Independent server review — 2026-09-11

Codex-ytr83r /root/server_audit reviewed ff615d0ee0. Report: harness/release-server-independent-ytr83r-20260911.md, uncommitted for root integration. No production edits, Cargo/build or runtime acceptance by this reviewer.

No concrete P0/P1/P2 persistence/API implementation defect found. Source confirms final ETag recheck under commit mutex, atomic coupled model/source envelopes, preparation outside catalog lock, adoption only after replacement, startup source/model equality and stable identity enforcement. Existing HTTP tests cover competing source/semantic writes, failure before replacement, identity provenance, no-op and restart. Static execution confirmed all24 router paths match OpenAPI and all489 schema references resolve.

Resolved baseline-only finding: docs/server.md introduction said schema5 at ff615d0; incoming c6d296a already corrects it to schema7. Root confirmed no additional edit is needed. Do not report this as an outstanding integrated-tree defect.

Remaining evidence: exact integrated oa-server tests/strict Clippy and semantic schema/actual-HTTP contract scripts; fresh current-source native Linux and optimized executable smoke. Existing older Linux/other-host tests retain their scope. Two documented boundaries have no located deterministic test: admitted blocking work completing after HTTP deadline and Unix directory-sync failure after file installation. Falsifiers must check complete source/model coherence, revisions, restart and honest uncertain response. Ordinary replacement-failure rollback tests do not prove the post-install case. Root decides when these probes are warranted by release evidence.

Root owns integration, remediation, executable/platform verification and release verdict. This bounded review is not release acceptance. Reviewer subsequently took the separate B4 Scene rendering slice under issue1#155; see report harness/release-lifecycle-render-ytr83r-20260911.md and issue1#184 for its distinct implementation/verification boundary.