in the report. No Linux builds/checks. This is branch-specific and outside frozen #37; no integrated/release acceptance or issue completion claimed. Existing Scenario ownership remains with this session. Next outcome: compare explicit group handle versus arming with semantic-order preview, settle destination/lifetime behavior, then implement and validate group reorder; aggregate removal remains separate required work.

Codex-9e8r6t /root — Scenario selection adapter increment published and available to peers on codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924 at 3b2bb8ba782eef5a0665fd95484216d2ac033a28. Tested production source is ed55b1781d86ec49af5d2588cbd06f7b878d9009; delivery descendant adds records only. Remote branch readback and fresh downloads of all three evidence ZIPs exactly match local bytes. [Verification and behavior report](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/3b2bb8ba782eef5a0665fd95484216d2ac033a28/harness/scenario-selection-20260924.md). Exact rendered Scenario targets, full representation/visit + shared selection identity, Shift toggle, stationary collapse, contextual Add/Remove/Inspect/Select only, visible count and primary. Group drag/Delete/order paths refuse the whole group while unsupported. First-press singleton saved spacing is preserved. Review/runtime corrections cover same-press blank-pan interruption, legacy selection ABA and a newly scheduled reveal regression; historical failures and the deliberately interrupted changed-input attempt are retained honestly. Final Windows GNU LLVM source: Scenario filter268 passed/0failed/1ignored; complete menu filter14/0/0 (filters overlap, do not sum). Format, strict desktop all-target Clippy, and desktop debug build pass. All809 captured inputs match exact source blobs; independent reviewer repeated all four historical source comparisons and all raw package comparisons. Native exercise: contextual two-member selection/primary, group refusal, blank clear+pan on one gesture, stationary collapse, first-press different-singleton spacing, A/B/Automatic/A navigation, Save all and one Undo. Selection-only and final saved file equal baseline bytes; the spacing snapshot changes only saved A updated_report send_y. Clean exit0 and empty logs. Native Shift/Redo/dirty Properties/stale events/group navigation/fallback C are not claimed; mounted-test coverage remains separate. Portable evidence under harness/scenario-selection-evidence-20260924 at the delivery commit: - checks/evidence.zip: 12,926,901 bytes; SHA256 05d040e856d0b37adf44f6a9e3d2789d4d76c026e61e85fdfcab0e7bebca4dd4; 12 closed unchanged-input runs,3 recorded failures,12proofs,4capsules. - native/native.zip: 2,622,962 bytes; SHA256 391a91b55ab2c4c4d7663026d38a6485bfa5876d1205f40456da508978a69df3;99 original members, independently audited. - invalid-attempt-3/raw.zip: 3,192,626 bytes; SHA256 9afef85b7e395d811bf99cd3a49909da881403cac3bcfcaea9fdc701f4ee5180; excluded from accepted checks. Verification after checkout: python -B harness/scenario-selection-evidence-20260924/checks/verify.py and python -B harness/scenario-selection-evidence-20260924/native/verify.py. Exact Cargo commands/environment and native launch provenance are in the report. No Linux builds/checks. This is branch-specific and outside frozen #37; no integrated/release acceptance or issue completion claimed. Existing Scenario ownership remains with this session. Next outcome: compare explicit group handle versus arming with semantic-order preview, settle destination/lifetime behavior, then implement and validate group reorder; aggregate removal remains separate required work.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root — #37 independent downloaded-package QA is delivered in comment1275; resuming retained Scenario scope on codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924 (published3b2bb8b). Reassessing the next increment against the user's original Shift-select-and-move request: Saved singleton body movement already means presentation spacing, so Saved group presentation movement should precede adding semantic reorder controls. The existing semantic sibling-block planner remains useful, but does not itself fulfill ordinary group movement. This changes implementation priority, not required scope; explicit semantic reorder and aggregate removal remain required follow-ups.

Next bounded outcome under this ownership: homogeneous local message groups share one vertical delta; homogeneous lifeline groups share one horizontal delta, from actual captured rendered origins. Original complete typed selection admitted before any no-op; unsupported/mixed/fallback sets refuse whole, never primary-only. Apply one combined candidate and geometry validation, preserve semantic step order and every other view, commit once with exact source/Undo/Redo; retain complete selection/primary. Compare this default movement task with the explicit semantic destination design before choosing its later UI. Independent design/adapter mapping in progress; no new production/native claim. This remains outside frozen #37 and Windows-only under the user's current platform scope.

Codex-9e8r6t /root — #37 independent downloaded-package QA is delivered in comment1275; resuming retained Scenario scope on `codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924` (published3b2bb8b). Reassessing the next increment against the user's original Shift-select-and-move request: Saved singleton body movement already means presentation spacing, so **Saved group presentation movement should precede adding semantic reorder controls**. The existing semantic sibling-block planner remains useful, but does not itself fulfill ordinary group movement. This changes implementation priority, not required scope; explicit semantic reorder and aggregate removal remain required follow-ups. Next bounded outcome under this ownership: homogeneous local message groups share one vertical delta; homogeneous lifeline groups share one horizontal delta, from actual captured rendered origins. Original complete typed selection admitted before any no-op; unsupported/mixed/fallback sets refuse whole, never primary-only. Apply one combined candidate and geometry validation, preserve semantic step order and every other view, commit once with exact source/Undo/Redo; retain complete selection/primary. Compare this default movement task with the explicit semantic destination design before choosing its later UI. Independent design/adapter mapping in progress; no new production/native claim. This remains outside frozen #37 and Windows-only under the user's current platform scope.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root — Saved Scenario group spacing is pushed and remote-ref-verified at 5381729869 on codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924. Final product source is 8d6fac4701; delivery descendant adds records only. Implementation, verification and limitations.

Dragging any selected local message moves the homogeneous message group vertically; selected lifeline headers move the homogeneous lane group horizontally. Full membership/primary and original rendered origins are captured. One combined validated transaction preserves semantic order, unselected records and other views. Unsupported/mixed/fallback sets refuse whole; stationary clicks still collapse. Off-axis/no-op/cancel preserve selection/history, and stale/ABA input is rejected. This is ordinary Saved presentation movement; semantic reorder and aggregate removal remain required.

Windows Scenario regression filter: 289 passed / 0 failed / 1 ignored at 67534ce4. Subsequent changes are independently reviewed numerically equivalent test annotations and UI text only; the 289 tests were not executed at final8d6. Final8d6 format, strict desktop all-target Clippy, Studio+CLI builds pass; all ten captured gate runs have811 unchanged inputs and exact source proofs. Earlier Scenario and Clippy failures remain preserved.

Native final8d6: two normal exits0, empty logs,67 captures. Nonprimary message anchor moves both selected messages+24Y; nonprimary lane anchor moves both selected lanes+32X. One Undo/Redo per group, off-axis no-op preserving Redo, mixed body/header refusals and stationary collapse, outside-canvas cancel, A/B navigation and fresh-process reopen pass. Nine run1 saved snapshots plus one reopened saved snapshot satisfy exact whole-source phases (only exact decimal spelling flexibility at four predeclared changed A coordinates). Native selection used contextual Add; Shift remains mounted-test evidence. Existing ellipsized labels and Beta label backing interrupting a short Archive lifeline segment are explicitly documented visual limitations; broad GUI/accessibility acceptance is not claimed.

Portable evidence and review: checks ZIP12,897,498 bytes SHA256 d3de224502a2b7f8236d2ad82af6d6c57bb3a349468aebeea7369c3c3c267342; native ZIP6,069,072 bytes SHA256 27e0e189053fdfdbfcecd8c91ae718849448b090aab557afc7d9445af1ceaba8. Both offline verifiers and13 exact staged files pass. Independent delivery audit found no material discrepancy. Fresh Gitea downloads of both archives, report, index and review match committed bytes.

This remains branch-specific and outside delivered #37; no combined integration/release or #29 closure. I retain Scenario/removal ownership. Next bounded outcome: compare an explicit semantic destination chooser plus before/after order preview with a labelled group drag handle, reuse the existing exact sibling-block planner, and prove destination reachability/comprehension even when Saved Y differs from semantic order. No UI choice accepted merely from this design comparison. Windows Gitea read/write/push/download access works; WSL networking is not established and Linux remains excluded by the user.

Codex-9e8r6t /root — Saved Scenario group spacing is pushed and remote-ref-verified at **53817298698cadb35c9bbd745e934ff3416cceee** on `codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924`. Final product source is **8d6fac4701933c7ada13cc7e6e07060662aa7465**; delivery descendant adds records only. [Implementation, verification and limitations](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/53817298698cadb35c9bbd745e934ff3416cceee/harness/scenario-group-spacing-20260924.md). Dragging any selected local message moves the homogeneous message group vertically; selected lifeline headers move the homogeneous lane group horizontally. Full membership/primary and original rendered origins are captured. One combined validated transaction preserves semantic order, unselected records and other views. Unsupported/mixed/fallback sets refuse whole; stationary clicks still collapse. Off-axis/no-op/cancel preserve selection/history, and stale/ABA input is rejected. This is ordinary Saved presentation movement; semantic reorder and aggregate removal remain required. Windows Scenario regression filter: **289 passed / 0 failed / 1 ignored at 67534ce4**. Subsequent changes are independently reviewed numerically equivalent test annotations and UI text only; the 289 tests were not executed at final8d6. Final8d6 format, strict desktop all-target Clippy, Studio+CLI builds pass; all ten captured gate runs have811 unchanged inputs and exact source proofs. Earlier Scenario and Clippy failures remain preserved. Native final8d6: two normal exits0, empty logs,67 captures. Nonprimary message anchor moves both selected messages+24Y; nonprimary lane anchor moves both selected lanes+32X. One Undo/Redo per group, off-axis no-op preserving Redo, mixed body/header refusals and stationary collapse, outside-canvas cancel, A/B navigation and fresh-process reopen pass. Nine run1 saved snapshots plus one reopened saved snapshot satisfy exact whole-source phases (only exact decimal spelling flexibility at four predeclared changed A coordinates). Native selection used contextual Add; Shift remains mounted-test evidence. Existing ellipsized labels and Beta label backing interrupting a short Archive lifeline segment are explicitly documented visual limitations; broad GUI/accessibility acceptance is not claimed. [Portable evidence and review](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/53817298698cadb35c9bbd745e934ff3416cceee/harness/scenario-group-spacing-evidence-20260924/README.md): checks ZIP12,897,498 bytes SHA256 `d3de224502a2b7f8236d2ad82af6d6c57bb3a349468aebeea7369c3c3c267342`; native ZIP6,069,072 bytes SHA256 `27e0e189053fdfdbfcecd8c91ae718849448b090aab557afc7d9445af1ceaba8`. Both offline verifiers and13 exact staged files pass. Independent delivery audit found no material discrepancy. Fresh Gitea downloads of both archives, report, index and review match committed bytes. This remains branch-specific and outside delivered #37; no combined integration/release or #29 closure. I retain Scenario/removal ownership. Next bounded outcome: compare an explicit semantic destination chooser plus before/after order preview with a labelled group drag handle, reuse the existing exact sibling-block planner, and prove destination reachability/comprehension even when Saved Y differs from semantic order. No UI choice accepted merely from this design comparison. Windows Gitea read/write/push/download access works; WSL networking is not established and Linux remains excluded by the user.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root — next retained Scenario checkpoint is published and remote-ref-verified at a16e014049 on codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924. Experiment, decision and implementation boundary. Tested source cae7a22297; subsequent commit adds records only.

Actual production layout/picker experiments confirm an important counterexample: two semantically valid Saved before-slots can share Y while presentation remains Ready. The current nearest-Y picker cannot choose one of those identities. Reversing a deterministic tie winner merely hides the other. We therefore reject unchanged nearest-Y-only dragging as the sole complete semantic group destination method. Exact identity choice, a semantic order strip or explicit disambiguation is required. This does not accept chooser UX or reject every possible graphical drag design. Crossed, subpixel-close and fixed-viewport offscreen cases retain their narrower documented conclusions.

A shared immutable reorder session now captures full Context/Snapshot/token, admits the entire actually rendered set before planner no-op, keeps one current exact-Slot proposal, distinguishes semantic outcome from requested-view Ready/Fallback/Unavailable status, and consumes exact inputs before returning a command. Full-scene-per-destination caching was rejected for unbounded retained geometry. The Session and experiments are test-only (cfg(test)) pending the App adapter; no new user command is enabled. Tests cover nonempty saved layouts, literal whole-model changes, temporal refusal replacing a prior valid proposal, current-Slot cache reuse, explicit destination/no-op and selection-generation ABA.

Windows GNU/LLVM focused reorder_ filter passed 22/0/0, including all five new session and four slot experiment functions plus thirteen existing matches; 1,573 filtered. Format and strict all-target desktop Clippy pass. All three runs have 814 unchanged inputs proven against exact Git blobs. Portable evidence and independent review: ZIP 3,244,466 bytes, SHA256 b713a5c8c03f4cb4f4a6884bde7eb081fca00d1f5ebf85427ce14bc03acae166; 3 runs, 3 proofs, 1 source capsule. Parent and independent offline/raw audits pass; all 12 staged record files matched exact bytes. Fresh Gitea downloads of archive/report/policy/index/review match committed bytes. No native/new release/full-suite claim.

I retain Scenario semantic reorder and aggregate removal ownership. Next concrete dependency is a built App adapter with visible exact destination + before/after semantic preview, early current-session admission, terminal retirement on refusal/source failure, one Document transaction, keyboard cancellation and bounded destination discovery. Compare direct graphical access using explicit identity/disambiguation; ordinary body/header spacing keeps its delivered meaning. Native repeated-name/20-sibling/compact-window workflows and Ready-to-degraded commit policy remain required, as do removal and full #29 acceptance. #37 stays unchanged; Linux remains user-paused.

Codex-9e8r6t /root — next retained Scenario checkpoint is published and remote-ref-verified at **a16e014049aff09879eecdf280ad02941e5f8588** on `codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924`. [Experiment, decision and implementation boundary](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/a16e014049aff09879eecdf280ad02941e5f8588/harness/scenario-reorder-interaction-20260924.md). Tested source **cae7a22297d09810c412dbdf4ce5d8a28164b247**; subsequent commit adds records only. Actual production layout/picker experiments confirm an important counterexample: two semantically valid Saved before-slots can share Y while presentation remains Ready. The current nearest-Y picker cannot choose one of those identities. Reversing a deterministic tie winner merely hides the other. We therefore reject unchanged nearest-Y-only dragging as the sole complete semantic group destination method. Exact identity choice, a semantic order strip or explicit disambiguation is required. This does not accept chooser UX or reject every possible graphical drag design. Crossed, subpixel-close and fixed-viewport offscreen cases retain their narrower documented conclusions. A shared immutable reorder session now captures full Context/Snapshot/token, admits the entire actually rendered set before planner no-op, keeps one current exact-Slot proposal, distinguishes semantic outcome from requested-view Ready/Fallback/Unavailable status, and consumes exact inputs before returning a command. Full-scene-per-destination caching was rejected for unbounded retained geometry. The Session and experiments are **test-only (`cfg(test)`)** pending the App adapter; no new user command is enabled. Tests cover nonempty saved layouts, literal whole-model changes, temporal refusal replacing a prior valid proposal, current-Slot cache reuse, explicit destination/no-op and selection-generation ABA. Windows GNU/LLVM focused `reorder_` filter passed **22/0/0**, including all five new session and four slot experiment functions plus thirteen existing matches; 1,573 filtered. Format and strict all-target desktop Clippy pass. All three runs have 814 unchanged inputs proven against exact Git blobs. [Portable evidence and independent review](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/a16e014049aff09879eecdf280ad02941e5f8588/harness/scenario-reorder-interaction-evidence-20260924/README.md): ZIP 3,244,466 bytes, SHA256 `b713a5c8c03f4cb4f4a6884bde7eb081fca00d1f5ebf85427ce14bc03acae166`; 3 runs, 3 proofs, 1 source capsule. Parent and independent offline/raw audits pass; all 12 staged record files matched exact bytes. Fresh Gitea downloads of archive/report/policy/index/review match committed bytes. No native/new release/full-suite claim. I retain Scenario semantic reorder and aggregate removal ownership. Next concrete dependency is a built App adapter with visible exact destination + before/after semantic preview, early current-session admission, terminal retirement on refusal/source failure, one Document transaction, keyboard cancellation and bounded destination discovery. Compare direct graphical access using explicit identity/disambiguation; ordinary body/header spacing keeps its delivered meaning. Native repeated-name/20-sibling/compact-window workflows and Ready-to-degraded commit policy remain required, as do removal and full #29 acceptance. #37 stays unchanged; Linux remains user-paused.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root — retained Scenario scope checkpoint. Source is pushed and remote-ref-verified at 14df924b98 on codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924; this is still outside delivered #37 and is not native/release acceptance.

The exact destination chooser and App adapter are now production-wired: whole captured selection, same-parent stable block, bounded alias/name/position search, before/after semantic neighborhoods, explicit proposal-bound Apply, persistent context-bound result with full aliases, one Document transaction and retained selection. Saved body/header spacing keeps its existing meaning. Enter previews a unique search match; Ctrl+Enter explicitly applies the displayed exact proposal; Escape cancels. Review corrections cover canvas pre-handler interference, same-batch picker priority, and a delayed old focus task blurring a new chooser.

Windows GNU/LLVM Scenario gate at 04485e0017 passed 310/0/1 existing ignored timing diagnostic, including all twelve new App/mounted tests; strict desktop all-target Clippy passed at that source. Exact817-input proofs are locally retained. Current14df changes only summary label shortening to the existing grapheme-safe helper; format passes and its Scenario rerun is running. Earlier compile failures and incorrect fixture assumptions remain in history/raw records. Same-parent source permutations preserve original chunks/trivia and byte count, so the attempted byte-budget error oracle was invalid; real App source-write failure coverage remains an explicit gap, not a passing claim.

Next within existing ownership: final Windows build, actual native repeated-name/tied-destination/compact-window/keyboard workflows, exact saved-source/Undo/Redo/reopen checks, then publish portable verification and the final report. Current raw logs/review/native fixture preparation are local-only until that delivery. No aggregate removal, integrated acceptance, issue closure, Linux or new prerelease claim.

Codex-9e8r6t /root — retained Scenario scope checkpoint. Source is pushed and remote-ref-verified at 14df924b98d74144c1e40fbe7098994ff5eb2e94 on codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924; this is still outside delivered #37 and is not native/release acceptance. The exact destination chooser and App adapter are now production-wired: whole captured selection, same-parent stable block, bounded alias/name/position search, before/after semantic neighborhoods, explicit proposal-bound Apply, persistent context-bound result with full aliases, one Document transaction and retained selection. Saved body/header spacing keeps its existing meaning. Enter previews a unique search match; Ctrl+Enter explicitly applies the displayed exact proposal; Escape cancels. Review corrections cover canvas pre-handler interference, same-batch picker priority, and a delayed old focus task blurring a new chooser. Windows GNU/LLVM Scenario gate at 04485e001798430fb1b2e8d1347e6bde51e6e7a1 passed 310/0/1 existing ignored timing diagnostic, including all twelve new App/mounted tests; strict desktop all-target Clippy passed at that source. Exact817-input proofs are locally retained. Current14df changes only summary label shortening to the existing grapheme-safe helper; format passes and its Scenario rerun is running. Earlier compile failures and incorrect fixture assumptions remain in history/raw records. Same-parent source permutations preserve original chunks/trivia and byte count, so the attempted byte-budget error oracle was invalid; real App source-write failure coverage remains an explicit gap, not a passing claim. Next within existing ownership: final Windows build, actual native repeated-name/tied-destination/compact-window/keyboard workflows, exact saved-source/Undo/Redo/reopen checks, then publish portable verification and the final report. Current raw logs/review/native fixture preparation are local-only until that delivery. No aggregate removal, integrated acceptance, issue closure, Linux or new prerelease claim.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root — native trial found and corrected concrete Scenario reorder UI defects. Source is pushed and remote-ref-verified at 1c4099a9ef on codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924. Windows Scenario gate now passes 315/0/1 existing ignored diagnostic; format passes; exact818-input proofs retained locally. Strict Clippy/current GUI build are running.

Native run1 at14df demonstrated distinct alias-based BeforeB/BeforeC previews despite equal saved Y, Enter with no default destination, Escape/explicit Cancel, Ctrl+Enter commit, retained two-member selection/primary, and one Undo/Redo. It exposed floating-scrollbar text clipping and immediate loss of result summary when new spacing notices resized the viewport. Corrected source reserves a scrollbar gutter/wraps labels, keeps summary across benign geometry epochs while checking document/view/selection, and clears it immediately after a subsequent spacing transaction. Four lifecycle and one mounted layout regressions pass. Explicit Cancel feedback and alias-based saved-order notices are clearer.

Run1 is not accepted: its original full-source oracle assumed canonical whitespace. Actual source differed only inside steps because the established writer moves leading trivia with reference identity; order B,A,D,C and every other source byte were preserved. OneUndo matched baseline all12764 bytes; Redo matched committed result. Original failed receipts remain unchanged. Separate exact oracle-v2 matches actual beforeC bytes; no whitespace-ignore rule. Normal native exit0, empty logs. New-source native verification, portable evidence/report delivery and independent final review remain pending. #37 unchanged, aggregate removal not complete, Linux remains paused.

Codex-9e8r6t /root — native trial found and corrected concrete Scenario reorder UI defects. Source is pushed and remote-ref-verified at 1c4099a9ef76dd28d17ef892e95edf89e860569f on codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924. Windows Scenario gate now passes 315/0/1 existing ignored diagnostic; format passes; exact818-input proofs retained locally. Strict Clippy/current GUI build are running. Native run1 at14df demonstrated distinct alias-based BeforeB/BeforeC previews despite equal saved Y, Enter with no default destination, Escape/explicit Cancel, Ctrl+Enter commit, retained two-member selection/primary, and one Undo/Redo. It exposed floating-scrollbar text clipping and immediate loss of result summary when new spacing notices resized the viewport. Corrected source reserves a scrollbar gutter/wraps labels, keeps summary across benign geometry epochs while checking document/view/selection, and clears it immediately after a subsequent spacing transaction. Four lifecycle and one mounted layout regressions pass. Explicit Cancel feedback and alias-based saved-order notices are clearer. Run1 is not accepted: its original full-source oracle assumed canonical whitespace. Actual source differed only inside steps because the established writer moves leading trivia with reference identity; order B,A,D,C and every other source byte were preserved. OneUndo matched baseline all12764 bytes; Redo matched committed result. Original failed receipts remain unchanged. Separate exact oracle-v2 matches actual beforeC bytes; no whitespace-ignore rule. Normal native exit0, empty logs. New-source native verification, portable evidence/report delivery and independent final review remain pending. #37 unchanged, aggregate removal not complete, Linux remains paused.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root — Scenario semantic reorder App checkpoint is delivered at cdd5a0462b, pushed and remote-ref-verified on codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924. Tested production source is 1c4099a9ef; delivery descendant adds records only. Implementation and scoped verification, portable evidence, commands and final audit.

The exact same-parent destination chooser moves the complete captured group in original semantic order, independently of primary/click order. Full-name/alias/position search and paging reach tied-Y and offscreen destinations; explicit proposal-bound Apply changes one parent sequence in one Document transaction. Saved positions and unrelated views remain unchanged. Enter previews a unique match, Ctrl+Enter applies, Escape cancels. Preview text now reserves the scrollbar gutter; a context/selection-bound result summary survives diagnostic viewport resizing and retires after substantive edits, including subsequent spacing. Ordinary body/header group spacing retains its delivered meaning.

Final Windows GNU/LLVM Rust/Cargo1.98.1 gates: Scenario filter 315 passed / 0 failed / 1 existing ignored timing diagnostic, including all17 App tests; formatting, strict desktop all-target Clippy and Studio+CLI builds pass. All four final gates have exact818-input source proofs. The portable checks retain all17 attempts and five failures. No full desktop-suite claim; a real App source-write-failure fixture remains an explicit runtime coverage gap.

Native corrected-source run2 (78 captures) verifies repeated-name/tied and distant destinations, readable preview/footer/results at1605×872 and1104×732, no implicit destination, keyboard entry/query/Apply/Escape, exact one Undo, Cancel+selected-anchor no-op preserving Redo, and retained count2/primaryA. Six full-source snapshots exactly match separately pinned v2 expectations; no normalization. Fresh-process run3 (15 captures) reopens run2's final saved source, displays persisted ordinals, and saves exactly the same12764 bytes. Both normal exits0, empty logs, unchanged immutable inputs. Original run1 remains unaccepted with its original failed whitespace oracle and UI findings preserved. Native selection used contextual Add, not demonstrated Shift-click; long F6/six-reverse-Tab entry is a discoverability limitation. Native fallback/source-error and broad accessibility acceptance are not claimed.

Checks ZIP29,229,448 bytes SHA256 80406d81e0a5d47bea2ef284bc50a079713d828e8ea291cb96cfcedfeaa16235; native ZIP12,792,711 bytes SHA256 0686d691a6ecea80310c5ee31056de36a7389d89a41ca501e6db9427f1ba4a82. Both offline verifiers and independent raw-member audits pass; original failures remain explicit. All14 staged delivery files matched exact bytes, and fresh authenticated Gitea downloads of every delivery file match committed/local bytes. Executable/DLL pins are retained, but the evidence ZIP is not a runnable release.

This is branch-specific, outside the delivered #37 prerelease; no integrated/release acceptance or issue closure. Aggregate removal remains required and retained by this session. Next bounded outcome: reconcile shared whole-selection removal/dependency policy with current Scenario targets, close primary-only deletion paths, then implement one atomic previewed group removal with exact source/history/selection verification. Current Windows Gitea read/write/push/download networking works; WSL networking is not established here and Linux builds/checks remain user-paused.

Codex-9e8r6t /root — Scenario semantic reorder App checkpoint is delivered at **cdd5a0462b2fe97c6b8db3f30459cdb93f693089**, pushed and remote-ref-verified on `codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924`. Tested production source is **1c4099a9ef76dd28d17ef892e95edf89e860569f**; delivery descendant adds records only. [Implementation and scoped verification](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/cdd5a0462b2fe97c6b8db3f30459cdb93f693089/harness/scenario-reorder-app-20260924.md), [portable evidence, commands and final audit](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/cdd5a0462b2fe97c6b8db3f30459cdb93f693089/harness/scenario-reorder-app-evidence-20260924/README.md). The exact same-parent destination chooser moves the complete captured group in original semantic order, independently of primary/click order. Full-name/alias/position search and paging reach tied-Y and offscreen destinations; explicit proposal-bound Apply changes one parent sequence in one Document transaction. Saved positions and unrelated views remain unchanged. Enter previews a unique match, Ctrl+Enter applies, Escape cancels. Preview text now reserves the scrollbar gutter; a context/selection-bound result summary survives diagnostic viewport resizing and retires after substantive edits, including subsequent spacing. Ordinary body/header group spacing retains its delivered meaning. Final Windows GNU/LLVM Rust/Cargo1.98.1 gates: Scenario filter **315 passed / 0 failed / 1 existing ignored timing diagnostic**, including all17 App tests; formatting, strict desktop all-target Clippy and Studio+CLI builds pass. All four final gates have exact818-input source proofs. The portable checks retain all17 attempts and five failures. No full desktop-suite claim; a real App source-write-failure fixture remains an explicit runtime coverage gap. Native corrected-source run2 (78 captures) verifies repeated-name/tied and distant destinations, readable preview/footer/results at1605×872 and1104×732, no implicit destination, keyboard entry/query/Apply/Escape, exact one Undo, Cancel+selected-anchor no-op preserving Redo, and retained count2/primaryA. Six full-source snapshots exactly match separately pinned v2 expectations; no normalization. Fresh-process run3 (15 captures) reopens run2's final saved source, displays persisted ordinals, and saves exactly the same12764 bytes. Both normal exits0, empty logs, unchanged immutable inputs. Original run1 remains unaccepted with its original failed whitespace oracle and UI findings preserved. Native selection used contextual Add, not demonstrated Shift-click; long F6/six-reverse-Tab entry is a discoverability limitation. Native fallback/source-error and broad accessibility acceptance are not claimed. Checks ZIP29,229,448 bytes SHA256 `80406d81e0a5d47bea2ef284bc50a079713d828e8ea291cb96cfcedfeaa16235`; native ZIP12,792,711 bytes SHA256 `0686d691a6ecea80310c5ee31056de36a7389d89a41ca501e6db9427f1ba4a82`. Both offline verifiers and independent raw-member audits pass; original failures remain explicit. All14 staged delivery files matched exact bytes, and fresh authenticated Gitea downloads of every delivery file match committed/local bytes. Executable/DLL pins are retained, but the evidence ZIP is not a runnable release. This is branch-specific, outside the delivered #37 prerelease; no integrated/release acceptance or issue closure. Aggregate removal remains required and retained by this session. Next bounded outcome: reconcile shared whole-selection removal/dependency policy with current Scenario targets, close primary-only deletion paths, then implement one atomic previewed group removal with exact source/history/selection verification. Current Windows Gitea read/write/push/download networking works; WSL networking is not established here and Linux builds/checks remain user-paused.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root — continuing retained Scenario aggregate removal scope after delivered cdd5a046 checkpoint, same remote branch codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924. Current AGENTS matches remote main e76647f; worktree clean. Acceptance for this increment: complete exact visible local selection admitted without primary-only fallback; one aggregate impact preview and one atomic Document transaction; local occurrences/participants removed with existing dependency semantics and reused definitions preserved; stale/cancel/refusal leave exact source, history and selection unchanged; successful removal, one Undo/Redo and persistence verified. Mapping reusable union planner and all App input paths before implementation, with independent semantic review. No overlap claim outside Scenario; no new release/Linux acceptance.

Codex-9e8r6t /root — continuing retained Scenario aggregate removal scope after delivered cdd5a046 checkpoint, same remote branch `codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924`. Current AGENTS matches remote main e76647f; worktree clean. Acceptance for this increment: complete exact visible local selection admitted without primary-only fallback; one aggregate impact preview and one atomic Document transaction; local occurrences/participants removed with existing dependency semantics and reused definitions preserved; stale/cancel/refusal leave exact source, history and selection unchanged; successful removal, one Undo/Redo and persistence verified. Mapping reusable union planner and all App input paths before implementation, with independent semantic review. No overlap claim outside Scenario; no new release/Linux acceptance.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root — Scenario aggregate removal source is pushed and remote-ref-verified at 43340b94a1 on codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924. Policy. This remains outside delivered #37 and is not native/integrated acceptance.

Complete exact visible Scenario groups now have a captured Remove control/menu/Delete route, searchable paged aggregate impact review, token-bound cancellation/confirmation and one atomic Document Batch. Admission includes all original targets before collapsing selected ancestors; cross-parent local occurrences and participant/occurrence mixtures have one local removal meaning. Actual deleted and changed surviving records are reviewed, including cleared references and saved-layout pruning; reusable definitions stay intact. Stale singleton commands remain refused; stale modal packets cannot disturb newer reviews. Success clears removed transient selection and returns inspection to Scenario; one model/source Undo restores the change.

At this exact source on Windows GNU/LLVM Rust1.98.1: Scenario333 passed/0 failed/1 existing ignored timing diagnostic; removal53/0; format and strict desktop all-target Clippy pass. All four closed current gates have823-input unchanged/source proofs locally. The first compiler-import failure, two incorrect test assumptions and oversized-event Clippy failure remain retained; no failed attempt relabeled. Independent planner/adapter source review found no blocker; GUI build is running. Native repeated-name mixed participant/message review, exact saved-source/history/reopen, and portable evidence publication remain next. Real App source-write-failure coverage remains a stated gap.

Connectivity: Windows Gitea reads/push work. Ubuntu-26.04 starts, but the attempted WSL curl to https://index.crates.io/config.json failed with DNS resolving timeout after10s. No Linux build/check attempted; user pause preserved.

Codex-9e8r6t /root — Scenario aggregate removal source is pushed and remote-ref-verified at 43340b94a13f192c3b5d3c3112dbe87246790a44 on `codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924`. [Policy](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/43340b94a13f192c3b5d3c3112dbe87246790a44/harness/scenario-group-removal-policy-20260925.md). This remains outside delivered #37 and is not native/integrated acceptance. Complete exact visible Scenario groups now have a captured Remove control/menu/Delete route, searchable paged aggregate impact review, token-bound cancellation/confirmation and one atomic Document Batch. Admission includes all original targets before collapsing selected ancestors; cross-parent local occurrences and participant/occurrence mixtures have one local removal meaning. Actual deleted and changed surviving records are reviewed, including cleared references and saved-layout pruning; reusable definitions stay intact. Stale singleton commands remain refused; stale modal packets cannot disturb newer reviews. Success clears removed transient selection and returns inspection to Scenario; one model/source Undo restores the change. At this exact source on Windows GNU/LLVM Rust1.98.1: Scenario333 passed/0 failed/1 existing ignored timing diagnostic; removal53/0; format and strict desktop all-target Clippy pass. All four closed current gates have823-input unchanged/source proofs locally. The first compiler-import failure, two incorrect test assumptions and oversized-event Clippy failure remain retained; no failed attempt relabeled. Independent planner/adapter source review found no blocker; GUI build is running. Native repeated-name mixed participant/message review, exact saved-source/history/reopen, and portable evidence publication remain next. Real App source-write-failure coverage remains a stated gap. Connectivity: Windows Gitea reads/push work. Ubuntu-26.04 starts, but the attempted WSL curl to https://index.crates.io/config.json failed with DNS resolving timeout after10s. No Linux build/check attempted; user pause preserved.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root — user reports Gitea server disk recovery. Retained issue29 work continues on codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924. Pending verified checkpoints through 8688faf8c5 are currently local-only; I am retrying publication and will report exact remote confirmation separately.

Since last successful comment1328: Scenario aggregate removal native/source-budget acceptance and Process group-removal App/native/compact review were completed locally with portable records. Latest saved Architecture/State pure planner source7750ecd7 is test-gated and passes12Windows tests, format, strictdesktopalltargetClippy with835input sourceproofs; records8688faf8. No completed saved-view UI claim.

Current uncommitted work wires saved-view explicit model deletion (Hide/plainDelete retained): shared ordinary/State input lifetime for queued native batches, complete stored and derived reused-Process impact, token-bound aggregate review and one atomic Document source/history transaction. Acceptance still requires App and native verification; no integration/release/issue37 modification or Linux build. Scope remains this session's retained aggregate-removal work.

Codex-9e8r6t /root — user reports Gitea server disk recovery. Retained issue29 work continues on codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924. Pending verified checkpoints through 8688faf8c558ade7dd1a7119c00f158fd4c88a23 are currently local-only; I am retrying publication and will report exact remote confirmation separately. Since last successful comment1328: Scenario aggregate removal native/source-budget acceptance and Process group-removal App/native/compact review were completed locally with portable records. Latest saved Architecture/State pure planner source7750ecd7 is test-gated and passes12Windows tests, format, strictdesktopalltargetClippy with835input sourceproofs; records8688faf8. No completed saved-view UI claim. Current uncommitted work wires saved-view explicit model deletion (Hide/plainDelete retained): shared ordinary/State input lifetime for queued native batches, complete stored and derived reused-Process impact, token-bound aggregate review and one atomic Document source/history transaction. Acceptance still requires App and native verification; no integration/release/issue37 modification or Linux build. Scope remains this session's retained aggregate-removal work.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root — publication recovered. Verified checkpoints are now pushed at 8688faf8c5 on codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924. Fresh remote ref matches; authenticated downloads of all 73 delivered record/evidence files match exact committed and local bytes. Current uncommitted saved-view App work is excluded.

Delivered branch records:

All reports link portable evidence and reproducible checks. Independent source/native/package reviews retain their actual scope; evidence archives omit executables and are not runnable releases. No full desktop suite, broad accessibility, native Shift-click, new integration/release or issue closure claimed. Linux remains excluded per user instruction. Next retained work is saved-view input lifetime + derived Process impact + App confirmation/source/history/native acceptance as recorded in comment1332.

Codex-9e8r6t /root — publication recovered. Verified checkpoints are now pushed at **8688faf8c558ade7dd1a7119c00f158fd4c88a23** on `codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924`. Fresh remote ref matches; authenticated downloads of all **73** delivered record/evidence files match exact committed and local bytes. Current uncommitted saved-view App work is excluded. Delivered branch records: - [Scenario aggregate removal](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/8688faf8c558ade7dd1a7119c00f158fd4c88a23/harness/scenario-group-removal-app-20260925.md) and [keyboard/genuine source-budget failure follow-up](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/8688faf8c558ade7dd1a7119c00f158fd4c88a23/harness/scenario-removal-followup-20260925.md). - [Process atomic group removal](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/8688faf8c558ade7dd1a7119c00f158fd4c88a23/harness/process-group-removal-app-20260925.md) and [1102×732 compact native verification](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/8688faf8c558ade7dd1a7119c00f158fd4c88a23/harness/process-removal-compact-20260925.md). Tested production source572e96ba; earlier broader187-test pass belongs to d93c0a80. Native exact source, one Undo/Redo and fresh reopen evidence and all failed attempts are preserved with scoped claims. - [Saved Architecture/State pure planner foundation](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/8688faf8c558ade7dd1a7119c00f158fd4c88a23/harness/saved-group-removal-foundation-20260925.md): source7750ecd7,12/0 tests, format and strictClippy pass,835-input source proofs. Test-gated only at this checkpoint; no saved-model deletion UI claim. All reports link portable evidence and reproducible checks. Independent source/native/package reviews retain their actual scope; evidence archives omit executables and are not runnable releases. No full desktop suite, broad accessibility, native Shift-click, new integration/release or issue closure claimed. Linux remains excluded per user instruction. Next retained work is saved-view input lifetime + derived Process impact + App confirmation/source/history/native acceptance as recorded in comment1332.
Collaborator

Codex-9e8r6t /root — saved and published immediately at the user's explicit instruction to STOP. Checkpoint d8db66080d is pushed on codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924; exact remote ref confirmed and working tree clean. Source fa9d89efad. Checkpoint report and remaining verification.

Saved Architecture/State explicit group model deletion is wired with whole-selection review, input lifetime checks, derived Process impact, and one Document transaction. Final verification is UNFINISHED. Last completed bounded regression gate at b137d457: 270 passed, 3 failed, 0 ignored. The final source corrects expired-menu retirement, noneditable Scenario gesture cancellation, and the outdated State Shift+Delete expectation; these corrections have NOT passed their rerun. The final strict Clippy process tree was terminated at the user's instruction (exit 4294967295); subsequent tests/format did not start. No check is intentionally left running.

Raw records/source capsules retain all five attempts, including failures and interrupted lint. ZIP 16,522,133 bytes; SHA256 d97ed023dcb53b962040420e7b08f7ac3c3df8c1d9481e0908d07c94b65ef6ae. Hash manifest is adjacent. Raw checkpoint package, not independently audited acceptance evidence.

When the user resumes: run cargo test -p oa-desktop --message-format=json -- removal multiselect focus state_canvas direct_canvas_tests --test-threads=1, strict desktop all-target Clippy and fmt; then fresh independent review and native saved-view acceptance. Native compact mixed selection/review/save/Undo/Redo/reopen and genuine saved-App source-failure coverage remain gaps. No default-branch integration, runnable release, issue closure, Linux check or #37 change claimed. Work is paused by the user; I am stopping now and will not select another task.

Codex-9e8r6t /root — saved and published immediately at the user's explicit instruction to STOP. Checkpoint **d8db66080d919bc1e9cb269ec46cc14935a33f45** is pushed on `codex/scenario-multiselect-9e8r6t-20260924`; exact remote ref confirmed and working tree clean. Source **fa9d89efad052d9f5591ac4f8b72d18db4ca58ed**. [Checkpoint report and remaining verification](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/d8db66080d919bc1e9cb269ec46cc14935a33f45/harness/saved-group-removal-app-20260925.md). Saved Architecture/State explicit group model deletion is wired with whole-selection review, input lifetime checks, derived Process impact, and one Document transaction. Final verification is UNFINISHED. Last completed bounded regression gate at b137d457: 270 passed, 3 failed, 0 ignored. The final source corrects expired-menu retirement, noneditable Scenario gesture cancellation, and the outdated State Shift+Delete expectation; these corrections have NOT passed their rerun. The final strict Clippy process tree was terminated at the user's instruction (exit 4294967295); subsequent tests/format did not start. No check is intentionally left running. [Raw records/source capsules](http://217.177.34.108:3000/sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio/src/commit/d8db66080d919bc1e9cb269ec46cc14935a33f45/harness/saved-group-removal-app-evidence-20260925/interrupted-checkpoint.zip) retain all five attempts, including failures and interrupted lint. ZIP 16,522,133 bytes; SHA256 d97ed023dcb53b962040420e7b08f7ac3c3df8c1d9481e0908d07c94b65ef6ae. Hash manifest is adjacent. Raw checkpoint package, not independently audited acceptance evidence. When the user resumes: run `cargo test -p oa-desktop --message-format=json -- removal multiselect focus state_canvas direct_canvas_tests --test-threads=1`, strict desktop all-target Clippy and fmt; then fresh independent review and native saved-view acceptance. Native compact mixed selection/review/save/Undo/Redo/reopen and genuine saved-App source-failure coverage remain gaps. No default-branch integration, runnable release, issue closure, Linux check or #37 change claimed. Work is paused by the user; I am stopping now and will not select another task.
Sign in to join this conversation.
No labels
2 Participants
Notifications
Due Date
No due date set.
Dependencies

No dependencies set.

Reference: sorokin.oleg.edu/ARCADIA-Studio#29